For us, the BOGO half off didn't work out to be the best deal. What worked for us was getting one AP with the extra three months. I think that was $168. Then, my three kids got fun cards with the extra three months for $99 each. My AP also got a free ticket in January, which a relative used, and will get another free ticket in Sept. (And then another next January likely since I have it for 15 months!) I can also purchase 6 tickets at 50% off. So, though we bought one AP due to free parking, it was worth it for so much more. (It's also gets 10% off food and access to the passholders lounge and other special deals).