Wow! Thanks for all the great replies!
So on Wednesday when I originally posted this question, we decided to head over to BWV and play there. The reason we picked that was because there is other stuff to do over there and we wanted to check that out too.
We liked BWV a lot. The slide was great, and the pool was big.
We decided to wander over to BCV to check out SAB too. We couldn't get in to pool hop (we knew that and weren't expecting to) but we all agree that BCV is a must stay on a future trip so we can play in SAB!
Thursday we almost drown from the rain LOL!

So we decided to hop in the car and pool hop at Vero Beach, since the radar showed it was clear down there. For future reference, for anyone looking to do a day trip away from the parks and you have a car, this is a GREAT option! They were more than welcoming (especially since they knew Disney was contemplating building an ark in Orlando). The combination of beach and a great pool made for a great day. They also have fun activities and it was a very relaxing day away from the fun chaos of WDW.
Friday we decided to head over to VWL, since this is our home resort for the last 8 years and we have never set foot in the place. We were very underwhelmed at the pool there. The building and grounds were nice, but just didn't have that "Disney magic feel" to us. Since it was our last day, I asked the kids which pool they wanted to go back to, and they unanamiously chose OKW.
I have to say, it was really nice having this pool hopping option, since now we know what the other resorts are like, and know which ones to shoot for with our next ressies.
Thanks again for all the suggestions!