I have to agree with the OP. The opinions on WDW restaurants in general vary tremendously. As an example, OneMoreTry has espoused the wonderful virtues of Flying Fish. We were underwhelmed with our experience at Flying Fish. Impecable service, but only good food (for the price, we expected far better). Our experience is that California Grill is far better than FF. This is sad to me, inasmuch as we own at the Boardwalk and CG is a bit of a hike.
The reality is, no matter what your opinion is on a WDW restaurant, you can find a whole heep of people with a contrary opinion.
As for the original question. On the BW, we love Spoodles. Everything we've eaten there (with the possible exception of the take out pizza) has been outstanding. Overall a good value for an excellent meal. The salmon was fabulous!