The first time my DM and I went to WDW (1998) we "stumbled" on the Boardwalk area. I hadn't done much research ahead of time and hadn't been at WDW since 1983. I had read a little about it at what was then Deb's Unofficial WDW Guide (now allearsnet.com) so I knew a little about it. We went there to walk around our first night at WDW (late afternoon flight) and I really liked the feel of the place. I can't really say why, it's just kinda cool to walk around. We also had our first TS meal that night at YC. I think we ate at Yacht Club Galley. It was a enjoyable meal and our server was very friendly. The only drawback was even though we rode one of the Friendships over from BW, by the time we finished eating, they had stopped running! Oh no, we had to walk all the way around-not really that big of a deal, but who knew?
One of the things I enjoyed, that they no longer do, was the seagull cries you used to be able to hear. Haven't heard them since that first trip.
Also, a few trips ago (Jan. 05) my DM, DD, and myself enjoyed a leisurely meal at the Spoodles window while seated outside in the cool January sunshine. It was a way to keep the Disney Magic going without going to a park that day. We sat there eating our pizza and salad and playing my DD's new Stitch Trouble game.
If it was just my DM and myself traveling, I would give Jellyrolls a try, but since DD7 can't go in, we don't.
Of course there is the Baordwalk Bakery, everything looks yummy, ESPN Cafe, Flying Fish, and Spoodles.