Boiled Quail and Cornmeal By the Yard . . PTFS 10/18

KCMiller

DIS Veteran
Joined
May 7, 2003
Messages
1,731
I'll be posting more detail in a bit, but I have to say, I was REALLY disappointed in this event. High end tasting menus? Really? Who thought it was a good idea to have two jambayalas, from two separate restaurants? And several polentas? And what in heavens name was that entertainment? And did anyone actually TASTE the food before they put it out? And if one more person had snarled at me when I asked if I could sit at their table, I was going to lose it.

I'm not usually a terribly picky person, but wow. I'm at the office right now, but I'll post the menu and my feelings about the choices (unlike what I had read on this board previously, the brochure they handed us on the way in DID list the menu items - which was good, because otherwise, there were several I would never have guessed just by taste...).

KC (who is usually more :sunny: than this review will sound!)
 
ok I am in.. I want to hear and see what happend! Sorry you didn't like it!
 
Sorry to hear that your experience wasn't a good one. There must have been something strange in the air that night from everything I've read about that PFTS so far.

We went on the 11th and while I didn't think PFTS this year was quite the experience it was last year, it was still fun and worth the price of admission. And people were exceptionally nice - we approached many people about sharing tables and they were all friendly and welcoming. We were the same when we had a table to share.

What a shame that so many Surly Joes had to be in attendance.

I look forward to your review and pictures! :thumbsup2
 

Sorry for the delay in posting this!

This is my review from the Party for the Senses, October 18, 2008. There were many wines, but I have to admit, although I enjoy wine, I really am no expert, and so most of the whole ‘subtle nuance’ was lost on me. I drank some, and then I switched to beer. I did get some yummy ice wine, but when I went back, it was all gone.

The easiest way to do this is to put my comments right after the menu item – bon appétit!

Robert Irvine, Former host of Dinner: Impossible
Horseradish crusted salmon with braised endive, beet reduction

Possibly the dullest piece of fish I’ve had in some time. How he managed to get the salmon to have no flavor at all past crumbs is beyond me. And it was falling apart. The endive with beet reduction tasted like slimy dirt. And he was unpleasant, on top of it all. Quite a let down. Nice forearms, though . . .

Kit Miller, Tusker House
Pomegranate marinated quail breast with spinach and quinoa salad, roasted fresh fig

I was totally unaware that ‘pomegranate marinated’ was some sort of chef code for boiled. Fascinating. Inedible, but fascinating.

Paul Pavlovic, Biergarten
Mediterranean polenta cakes with Roquefort and figs

Ah, the first polenta dish. It tasted like, um, cold cornmeal. With cheese crumbled on top, and figs. But not in a good way.

Tami McAdam, Edible Artistry
Fragrant Pork and Prawn Yum Cha dumplings with Traditional Asian dipping sauce

I think I would have enjoyed these had they been less nasty. Salty, like the Dead Sea. And traditional asian dipping sauce, as far as I can tell, is soy sauce with salt stirred in. Using the word ‘Yum’ in the title of this dish was mean.

Guy Grossi, Grossi Florentino
Wet Roast suckling lamb with herbs, breadcrumbs, Parmigiano-Reggiano and polenta

Nice lamb, properly cooked. And since the polenta was evidently fried in butter, I was happy. Everything is good when fried in butter.

Alphonso Walker, Artist Point
Marinated Muscovy Smoked Duck with Wild Mushroom Risotto, Port reduction

This was actually really tasty – my DS’s really liked the risotto. My duck was quacking rare, but I like it like that – it rather skeeved out one of my sibs, though.

International Cheese Selection
There was many, many cheeses. And honeycomb, and figs, and nuts – it was a buffet of little ‘doots’ of stuff to put on cheese. The cheese was good. It was cheese. Cheese is good. Except for Velveeta. But they didn’t have that kind. And I lied. Velveeta is good, too, for grilled cheese sandwiches. Mmm, cheese . . .

Kurt Fleischfresser, The Coach House
Herb seared buffalo with Red Chile Risotto cakes and Cilantro Remoulade

I like the meat very much - I didn’t try the risotto.

Nabi Saito, Tokyo Dining
Mimaki Chicken – Chicken breast roll with surimi and vegetables, demi-glace sauce

Really? Really? This was the best they could come up with? Boiled chicken wrapped around fake crab? I mean, the set up was pretty, kimonos and bowing as far as the eye could see, but, although pleasing to the eye, the dish was bland, bland, and cheap.

Andrea Born, Bakery, Hollywood Studios
Caramelized Pineapple Salsa with a coconut macaroon
Brule Pistacho cakes on Apricot confit
Chocolate Banana Cup with Salted Caramel

Three nice desserts. I heard. From my DS’s.

