I admit I was reluctant about going our 1st trip in 2007. My husband (fiance) at the time, insisted on going since he was an army brat & grew up in Germany. Our kids DD14, DS13, DS9 & DS7 at time, are picky eaters & they loved it. It was my birthday too that day & the band got the entire restaurant to sing happy bithday to me. It was fun. The kids even got up & danced on the dance floor to the band. Great atmosphere.
We went back the following year for our honeymoon, this time I insisted on eating there.
We're going back to Disney in a couple weeks & will of course visit again. I recommend it highly. There is enough of a variety of food to fit every palette. Not to mention the pints of beer are a definate to quench any thirst.