Never been to NYC so I'll be no help there, sorry! But how fun and exciting!! I love all the things you'll get to do, the only thing I'd add is a broadway show if you can arrange a family member to watch Izzy for an evening and have a date
Thanks for reminding me of that idea. I know we had tossed it around briefly early on in our planning, but I'd forgotten. I think it's a possibility. I don't want to force anyone (probably Dug's parents) to stay in when they want to go out, but I think they might be willing to do this and spend a night in. We'll have to chat with them about it, maybe. I wonder if Broadway tickets are available on short notice?

That would be really fun to have a night out. We really have not had that - Dug's parents have watched her for a few matinee movies/meals out for us, but that's about it.
I have lots to say, been to NYC 3 times (2x with my mom and then our honeymoon) plus I olanned my mom and brothers trip there last year. But I'm on my phone so I'll write more when I'm on my computer.
Awesome, would you like to plan my trip for me?

Can't wait to hear what else you have to say!
The singing diner is Ellen's stardust diner. It's awesome. Go!
That's right, I didn't have the name in front of me. I know Dug mentioned it to his family and they were all interested. Sounds fun and I bet it would keep Izzy occupied. I think it's fairly close to our hotel, too.
Yes you are going to hate yourself for driving into midtown and I would drop it off somewhere near a subway station and take the subway. Or do the towncar from the airport. Midtown is terrifying just riding in the car/taxi. I would NEVER EVER want to drive in it!!
That bad, huh?

I'm hesitant to do the subway, because we'd have to lug all of our bags and the carseat and stroller with us. Sounds complicated. If Dug's sister/BIL and/or his parents are going to drive in, though, I suppose we could have them take our bags and then maybe do this. Otherwise, the airport would add some extra expense, but maybe it's worth it?
I've only been to NYC once and I was 12 so can't really help on anything.
For the carseat, we took the carseat (in our own red bag that you can buy at Babies R US or anywhere else) all the way to the gate to see if there were any seats available because there were some seats available the day before our flight. But unfortunately, with all the stand bys, all the seats got taken. I've heard that they have bags but figured it would be easier for all of us, if we'd have our carseat already in a bag ready to go.
Good idea, I'll plan to pick up one of those bags. They're fairly cheap and I could even keep it in the package in case we don't need it and want to return it. Good point that the currently open seats may disappear at the last minute. There are not a lot of them, so we'll see. I think she'll be fine as a lap baby too. Disney was not that long ago and she did fine with it then. We just figured, since we're bringing the car seat, might as well take advantage of having it, if possible.
Also, when we drove to the airport, we took an additional car seat in the trunk so that we wouldn't have to unhook DS's regular car seat (it's a pain in the butt to take in and out) so it was nice to just pull it out of the trunk and go. And when we returned to our car after our trip, it was nice knowing that we could just take off and go.
That is a good point and some extra reasons for why buying this new seat was a good idea. My $40 seat just got delivered today and it actually seems pretty nice for what we want to use it for. I'll have to play around with installing it in all the different ways, but it seems pretty good. And we can leave our existing seats in our cars.
I'm shocked that they don't provide a PnP, even though it's a B&B. I'd say ask for a PnP from family members, if not, i'd go with the travel tent that way you can take it home too versus purchasing a PnP.
Yeah, I was surprised. We asked a few times, just to be sure. The place hosts weddings frequently - we can't be the first people to bring a toddler to a wedding? Oh, well - at least we've now been switched to a room big enough for a PnP - apparently our original one was not!

Yeah, one of those two options makes more sense than ordering a new PnP, I think. I have to admit I do kinda like the idea of having the little travel tent thing on hand, in general.
Hi - I live/work near NYC and have my entire life so hopefully I can help a little bit
Yay, thank you!
As for flying with the car seat, we have always used our own bags - though I have seen people check car seats without bags, but I don't think the airlines provide anything
Sounds good, I'll plan to pick up a gate check bag for it.
As far as apps for your phone, if you don't have it yet I suggest Toddler Lock. It is a fun little activity for young kids and it locks all the other buttons on your phone so they can't do anything else
That sounds awesome!

