I think my in-laws use bank one. It used to be Indiana National, but was bought out a few years back. When we lived there, we used a credit union, so I dont' have first hand experience. I don't think they have many positives or negatives about their bank, which might be about as good as you can do now.
If you're interested in credit union type things, I think Railroadmen's Federal Credit Union is still in business. We finanaced a house through them, and I was pretty happy with their service.
Good luck! OBTW, what part of Indy are you moving to?