Oh, I'm thrilled that I found this thread! I was just about to ask the same question.
I want to stay in Alligator Bayou, too. I'm not so concerned about being close to things; I'm more interested in being sure I don't get a parking lot view, and I'd like an all non-smoking building.
The POR FAQ thread says, "Smoking is permitted in Buildings 17, 27, 28, 34 and 36." But later, the FAQ threads says, "Smoking optional buildings are Oak Manor in the Mansions and Alligator Bayou buildings 18 and 38." Anyone know which information is current?
Anything special I should do to put in my room request? Do I just call POR's reservation number? (I think that 407-934-7639)
Also, here's a question for folks who were recently there -- was there much damage to the landscaping?
Thanks!