Personally, I wouldn't mind seeing pool hopping eliminated completely, especially if they're only going to allow it at the so-called desirable pools like BLT and SAB.
We own at BWV and usually choose to stay there. While I wouldn't mind being able to use SAB during our July trip, I totally respect the fact that it's limited to BC/YC guests. What annoys me is that as guests of the BW, just because of the nature of the boardwalk itself, the same strictness isn't applied at our resort. I would love to see rules put in place for EVERY
DVC that experiences an overflow from other guests, be it that they are reserved for members in general or for specific resort guests.
I bring this up based on our last two trips to the BWV, when we noticed two things: first, the number of people enjoying the pools (we have never had an issue finding a couple of chairs near one of the pools, but had a lot of trouble the past two trips - there just seemed like there were soooo many people) and secondly, the parking lot situation. We had a LOT of trouble finding parking in the lot in March (during ESPN weekend) and a couple of weeks ago, so on our walk from the lot towards the hotel during one afternoon (maybe 2:00 pm), we took notice of the passes in the windows - the majority of them (yes, MAJORITY) were not even BoardWalk guests. Of the ones we looked at (I'd say at least twenty between us) only 6 of them were BoardWalk Villas or Inn...the rest were Pop, Caribbean, Port Orleans...
I know that guests of other hotels will park there to visit the BoardWalk, but at 2:00 on a Monday afternoon, I highly doubt that's where most of them were. I've always heard that at Poly and CR, you are permitted to park if you have reservations to eat there, and that your pass expires like three hours after you enter. I don't know if that's true or not, but I do think a policy like that is necessary at any resort that has something more to offer to other guests - be it restaurants, savannahs, boardwalk, etc. - especially if a park is within walking (or even monorail) distance.
No offense to anyone!