They may be different, but I'm not sure. I haven't gotten one since my first cruise. On the Magic, the ESPN Sky Box no longer exists, so if you have one of those mugs, it could be different. If you feel it's worth it, you could probably get away with it if the mugs are the same. Technically, the mug (or the old soda mugs) were supposed to be good for one cruise only, but I don't know how the could (or if they bother to) enforce it. I thought that lugging the thing around was kind of a pain, so I've only gotten it the one time.