Several years ago we decided to stay at BC for my Mom (we had normally stayed at mods or values, this was her first and supposedly her only trip to WDW so we wanted to make it special and she looked through the books and choose BC. We loved it so much we don't like to go anywhere else. We just returned from the AKL in April, (my husband and kids wanted to try it out) and the whole time there I just kept comparing it to the BC and told my husband I didn't want to stay anywhere else, but the BC from now on. My mom also has returned to WDW since, even though she thought the first trip would be a once in a lifetime thing, she just loved it so much. As a matter of fact, we recently purchased into the Disney Vacation Club at the Beach Club Villas which are attached to Beach Club, because we loved the Beach Club so much.
You really can't beat the 5 minute walk to Epcot, we go over every couple of nights to watch illuminations and just walk back to our hotel and are in bed before everyone else is even on their bus heading back to their resort. And the view at night from the beach looking over to the boardwalk is just breathtaking.
My only complaint about Beach Club is the lack of a food court type resturant. If your looking for a quick breakfast of bagels, doughnuts and croissants, Beach and Creme will do just fine, but if you want bacon, eggs, hashbrowns and waffles, you have to do a full service sit down. Don't get me wrong, their full service sit down resturant, Cape May Cafe is wonderful, it is just not cheap and you can't do it every day. It is a character breakfast with goofy, chip, dale and minne and the food is a buffet and it is excellent.
Okay, I have ranted enough, needless to say, it is a wonderful place. Go, you will love it.