Noah French, Setai Hotel
Jasmine Milk-Chocolate cream with Matcha Green Tea Jaconde and 5 spice strudel

This was really, really delicious. And I’m not much of a dessert person.

A Collection of Chocolates
This made me laugh – the line was out the door for these, all night. Honestly people, it’s just chocolate. The few pieces I managed to get at the end of the night tasted just as nice as the Lindor truffles you can get at the register at Walmart.

Jude Theriot, Author of The 100 Greatest Cajun Recipes
Pork Jambayala with Eggplant Deborah

I don’t understand jambayala – my mom used to make Rice a Roni when I was a kid, and if she had tipped a bottle of Tabasco into it, that what this reminded me of. Mushy rice with way too much spice in it. The eggplant made absolutely no impression on me. I hope this wasn't one of the 100 best.

Ernie Haverkorn, Sci-Fi Dine-In
Cumin-rubbed Ahi Tuna with Manchego Corn Cake and Six pepper relish

They can call it a corn cake all they want, but it’s POLENTA again. The ahi looked so nice before they boiled it . . . I think the heat in the frying pan was too low, but the tuna turned gray. Ick.

Wing Cheung, The Grand Hyatt
Black Currant Mousse
Tapioca Jasmine Rice Cream Brulee
Chocolate Praline Rice Krispy Crunch

More nice desserts which my DS’s tried. Nothing fabulous, just OK.

Aidan Dwyer, Bakery, Yacht and Beach Club
Spiced Chiffon Cake with Pumpkin Ice Cream and Autumn Fruits

THIS was fabulous. Really, really tasty.

Amy Malik, 33 Liberty Restaurant
Sweet Potato Panna Cotta

OK, did you ever accidently eat Crisco? Or the last time you had a cold, and tried to eat pudding or jello, but you couldn’t taste anything? Yeah, this is worse. My DS came over with a gleam in her eye, and whispered ‘I have 6 sweet potato panna cottas in my bag’ – the wine glass bag. OK, so she was going to bring them back to the room to share with my DM and DD. So we though we’d better try them, before lugging them back to Pop Century (you would have though the fact that no one stopped her from loading up her bag with little bowls of panna cotta would have been our first clue). We took some fresh ones from the table, and sat down to try them. I’ve never laughed so hard in my life, and I don’t THINK it was the wine. Truly, imagine a solid glop of absolutely no flavor at all in your mouth. Then look at your sister having the same experience. It’s a wonder we all didn’t choke. I think ‘sweet potato panna cotta’ is going into the family lexicon as ‘something so inedible as to be funny to watch someone else try’ – sort of like Beverly.

Mikko Gruenzner and Richard Smich, Disney Special Events
Country Style Pheasant Sausage, braised red cabbage and applewood bacon Pierogi, Sun-dried cherry port wine sauce

This was awful. Oh, the sausage was ok – but I’ve had better at Bob Evans. But the pierogi was a real disappointment – I LOVE pierogi, and bacon, but it was just this sad little slimy piece of dough with no love.

Dean Max, 3030 Ocean Restaurant
Georges Band confit of Swordfish, Honey pickled Eggplant, Arugula, Basil Aioli

Oh, yum! The swordfish was worth going back for more of – it was poached in olive oil, and the sauce was divine.

Javier Pareja, Special Events, Y&B
Chile and spice rubbed Rib Eye, Mofongo Cake and Spicy Carrot, Chayote and Cucumber slaw

My sisters really liked this, and I think that saying ‘mofongo’ was a big part of their enjoyment.

Albert Riviello, Le Cellier
Slow roasted pork with Calvados sauce and apple fennel slaw

Dry. And as far as I could tell, the apple fennel slaw was just apples and fennel, chiffonade. Some tough job cooking that one, let me tell you . . .

Brett Hill, Jiko
Dark spice braised short rib with truffled sweet potatoes and Tomato-date jam

Incredibly delicious – I need the recipe for this one. The short ribs were succulent, and the truffled sweet potatoes – well, they redeemed the vegetable in my eyes, after the panna cotta incident (all I have to do is THINK panna cotta, and I start giggling).

John Malik, 33 Liberty Restaurant
Crayfish Jambayala with a cheddar crouton

More overspicy mushy rice. How special. Not. I think he’s related to the panna cotta lady – remind me not to eat at their house.

Jarrod Pearman, Special Events, Boardwalk
Guava glazed pork tenderloin with Poblano Chile relish and batata mash
Again, my DS’s liked this, but I think it was because they could say ‘batata’. It’s funny – go ahead, say it yourself. See?

