Stay at the Polynesian. Stay at the Polynesian. Stay at the Polynesian.
The rooms are just slightly smaller (not noticable to me) than those at the Contemporary. Stay at the Polynesian. All of the rooms have daybeads which are large enough to sleep a 6 foot tall person. I've napped on one, so I know. All the rooms have 2 queen beds.
If you request the Tahiti longhouse (and your request is fulfilled), then the sink will be outside of the tub/toilet part of the bathroom which makes it easier for a group to get ready in the morning. Stay at the Polynesian.
Transportation options are the largest at the Polynesian. You can monorail to the MK or TTC. You can take the motor launch to the MK. You can walk to the ferry dock and take the ferry to the MK with all of the commoners (just kidding - but you will feel special if you stay at the Polynesian). You can walk to the TTC to catch the monorail to EPCOT. You can also catch motor coaches (o.k. they are just regular ol' busses) from in front of the Polynesian to just about anywhere in the World (unless its another resort hotel). Stay at the Polynesian. Or you can catch busses at the TTC.
The new Volcano Pool is a hit with my kids. Zero entry for my youngest and a long enclosed waterslide through the heart of the volcano for my oldest (9 yrs old). If the Volcano Pool is too crowded, you can go to the oval, quiet pool which is usually not that busy. It is deeper at one end than the Volcano Pool for those who like to perform underwater stunts ("How many underwater somersaults can you do?" is a game my kids like to play.)
When he was younger, my oldest absolutely loved the playing in the sand at the Polynesian's beach. My wife and I watched him with his grandpa on the beach to well after sundown from our perch in the California Grill several years ago. They were illuminated by the tiki torches that light the resort at night. Stay at the Polynesian. Those tikis just "do it" for me and my wife. We would purposely take the longest route back to our room at night, even after a loooong day in the parks (just not in the heat of summer!) just to enjoy the torch lit pathways.
If you can go at anytime of year, the Polynesian can be had for less than your $250 per night budget. You'll need to go in Value Season with a code. We were there in August last year for $198/night including taxes (11%). Stay at the Polynesian.
In all fairness, the CR (and the GF) all have their plusses. But for a themed resort, the Polynesian wins hands down. Last trip down, my kids thought it was just like being on "Survivor" except there was air conditioning, room service, indoor plumbing, 3 restaurants, shops, a video arcade, a marina and surrey bike rental. Stay at the Polynesian. The Polynesian is one of only two WDW resorts that had Walt's input. So there is original magic there!
Have a great time wherever you stay! Did I mention that I think you should stay at the Polynesian?
