I agree with Wayne - you simply can't judge on the preferences of others. We've never had a bad meal at California Grill, but have been spectacularly underwhelmed by both our visits to Grand Floridian Cafe! (Wayne, you
have to give something a second chance to have a valid opinion

- although I'll admit that we'll never return to Pizzafari.)
Seriously, we'd need to know your party make-up and an idea of the kind of thing you like to properly answer your question. After 20 years of visiting WDW we now visit without kids and our tastes have evolved, but we still enjoy a wide variety of dining experiences. To answer your question as set, I'd probably say Victoria and Albert's, but it's not for everyone by any stretch of the imagination.