Christian Rumpler, Rose and Crow
Herb marinated ostrich, crispy potatoes and bacon, mushroom ragout and horseradish pesto

Way too much going on here – 3 little dices of potato fighting for plate territory with some bacon, being ambushed from behind by what appears to be a mushroom dish, with a largish flap of meant (I can only assume it’s ostrich) over the top and sauce. Almost impossible to eat without sitting down, which was, as I mentioned in the first post, a dangerous endeavor. We were actually shooed away from a table by a scary woman wielding a dish of panna cotta. We fled.

Doug Turbush, Bluepointe Restaurant
Lemongrass and Black pepper shrimp with dried mango and coriander

Too spicy for me – I took one bite and put the plate down.

Axel Martin, Coral Reef
Goat Cheese and Portobello pot stickers with sweet and sour and red pepper coulis

Lordy, this was nasty on so many levels.

And I haven’t even talked about the entertainment, although the short version is 'whatever'. Weird techo music performed by a group of guys who were trying, I think, to look remote, but ended up looking vaguely pissed, and who could blame them? And who the heck costumed these guys? It looked like we were being entertained by rejects from the last Sci Fi Matrix convention – hey guys, your outfits are too lame to be at the convention, but we have a gig for you! Then they twirled stuff. Did no one think of maybe a nice 3 piece orchestra in the corner doing standards? And a dance floor – I think people would have enjoyed a dance floor. If only to work off the chocolate.

Next time, I’m going to buy a Mickey Bar and work my way around the F&W Festival – cheaper by far, less pretention, better food – and maybe a place to sit down! But I'd like to give a shout out to my three darling sisters, who made the evening so fun, and who, I hope, will enjoy my review! A good meal is a just good meal, but a bad meal is loads of funny stories to tell!

KC:sunny:
 
I really enjoyed your review...I too have read horror stories about this particular PFTS!

I was :rotfl: about your comment '...I think he’s related to the panna cotta lady – remind me not to eat at their house.'
 
Thanks - I'm left wondering what in heaven's name they'll serve for Thanksgiving :lmao: !

I'd love to hear other peoples reviews of this PTFS, or comments on my review!


KC:sunny:
 
Absolutely a gut-busting review ... thank you for posting it! :thumbsup2

I think my favorite comment of yours was that it was mean to use the word yum in the title of the dish prepared by Tami McAdam. :lmao:

The hubby and I are seriously considering skipping PFTS next Fall and booking a nice dinner somewhere instead. We enjoyed the one we attended this year, but it wasn't as good as the one we went to last year.
 
LOVED your review!! You definitely convinced me to stick to the booths!
 
Wonderful review! You were tough... "Possibly the dullest piece of fish I’ve had in some time" but fair "Nice forearms, though" ! :rotfl:

Sorry the event was rather disappointing, but it sounds like you and your sisters made it fun.

I'm still laughing about the duck comment: "it rather skeeved out one of my sibs, though." That would have sincerely skeeved me too! :scared1:
 
I was at the same event, ate most of the items reviewed, and only agree with one or two things. For the most part, I found the food good, and the wines were very good.

I did think some things were drenched in sauce (like the piece of buffalo I got) which ruined the dish for me. Of the two jambalayas, I liked the pork one best. It seemed like I had stuffing on my plate, but still, it tasted good. I didn't find anything wrong with the dumplings. Tami McAdam was probably the nicest, friendliest of the chefs there.

And the swordfish was not as amazing as reviewed. But I contribute that to the piece of swordfish I had at Jiko two days earlier.

I know there are hits and misses. Even among my group, there were some people that loved things I didn't. That's why our palates have to be the judge. We all did like the lamb and duck dishes, and I loved the uniqueness of the dessert this OP loved.

But I haven't gotten to my review of PFTS yet. I just barely got part of day 2 done. :laughing:
 
I was at the same event, ate most of the items reviewed, and only agree with one or two things. For the most part, I found the food good, and the wines were very good.

I did think some things were drenched in sauce (like the piece of buffalo I got) which ruined the dish for me. Of the two jambalayas, I liked the pork one best. It seemed like I had stuffing on my plate, but still, it tasted good. I didn't find anything wrong with the dumplings. Tami McAdam was probably the nicest, friendliest of the chefs there.

And the swordfish was not as amazing as reviewed. But I contribute that to the piece of swordfish I had at Jiko two days earlier.

I know there are hits and misses. Even among my group, there were some people that loved things I didn't. That's why our palates have to be the judge. We all did like the lamb and duck dishes, and I loved the uniqueness of the dessert this OP loved.

But I haven't gotten to my review of PFTS yet. I just barely got part of day 2 done. :laughing:

Well, I'm really looking forward to reading your review! I wonder if maybe next year, the mods can create a thread just for PFTS reviews - it's been difficult to find reviews embedded in multi day trips (but I keep looking :laughing: !)

(I edited this to say that d'oh! I did find the F&W review sticky. But I still think a thread just for PFTS reviews would be a good idea!)


KC:sunny:
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE







New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top