I saw the Orlando show in July and absolutely loved it. I had a chance to see the touring show with a friend in November. Personally, I enjoyed the Orlando show more, but it was completely new to me then. Also, in Orlando, I was able to spend the day at the Universal parks and eat lunch at Emeril's. I worked 8 hours the day of the touring show, and drove an hour each way to the performance. It shouldn't have made a difference, but it was nice seeing BMG while in a vacation frame of mind.
There are similarities in the shows, but they are not identical. The tour is more music oriented with a number of songs featuring vocalists. I don't want to spoil anything by saying too much about the overlap. I liked the more intimate feel of the theater in Orlando, but I'm glad I saw the tour version as well.