This is a very personal decission as you can see by the varied responses. We have a girl, so our perspective is skewed that way. However, my favorite (food) character meal has been O'hana. Their skillet style Polynesian breakfast was ridiculous. Plus their guava orange whatever juice is to die for. I'd for for that alone.
We also liked the characthers, it is Lilo and Stitch, plus a couple of other guests. We had Mickey and Minnie.
We've done Chef Mickey's and Cape May for breakfast. Both were ok. Standard breakfast buffet food. I think Cape May had a better selection of fruits and such. Both offer some set of the Fab Five.
We've done for lunch and/or dinner several:
- Garden Grill (Chip/Dale and friends)
- Chef Mickey's
- 1900 Park Fare
- Akershus (Norway)
- Cinderella's Royal Table
Of those, our favorite is Chef Mickey's. The food is standard buffet fare, we get that. But we've never experienced what a previous poster has and felt the characters were very accommodating. Matter of fact, a couple of times we saw them more than once. We also like the light hearted and somewhat loud atmosphere. Maybe we won't when our DD5 is older, but for now we fit right in.
2nd to that we'd likely say Garden Grill (for the food), agree character photos are hard here or Akershus (for the princesses). We had a much better princess experience for a significantly lower cost here than at Royal Table.
1900 Park Fare and Royal Table were our least favorite. We did Park Fare so we could see unique characters (Lady Trumane, step sisters and Prince Charming), but the food (buffet) left a lot to be desired. Royal Table was good, but just not worth the price. Fun to say we've eaten in the castle, and we may do it again someday. But this is a once to every great once in a while thing - not an all the time thing.
I've eaten at Crystal Palace for breakfast, but it was 1993 so I don't feel I should comment on it as I barely remember it.
We hope to try both Crystal Palace and Tusker House for breakfast sometime as getting into both those parks early is appealing. We're not huge Pooh fans, so Crystal Palace would be for the pics of Main Streen before open. We were able to catch Piglet at DHS this last trip so even for autographs we're good on Pooh, Tigger, Eyeore and Piglet.
I wish they'd have the Princes at the princess meals or do some Pirate's League meal for boys. Probably not enough interest.