Ban on Carry-ons?

CPT Tripss

Registered
Joined
Feb 26, 2006
Messages
5,366
It will be for your safety. Do you support this?

Counterterrorism officials are talking about banning carry-on luggage on flights around Christmastime ahead of terrorism concerns, NPR reports. U.S. and U.K. officials worried about a terror plot aimed at commercial flights headed for Europe have discussed heightened security measures during the upcoming holiday, including a carry-on luggage ban or a ban on electronic devices in plane cabins.
http://www.smartertravel.com/blogs/...D933CE975&nl_cs=20820205::7597281::21102833::
 
I can't imagine not traveling with my electronics in the cabin. Additionally, I would like to know if extra security would be provided to protect your luggage from thieves? Not likely.
 
Cannot see this happening at.all.

Business travelers would revolt en mass.....don't see them being willing to check laptops and cell phones under almost any circumstances. The chances of expensive electronics getting to its destination intact in checked baggage are not good, between baggage handling throwing bags around and theft of items from luggage. Add in how much less productive travelers would be during flights and layovers without these items and I can see a vast majority of business travel curtailed. Airlines can't afford that.

Not to mention the inconvenience of all passengers traveling without e-readers and other devices that entertain during during flights. Keeping some kids occupied without electronic devices could be a real challenge

But then I've been wrong before popcorn::
 

Are you kidding?

People have gotten to where they can't possibly check their bag. Everything has to go in the cabin with them.

Most people are far to important to have to wait for checked baggage.
 
Not to mention the inconvenience of all passengers traveling without e-readers and other devices that entertain during during flights. Keeping some kids occupied without electronic devices could be a real challenge

Yeah! They might be forced to revert to books, coloring books, small toys, interacting with their children...
 
Yeah! They might be forced to revert to books, coloring books, small toys, interacting with their children...
:rotfl::rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:

Say it ain't so. You mean they would actually have to talk to their children?

I can't count how many times I have seen a family out for lunch or dinner, where every single member of the family is bent over their electronic device, rather than actually speaking to each other.
 
My first thought was also business travel. Telling leisure travelers to entertain themselves in other ways or don't fly is one thing. Telling businesses that there employees can't do any work on that 6 hour flight and that proprietary documents have to be checked would probably mean many refusing to do business travel. Now maybe the holiday season is busy enough that airlines can take that hit for a month or so... maybe not.

I also think it is stupid. if someone wants to blow up a plane badly enough they will find a way.
 
Sooner than later they'll ban passengers in the plane cabin then we'll be completely secure. Do I dare eat a peach?

Bill From PA
 
In the interest of full disclosure, here's the rest of the article (all bolding by me):

U.S. officials confirmed to NPR that they have intelligence suggesting a terrorist attack on passenger planes before Christmas. They also confirmed that the possible attack is aimed at Europe-bound flights only, as opposed to U.S.-bound flights or domestic air travel. In response, there's been talk among counterterrorism experts about prohibiting carry-on luggage or restricting electronic devices onboard planes in the U.S. and Europe. NPR gave no details as to whether a potential ban would be widespread or applied to select Europe-bound flights only.

NPR's Dina Temple-Raston writes, "One remedy under consideration is to ban all carry-on baggage, though there is some question as to whether airlines would push back against such a draconian provision." To be sure, it is highly unlikely we would see a full ban on carry-on luggage across the U.S. around the holidays. The logistics of this kind of action would be very tough to see through in a short amount of time, especially on full flights during the busy Christmas travel week. So don't get distressed about your holiday travel plans just yet.

An electronics ban is more feasible, but at this point, it's difficult to assess the likelihood of either option. If an electronics ban were to happen, passengers would need to stow phones, computers, and other devices in checked luggage.

These are counterterrorism measures that officials have discussed behind closed doors, says NPR. According to all reports, no steps have been taken to enact either ban. For now, keep that phone in your pocket and that carry-on bag firmly in hand.

1. It's merely being discussed.
2. Holiday travel starts in less than three weeks and ends in about four.
3. Unlikely airlines will agree/cooperate.
4. Discussion applies to only certain (Europe-bound?) flights.
 
If I knew ahead of time, guess I'd plan accordingly and take books or magazines along if that were allowed; however, I would be concerned with being unable to carry-on a very expensive piece of medical equipment ($16,000) for my child which fits under the seat or in an overhead bin which we never ever check.
 
I have been reprimanded for posting an entire article, hence only the lead graph.

Another numbers user :confused3 :teacher:
 
to the poster above that made the point that this is most likely not going to happen... Totally agree but it is still fun to discuss how it might play out if they did.

If I knew ahead of time, guess I'd plan accordingly and take books or magazines along if that were allowed; however, I would be concerned with being unable to carry-on a very expensive piece of medical equipment ($16,000) for my child which fits under the seat or in an overhead bin which we never ever check.

Hmm didn't think of medical equipment. I would think they would have to allow some medical equipment on (I'm sure there are some that a person couldn't go a 6-8 hour flight without... actually longer becasue if it can't go through security you have to count in layovers and time in the airports... So just like medically necessary liquids are needed now medically necessary electronics would be required then)

Now you could say that the lower volume with only having to check the medical devices would allow them to check more closely which is true but there is no way I could see them managing to ban all electronics.
 
I have been reprimanded for posting an entire article, hence only the lead graph.

Another numbers user :confused3 :teacher:

You were right; posting an entire article is a copyright violation.

Personally, I outgrew coloring books and playing with toys many years ago and have not flown with any children in several years. I need my iPad! Books are great, but if I'm flying 14+ hours ( my next flight next week), I need more than a book.
 
Well, if you're flying 14 hours, chances are you're not going to Europe. So even on the negligible chance some version of this does happen, it shouldn't affect your flight.

The iPad is less than five years old. What did you do on long distance flights before that, or before portable electronics?
 
What did you do on long distance flights before that, or before portable electronics?

This.

Flying from Australia to USA earlier this year my kids didn't get their devices out of their bags, that said, the flight did have entertainment on board. We will be flying SW next month and they *might* use them on the flights to Orlando if I bother to take them on this trip.

I'm feeling really old fashioned when I say this but I think there is too much devotion to electronic devices by everyone, I can't even drive to the local shops without my phone yet I drove across country before they were around :confused3

So, yeah I support whatever restrictions the airline deem fit when I fly, would much rather have a minor annoyance than be dead :)
 
I bet the airlines would love it! Look at all those additional checked luggage fees!
 
So are they going to guarantee they will take care of my laptop, ipad, cash etc..

:lmao:

But the 'show continues' and folks keep buying.

Your tax $ at waste.

(Gee honey terrorists aren't smart enough to put bombs in the cargo hold, or give them to the thousands of people who are 'exempt' from those pesky rules to protect us :rotfl2::happytv:)
 








Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom