Best city friendly SUV

I have a High Lander and live in a City. Its big. I proffered Rav 4 for parking purposes alone.
I loved, loved, loved my old Rav 4.
Had three row seating and seats would fold so low into bay when not used.
It was a great design.
 
Replacement parts are challenging across a wide range of vehicles, period. I have no idea why, but I know several people suffering hardships because of it.

We were approaching time to replace both vehicles just as the pandemic hit. Then the parts shortages held up vehicle availability so we toughed it out until my husband's car finally started signaling the end of the road was coming. We drive our vehicles until the wheels are about ready to come off -- not truly, but just don't believe a car is a great place to spend money so we wring every last mile out of ours.

Finally in summer of "22 we were able to get him a RAV4. Being from Motown we have previously always purchased domestic. We couldn't purchase anything domestic without certain features disabled because chips weren't yet available -- yet we would still be paying for the features and on a wait list for necessary chips. No thank you. We knew several people who made 18 mos. of car payments while still waiting for all of their chips. It took several months on a waiting list for the car to come in, but we were able to get it before my husband's car signed off on us. Toyota would not sell vehicles until all necessary chips were available and installed. It's been a great car for him.

Ironically my car was actually older and is still kicking around. Next month marks 20 years. The pandemic also shifted my job to mostly work from home, so I've been able to keep dragging my feet. Honestly I'm a bit intimidated by the new vehicles because it seems as though I've been driving a Model T in comparison to when I get in my husband's vehicle. He's been prodding and prodding me for a while now and I think next year it will be time for me to face the music. At this point I think I may be looking at a Highlander or something similar from Subaru that I don't remember the name of.

Truthfully I'm about ready for truly autonomous cars to be the norm and reality. I get in and it takes me where I want to go. Absolutely loathe driving anymore.
 
Subaru if not looking for a luxury level vehicle. Otherwise I'd suggest a BMW X3.
 
Another vote for RAV-4. We just got one this summer to replace an aging Tacoma pick-up. With regards to arthritis, it may depend on the individual but DH finds it much easier to get into an SUV/truck/minivan which sits higher than a sedan or cross-over which sits lower.

As for repairs -- I guess I got really lucky last winter when I hit a deer with our Dodge Caravan rendering it undriveable. Repairs were completed and I had it back in just about a month. I didn't take it to a dealer, though, but a local body shop. Maybe that makes a difference.
 
I drive a Honda Pilot. I have a transmission setting for sand, so seems like it would be fine for beach driving. It is also comfortable and safe. Might be a bigger SUV than what you want, so maybe look at the Honda CRV.
Loved the new Honda Pilots-
Ultimately we decided we didn't need that big of vehicle anymore (my son got my 23 year old 4Runner so we still have towing capacity as needed)
Honda CRV hybrid-2023 model. Have had it for ~5 months now and love it. Right size, excellent safety features, good gas mileage. We liked many Kia models as well but our mechanic said parts to get is a beast AND they are harder to work on.
Honda also didn't break the bank.

OP-my husband was Tboned when a red light runner ran a VERY red light and totaled his car. It was a CRV. Both hubs and son walked away with very minor aches. Glad you were also very fortunate!
 
Jeep Wrangler, Ford Bronco, or Toyota 4Runner are the first things that come to mind when I think of sturdy SUVs that aren't massive and would handle the streets as well as terrain like the beach. I know some would argue that the Bronco should fall under large, but the cargo capacity of the Bronco and Jeep are on par with a smaller SUV and they are really more chunky on the exterior than massive. That being said, I know a lot of people (myself included) who have had really bad experiences with Jeeps. If you're OK with a wagon, I know a lot of people who are really happy with their Subaru Outbacks. I hesitate going too deeply into the midsize SUVs because they are all so different, some are much bigger than others, and of the ones I've owned aren't great for city parking. I currently have a Hyundai Palisade, I previously had a VW Atlas, and before that I had a Nissan Pathfinder...all are classified midsized and they're a tight squeeze in urban parking situations. VW bought back the Atlas because it was such a lemon, but I know that vehicle had recalls that other owners went many months waiting on replacement parts. I've had a few waits for parts for my Palisade as well and have seen similar stories from people with the vehicle that have been in minor accidents. I think it's just the norm in the industry these days.
 
After a bad accident in a Subaru Impreza hatchback that even the body shop was surprised wasn't a total I am a total believer in their quality and build. After the repairs you would never know it had been nearly totaled. I now have an Ascent and while I don't think that fits the bill in the OP, I would look at a Crosstrek, Forester, Outback, or Impreza wagon.
 
Toyota Rav4?

Unless you plan on actually driving on the beach, I don't see a special need for a "Beach" vehicle.

My family likes Toyotas and the Rav4 is a smaller type SUV, so I think it checks the boxes.

As far as totalling the vehicle, doesn't the insurance company decide that, based on cost to repair vs value? NOT because of availability of parts?
Add me to the list of happy Rav4 owners!!
 
Just saw on our local news that Toyota is recalling a million cars for airbag problems.
 
It sounds like you want a small SUV that is safe and reliable with a touch of luxury. I would absolutely recommend an Acura RDX. Seems like it would check all of your boxes.
I ❤️ my RDX. DH has a full size truck and he loves the RDX too. So easy to maneuver in the city.
 
Seconded. We have a CRv Hybrid that we bought at exactly the wrong time when the inventory was nill (water pump went out on the Outback and MAN is that a poor design - you have to remove the timing belt to replace the water pump - WTH?). I digress...

Anywho, we ended up with the Touring trim package (all we could find) that I would NEVER have otherwise bought. It's really nice and has all the collision protection, park assist, etc. that comes in really handy when trying to park or driving in traffic. The Hybrid gets great gas mileage which is something I would otherwise never say about an SUV.
 
And now I just saw Honda is recalling over 2 million for a fuel pump issue.
 
I had a GMC Terrain and absolutely loved it. Very comfortable ride, plenty of technology, capable of driving off the paved roads. Not sure if it's too big for the city driving/parking you want to do, but I now have an Acadia and thinking of getting a Jeep Grand Cherokee after this one is done.
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE







New Posts



DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top