Best lobster roll on property?

[DoodlesMom]

My dh is currently obsessed (ok, maybe me too) with lobster rolls. We tried one the last trip at Columbia House & it wasn't very impressive. Is there a really good one in the World?

 

[Lisa F]

My dh is currently obsessed (ok, maybe me too) with lobster rolls. We tried one the last trip at Columbia House & it wasn't very impressive. Is there a really good one in the World?

Nope. Sorry. I think Columbia House is the pinnacle. The quick serve at contemporary has one that is very similar and I think captain's grille has one at the yacht club that had a bit less mayo but overall looked pretty pathetic.

Come to New England if you are obsessed. Or even get lobsters steamed from the supermarket, pick the meat, mix with the barest bit of mayo and a tiny little bit of white pepper and stuff it into a butter griddled hot dog roll. They are super easy to make except for the meat picking part

 

[HopperFan]

Columbia Harbor House is awful as far as I'm concerned. Quite disappointing after have a really good one at Food & Wine.

I have found the one at Captain's Grille for lunch to be very good and wouldn't hesitate to order it again.

 

[OrangeCountyCommuter]

I did not like Columbia House. BW Bakery used to have a good one. Not sure it's still on the menu, but if it is it was good. Captain's Grill was also good.

 

[PlutoTheDog89]

Boardwalk Bakery is pretty good. There's not much filler, but the sandwich has gotten a bit smaller.

 

[Lisa F]

Boardwalk Bakery is pretty good. There's not much filler, but the sandwich has gotten a bit smaller.

it is also gone

 

[Lehuaann]

it is also gone

When did they get rid of it?

 

[Lisa F]

When did they get rid of it?

yes. I have heard people here report it is gone and it is gone from the official menu.

 

[powellrj]

I had the sample size last year at food and wine and all I could tast was onion. Not a fan.

 

[PlutoTheDog89]

it is also gone

NO WAY!!! We love that. I remember not seeing it on the menu, but then again, a lot of Boardwalk Bakery stuff isn't listed but is there when you go (i.e. Breakfast).

That was such a good value on the DDP. Maybe that's why...

 

[Lehuaann]

yes. I have heard people here report it is gone and it is gone from the official menu.

It was missing from the official menu last Oct/Nov. However, when we arrived, it was still available. We got it 3 or 4 times. I hope it's not really gone, gone.

 

[anniemae]

I would try the Captains Grill.