We liked Chef Mickey's better than Liberty Tree. I thought the character interaction at Chef Mickey's was awesome (especially Minnie Mouse). Crystal Palace is also one of our favorites, but it is only the 4 main Pooh characters (Pooh, Eeyore, Tigger and Piglet). I guess it really depends on what their favorite characters are. I'd lean towards Chef Mickey's. Trying to get to Mickey Mouse in one of the parks can take a very long time. At Chef Mickey's you'll have him for a few minutes and you get food in between all the characters (Goofy, Mickey, Chip, Dale, & Minnie and also either Donald or Pluto) (we saw Donald at dinner and Pluto at breakfast, I don't know if that is the regular rotation though)