The only reason that we would keep it at 0 during the year, is that with the big refund, we usually pay off some bills and plan vacations. This year, everything we got in a refund, went to buying Haley a car.
And next year, Hannah will be 16 in April and of course (as she should) be expecting a car next year. We don't want to finance any more vehicles than we need to (DH's truck is finanaced and so we have to have more insurance than if we owned it outright). My car is paid for, Haley's car is paid for and when we get Hannah's, it will be paid for in full. The insurance is going to be terrible next year. 2 teens on the policy? Oy vey. I am seriously considering selling my car ( I wish I could just give it to Hannah) because I HATE to drive and really prefer being at home (thats part of the reason I'm trying for SSDI, I have a hard time being out anywhere). It's a good car with low miles, I just don't need it. Maybe I can just trade it in for something Hannah wants.
I don't know....if I'm good enough at this strange "budgeting" thing everyone talks about....maybe the only downside will be putting off our cruise until next year, or the year after. Carnival says I have a $700 credit I can use within 2 years of cancelling our cruise this summer.
Okay, I'm going to try to do this without sounding harsh or overly judgmental. First of all, it's not a good idea to think of the IRS as a "savings account." You aren't making ANY interest off of it, just giving the IRS a free loan. It's better to have it extra in your paychecks. Then you wouldn't have to wait and pay bills off just ONCE a year - pay them each month as you go.
As for the car for your teenager, it's a pet peeve of mine, that kids "expect" cars when they turn 16.

I believe if you want a car, then save your money and buy one. We have told all of our kids we will match whatever they save. Our now almost 16-yo totally lucked out because we just happen to have a third car that we're not using. It's a great car, so I don't want to get rid of it, and it really isn't worth much anyway. (It's a 1999 Honda Accord with about 174k miles on it.) She will have USE of that car as long as it's still alive. If at some point it needs some major repair(s), she can either pay for them and keep driving the car or she's SOL. We are NOT putting any more money into it at this point. SHE will be responsible for maintenance, etc, if she wants to continue driving it. She will also pay for at least HALF of her insurance. She doesn't have her half one month, she doesn't drive that month. We will give her gas money ONLY to get to school and then anywhere she goes for us (like picking her sisters up from dance, etc.) Other than that, she's on her own. She wants to drive to the movies or friends' houses, she needs to come up with that gas money herself. But it will help us out tremendously for her to have her license, get herself to and from school and help us out with running the other kids back and forth to activities (2 girls in dance and boy in football).
A car is not a "right" when kids turn 16, as much as they feel entitled to one. Yes, the majority of my daughter's friends got cars for their 16th birthday. One just got a Volvo Crossover - approximately $30,000 car. More than any of our cars cost! And yes, my dd has moaned and groaned and tried to tell me we *should* buy her a car.
Another option for you is for your teens to share the car the one already has. I have a friend who just bought a "third family car." Their oldest just turned 16 (although hasn't gotten her license yet) and it will be hers to use until their second one turns 16. (They're less than 2 years apart.) Then they will share it.
It's funny that my dd HATED the Accord. (It's also purple - well, a deep plum color, which I love.) But when it's drive that or nothing, it's not so bad after all.
She also lucks out cuz none of the other kids will get their license any time soon. Next one just turned 11, so 5 more years. Oldest will be out of the house and on her own by then. There are only 7 months between kid #2 and kid #3 (oldest 2 are mine biologically and younger 2 are DH's biologically). Doubtful the Accord will still be alive and kicking. Even if we DO have a "third family car," they would have to share it. We've told them (1) not to COUNT on us having a third car for them to use and (2) even if we do, you will still want your OWN car, so good idea to start saving NOW.
The main reason why we still have the Accord is because we won't let her drive my car (Honda Pilot) and she can't drive DH's (stick - although will hopefully teach her how to drive a stick at some point - I don't even know how and kinda wish I did.) So we kept the Accord cuz she needed SOMETHING to drive with her permit till she gets her license anyway.
We just started Dave Ramsey's Financial Peace University a few months ago, and it has been an absolute lifesaver! We are now on a budget and feel like we got a huge raise!! All bills are getting paid, on time, and we're tackling our debt to get that knocked out in about a year and a half. (And will NEVER have debt again!) I highly recommend it!!! It feels SOOOOO good to know that everything will be paid, how it will be paid, when it will be paid, and we even "cash flow" other things that come up like summer camp, etc., so we have a PLAN for everything. Such a stress reliever!!!