She LOVES to press the home button and exits out of the apps we do have. I'll let Dug know to load this one up!
I haven't used that town car provider (I usually just use the company we use for my work) but we have always found them to be new cars that have LATCH so I would imagine you should be fine, but might be worth calling the company to check
Okay, that sounds good. I'd be surprised if they were older cars (since LATCH has been a thing since 2002, I believe), but wasn't sure if towncars/limos were different. We can ask when we set it up. Worst case scenario, I can always install with a seatbelt, I guess.
All the items on your "to-do" list should be pretty close to where you are staying. Depending on exactly where you hotel is situated will dictate how easy to walk to everything (i.e., do you have to get to the other side of the FDR highway or not).
I'll have to look at a map and check that out. I feel so lost.
I would suggest trying to get to things like the Statue of Liberty as early in the morning as you can as they tend to get crowded later in the day. Also, for the 9/11 memorial, I suggest you reserve passes as there are limited spots per time per day and the day-of passes are first come first serve. You can use this site to reserve them:
http://www.911memorial.org/visitor-passes
Sounds like a plan. We'll be up early with Izzy anyway, so might as well get our day started. Thank you for the reminder about reserving 9/11 passes. We need to get on top of these things.
There are a ton of places to eat in the city - I can come up with lots of suggestions but are you looking to stay just in that area? What type of food do you like? One easy thing to do is use Open Table and go to a specific part of the city you will be at and see what is available. If you do go into Brooklyn there are lots of family friendly local places in the Park Slope area.
I'm thinking we'll probably mostly want to stay near our hotel areas and the sights we're seeing. Thanks for the suggestions!
Generally having a stroller should be no issue. Only problem we have found is if using the subway finding the elevators isn't always easy (and they aren't always super clean) so we sometimes wind up carrying them down the stairs which isn't that much fun.
Yeah, I've heard that about the subway. I wasn't even sure if there were elevators, to be honest. I'm thinking that, if we plan to use the subway, I might plan to wear her in the Ergo for that outing. Also, at places like the museums, is it okay to bring strollers in or would we have to park it? Anywhere we're going that wouldn't allow a stroller? I like how, in WDW, you can feel fairly safe leaving your stroller alone, but probably not in NYC.
It will take you definitely take you a few hours to get to Woodstock - it's actually up a little further north than you might think and it always just takes longer than one would think to get out of the City. I would plan for 3 hours.
Yeah, we'll try to leave plenty of time for travel. And car rental.
Not totally surprised the BnB doesn't have any pack-n-plays. At least our experience with them has been they are geared towards adults and don't have much for kids (speaking in generalities not about the one you are staying in specifically).
Good to know. I'm so used to places having them - I'm glad we asked in advance. That would be disappointing to get there and not have anywhere for Izzy to sleep. And, of course, MIL keeps saying things like, "Can't you just put her on a bed with pillows around her? That's what we did when you were kids." Well, considering Izzy considers beds playgrounds and is perfectly capable of removing the pillows, climbing out, and exploring the non-childproofed room while we try to sleep, um, no thanks.
For when you are back in NYC, the hotel definitely should have an area to unload - though might just be the curb of the street. But they are so used to having cabs and cars stop there it won't be an issue. Probably should have a doorman there to help unload and stuff too so you should be fine.
Okay, great. Maybe I'll have to do that Google street view of it.
That sounds like a lot of things to do on your list (all great things, but a lot). Also, it might look close on a map but they really aren't all that close. For example, probably will take you 20-20 mins to get form your hotel to the Museums (of natural history and art) and then they would be 30-40 mins to the Intrepid museum.
The empire state building is very cool, but it does get crowded and is pretty expensive to get to the top. Same with top of the rock, but they do have a bar/restaurant there. Just walking around rockafeller center is great and there is a cool
lego store and other things there.
Up from there you can hit up like F.A.O. Schwartz which is always fun and there is a giant Apple store right next to that. Up further past that is the Central Park Zoo which is pretty cool, then further up si the Metropolitan Museum of Art - so doing that one day would be good. The Natural History museum is on the other side of the park and you can check out Lincoln Center there as well.
Thank you for all of this. I really feel like I need a WDW-like Touring Plan. (Anyone can feel free to make one for me

)
As far as places to eat, there are things like Alice's Tea Cup which we like or Serendipity which is kinda close to FAO Schwarts to get Frozen Hot Chocolate (though it is very crowded). A fun (if touristy) place is the Jekyll and Hyde Club. Again, you can do the same thing of look in Open Table for different places to eat. But happy to provide penty of options if you let me know what type of place/style of food/cost that is ok/etc.
Mmmmm, frozen hot chocolate. I've heard that place is good. I'll see if Dug has any input on this and maybe make some requests of you.
Great update!
Hi, wiigirl!
I've seen you pop up on almost every single thread I look at on the DIS, but I really don't know much of anything about you. Please tell me about yourself!
How many times have you been to WDW?
What's your favorite ride?
Favorite WDW snack?
Favorite park?
Feel free to throw in anything else!
