I would give it another chance if had been something like poor service but it was everything, late seating, tiny portions(ok give me small steak but fill me up with veg at least) really bad server, freezing cold, over 2 hours for 2 courses(when we asked for it ASAP)I agree with Wayne - you simply can't judge on the preferences of others. We've never had a bad meal at California Grill, but have been spectacularly underwhelmed by both our visits to Grand Floridian Cafe! (Wayne, you have to give something a second chance to have a valid opinion- although I'll admit that we'll never return to Pizzafari.)
Seriously, we'd need to know your party make-up and an idea of the kind of thing you like to properly answer your question. After 20 years of visiting WDW we now visit without kids and our tastes have evolved, but we still enjoy a wide variety of dining experiences. To answer your question as set, I'd probably say Victoria and Albert's, but it's not for everyone by any stretch of the imagination.
This all comes down to your taste preferences really...and also can vary from one year to the next. For a couple of years we LOVED Boma's then something changed and we HATE it there now. Others will still love it..The same thing happened with the SCI-FI diner, loved it on a couple of occasions then last time thought it was dreadful and prob won't go back..
At the moment we like Jiko's as a TS and Port Orleans Riverside CS..this also could change come the next trip!!
Its just one of those things you have to find out yourselves, you might go to Boma's and Sci-Fi and wonder why on earth I don't rate them!!!![]()
Fav Table service
Grand Floridian cafe
Tutto Italia
Chefs de France
Teppan Edo
Yak N Yeti
Fav 2 credit TS
Narcoossee
Had bad experience in Yachtsman 2 years ago, went back again last year and got better service. Still consider Narcoossee better quality food & setting. Paid OOP before having DDP. Going back for our 4th visit in August
Fav counter service
Columbia Harbor House in MK
Yak N Yeti
Earl of Sandwich
P.O. Riverside
Have you been able to book Narcosossee for august yet Nige, we still keep getting nothing available, What are you doing on here anyway havent you got kids to be looking after![]()