Bitty Baby Question

We_love_WDW

DIS Veteran
Joined
Apr 9, 2009
Messages
714
Do you think a 5 year old is too old for this baby doll? How long did your daughter play with the bitty baby? My dd already has an American Girl doll and now wants the baby for Christmas. I am just thinking she might not play with it that much.
 
Do you think a 5 year old is too old for this baby doll? How long did your daughter play with the bitty baby? My dd already has an American Girl doll and now wants the baby for Christmas. I am just thinking she might not play with it that much.

I'm not familiar with these dolls (DGD is 12 now), but is it extremely expensive? Is there some other item she really wants within the same price range that you would get instead?

If it's not terribly expensive - and there's not something else she would be happy with as a substitute - I would buy it for her.. Little girls are little girls for such a short time.. :lovestruc I don't believe in rushing them through their childhoods based solely on age..

Good luck with whatever you decide..:goodvibes
 
My DD played with Bitty baby for longer and more than she played with Kit. DD is 16 and while she doesn't play with dolls anymore, she would not part with Bitty Baby or her stuff. It is all stored away for safe keeping. You can't go wrong with a Bitty Baby. I'm guessing she was played with until DD was probably 10 (?).

I think 5 is a great age for a Bitty Baby. I didn't let DD have an American Girl doll until she could read the books so Kit came when DD was 6. It was a big deal. She loved Kit but she still played with Bitty Baby more.
 
Personally I think that is a perfect age for it. She will be old enough to take good care of it. My DD played with hers for a while, and I ended up getting the Bitty Twins when she was 8 or 9 and she still played with them for a while. I say go for it. They are only little once, and kids today grow up way to fast. Cherish them playing with toys. Soon enough it will only be ipods & computers and video games. :rotfl2: Oh, and expensive boots!:lmao:
 

my dd is 6 and has 2 bittys, the bitty twins, and a just-like-me doll (she got that last christmas). She loves her bittys! but she is definitely getting more into the bigger dolls.

honestly I would get her bitty if she is asking for it. bonus is bitty is not all that expensive!
 
No and I think of all the AG dolls this was the one she played with the most!
 
Hate to admit how many AG dolls my DD has - but it's true Bitty was the forever doll - we STILL celebrate her birthday (night before Thanksgiving) because it reminds of us a special family year we shared with my parents (my Dad is gone now) Dolls are a great way to role play :thumbsup2

btw - Bitty turns 10 this year (her mama is 13) :laughing:
 
IDK if your dd is set on having that particular doll she may not be happy with any other doll, unless you start talking her out of it now. LOL

I saw the bitty baby day before yesterday for the first time in real life & I was disappointed - It was smaller than what I was thinking.

As far as my dd - she loves doing baby's hair - so of course a bitty baby would do us no good.
 
My dear cousins are 12, and 11 and still HUGE into baby doll play. They even have real strollers, basinettes, the whole shebang.
 
My DD never played with dolls until she got her AG dolls. She got some of the AG dolls first and then ended up getting both sets of Bitty Twins when she was in 3rd-4th grade or so. She played with them a lot until about 6th grade and every once in a while will pull them out and "change their clothes" even now :lmao:.
 
I'd get her any doll she wanted.

My dd11 has tons of dolls, and has gone through many stages with them. When she was a toddler, all her dolls were naked, and most had magic marker drawings on them.

She then 'graduated' to not scribbling on them, and occasionally dressing them, then putting them into the many adorable bunk beds I bought (trying to relive my own childhood!)

Funny story - she got a life size barbie (I think it was barbie) when she was about 6... it basically stood in the corner of her room untouched, until about 2 years later, when she and her girlfriend and my ds(who was 5 at the time) took all the clothes off the doll, detached the limbs and head off the doll, wrote all over the 'pieces' w/ black magic marker, and buried all the parts in our outside playset pea-gravel area. :eek:

I accidentally dug up the barbie head about a year later and had a heart attack! :lmao: I think pieces of her are still out there (dd is 11 now). Who knows what else the kids have buried in that pea gravel.

I had called the other mom at the time to warn her they all may be on the road to therapy! LOL!

My dd and her friends will still occasionally play "day car center" or "babysitter" with the dolls we have left, so even at 11yo, dolls can still be enjoyed.
 
My daughters are 11 and 10 and still play with dolls, and mostly their Bitty Babies! I know that I will blink and it will all go away, so I am enjoying every minute.
The things they play are very cute. The other day they pretended they were going overseas to adopt their Bitty Babies at an orphanage. I wanted to secretly video tape them.
They have always prefered baby dolls to Barbies, which is funny because I was obsessed with Barbies when I was their age!
 
my 7 year old DD has a Bitty Baby and a set of Bitty Twins and they are definitely her favorites. She got the BB when she was 3 and the BT when she was 5.
 
IDK if your dd is set on having that particular doll she may not be happy with any other doll, unless you start talking her out of it now. LOL

I absolutely agree with this! my dd had the bitty twins and a bitty baby and was insisting she wanted another bitty...one with darker "hair" than the one she had. I figured she would be fine with some new outfits for the bitty's she had. the whole week before christmas she kept talking about how santa was going to bring her the new bitty, then literally the day before christmas eve I just sat and watched her talk to her dolls and about the new baby that would be coming on christmas. she was 4, almost 5, then, and I could see she really had her heart set on it.

so guess where I was on christmas eve? yep, the american girl store. thankfully I have one nearby, and I was there at opening so it wasn't too bad. and it was totally worth it!
 
my 7 year old DD has a Bitty Baby and a set of Bitty Twins and they are definitely her favorites. She got the BB when she was 3 and the BT when she was 5.

DD7 loves her American girl dolls. Bitty Baby was her 1st from my grandmother and she still plays with her. Then she got the Bitty Twins from my MIL. Now she has a just like me ( from MIL) Kit from Santa and is getting Lanie from Xmas from my mom!
She really wants more nursery stuff for xmas, so I am getting her the high chair and maybe the diaper bag
 
Do you think a 5 year old is too old for this baby doll? How long did your daughter play with the bitty baby? My dd already has an American Girl doll and now wants the baby for Christmas. I am just thinking she might not play with it that much.

My DD played with Bitty Baby until she was 11 or 12 (of course she has a younger brother 7 years younger than her, and when he was little, we got them Bitty Baby Twins Boy/Girl, and they played them together, soooo cute:love:).

My daughter LOVED bitty baby forever, but never had any interest at all in the regular American Girl Dolls.
 
I was in 7th grade when I bought my bitty baby :rolleyes1

My friends and I loved playing with any kind of american girl dolls/barbies. They were very popular around here when I was in 7th grade.

five is the perfect age for a bitty baby!
 
I played with all of my American Girl dolls, including my bitty babies, until I was 12. I would get her the doll.
 
DD got Bitty when she was 4 & is now 10 & still loves Bitty the best.

Kae
 
IDK if your dd is set on having that particular doll she may not be happy with any other doll, unless you start talking her out of it now. LOL

I saw the bitty baby day before yesterday for the first time in real life & I was disappointed - It was smaller than what I was thinking.

As far as my dd - she loves doing baby's hair - so of course a bitty baby would do us no good.

The bitty twins have hair & were by far my daughter's favorite dolls. She had 4 twin, 2 bittys & 5 american girl dolls. She won't part with the bitty babies.
 





New Posts










Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top