Atonement.

BabyPiglet

DIS Legend
Joined
Jul 5, 2003
Messages
28,730
I just watched this movie. Wow.

This is the most depressing movie I've ever seen. Everything bad happens & nothing (that's real) good happens.

At first I was like 'Huh?' and as the movie went on it got less and less confusing.

Have you seen it? What'd ya think.
 
Movie terrible.
It's all o ver the place, the typewriter is annoying and it's kind of boring.
I was very confused the entire time I watched it.

The book, is a bit better but I find it entirely too dull. It's kind of like funny, how the problem with the book is the same problem at the magazine had with Briony's story. It was too much into detail about stuff no one cares about.
 
I liked the movie quite a bit.
It WAS really confusing, but you're right, it gets less and less confusing as it goes on.
It's really bleek too. Not the most depressing movie I've seen---I just saw revolutionary road...now THATS bleek! but it's definitley up there.

I'm gonna go all movie geek for a second--i really love the cinematography in Atonement, it's really beautifully shot.

on a slightly sick-humoured side note; my friend mark & i are constantly quoting 'you have to bite it'
lol
 
I liked the movie quite a bit.
It WAS really confusing, but you're right, it gets less and less confusing as it goes on.
It's really bleek too. Not the most depressing movie I've seen---I just saw revolutionary road...now THATS bleek! but it's definitley up there.

I'm gonna go all movie geek for a second--i really love the cinematography in Atonement, it's really beautifully shot.

on a slightly sick-humoured side note; my friend mark & i are constantly quoting 'you have to bite it'
lol
Ohh, niiice.

At the beginning I almost turned the movie off. I was so confused and nothing was happening. Basically this annoying little girl was running around talking about her play, and everyone & their sister were smoking. And then it backtracked, which made me even more confused.

When Robbie started writing his letters and gave Briony the wrong one, I was seriously -rolling- in laughter. Not so funny, I guess, but lol!

Overall it isn't the worst movie I've seen (by far), but not the best either. It's too disheartening I guess.

Little girl made a huge mistake and died feeling guilty about everything, the lovers were never reunited & both died in horrible circumstances. It's just sad. :(
 

The plot has so much going for it. I give the plot all the kudos, it's a really good plot. But in neither the book or the movie it was full explored to it's potential.
The most messed up thing in it, is that Lola marries her rapist.
 
Booooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooring.
I didn't even make it past half of the movie. It was so boring.
 
/
I believe there's nudity in it?
Or rape maybe.
I'm not sure, there wasn't anything in there shocking.
 
Never seen it. If it's as boring as everyone says I'm suprised it got nominated for Best Picture last year. I guess they have had some snoozers though.
 
Yeah. Why was it rated R? The book was amazing!

Um, the sex scene in the movie is pretty risque. I mean, there's not a lot of skin or anything, but it made ME blush (and I don't blush easily, haha).

I love James McAvoy but even I couldn't finish the movie. I just hate Briony. Nothing about her was good. She was just an annoying, horrible character.
 
Um, the sex scene in the movie is pretty risque. I mean, there's not a lot of skin or anything, but it made ME blush (and I don't blush easily, haha).

I love James McAvoy but even I couldn't finish the movie. I just hate Briony. Nothing about her was good. She was just an annoying, horrible character.

The library scene?

I saw it on youtube. :lmao:
 
haha, yeah! I dunno, I'm just "OH MY *BLUSH*" hahahaha. It wasn't even that explicit.

It wasn't explicit just really I don't know...passionate? :lmao:

I'd only have blushed if my mom was watching it with me.
 
I liked the movie quite a bit.
It WAS really confusing, but you're right, it gets less and less confusing as it goes on.
It's really bleek too. Not the most depressing movie I've seen---I just saw revolutionary road...now THATS bleek! but it's definitley up there.

I'm gonna go all movie geek for a second--i really love the cinematography in Atonement, it's really beautifully shot.

on a slightly sick-humoured side note; my friend mark & i are constantly quoting 'you have to bite it'
lol

ITA. Very beautifully shot.

Yeah. Why was it rated R? The book was amazing!

The sex scene wasn't exactly subtle. The rape scene and things like that.


I actually really liked the film. The first half hour was terribly boring, but it did get better. I cried at the end, it is a very sad story.

You definately need some energy to watch the film and appreciate it, it isn't one of those films you can just let fly over you. You need to make an effort to keep up and stay with it. It is kinda predictable, like how it ends and such.

Overall, I think it was a good film. Overated, but still a good watch for those who like cinema.
 
I liked it, but it wasn't my favourite movie ever. Yet, I can see why it would be nominated for Best Picture.

I thought the entire thing was easy to understand. I got the plot right away. Even the twist at the end didn't throw me.
 
Um, the sex scene in the movie is pretty risque. I mean, there's not a lot of skin or anything, but it made ME blush (and I don't blush easily, haha).

I love James McAvoy but even I couldn't finish the movie. I just hate Briony. Nothing about her was good. She was just an annoying, horrible character.
Yes, the library scene was very...passionate. Not explicit or showing a lot of skin or whatever, it's just like woah.

So you didn't watch the whole movie? Briony's character really develops & at the end I feel terrible for her.
I liked it, but it wasn't my favourite movie ever. Yet, I can see why it would be nominated for Best Picture.

I thought the entire thing was easy to understand. I got the plot right away. Even the twist at the end didn't throw me.
I could see why it'd be nominated for Best Picture.

The plot itself didn't throw me off as much as...the random stuff that was thrown in? Like Briony's play. And how things I guess...weren't explained fully?

Like how long had Cecilia been in love with Robbie? And the scene with the French man and Briony in the hospital, why did she say she was in love with him? How did he 'know' her and not even know her name?

Maybe I'm just slow, lol.
 
I liked the movie quite a bit.
It WAS really confusing, but you're right, it gets less and less confusing as it goes on.
It's really bleek too. Not the most depressing movie I've seen---I just saw revolutionary road...now THATS bleek! but it's definitley up there.

I'm gonna go all movie geek for a second--i really love the cinematography in Atonement, it's really beautifully shot.
on a slightly sick-humoured side note; my friend mark & i are constantly quoting 'you have to bite it'
lol

::yes::

One of the most well made movies I've ever seen. I own it, and know the script by heart. I had to watch it three times before I 100% understood what happened, but the scene at the very end makes me tear up every time. Keira and James played their roled very very well. Overall a fantastic movie, and the soundtrack is one of my favourites.

The infamous "green dress" (Also known as the "pinned-insect" dress :rotfl2: ) is one of my favourite movie costumes as well. I have almost 20 pages done of a study on it. :rolleyes: My goal is to make a replica at some point. :)
 
Yes, the library scene was very...passionate. Not explicit or showing a lot of skin or whatever, it's just like woah.

So you didn't watch the whole movie? Briony's character really develops & at the end I feel terrible for her.

I could see why it'd be nominated for Best Picture.

The plot itself didn't throw me off as much as...the random stuff that was thrown in? Like Briony's play. And how things I guess...weren't explained fully?

Like how long had Cecilia been in love with Robbie? And the scene with the French man and Briony in the hospital, why did she say she was in love with him? How did he 'know' her and not even know her name?

Maybe I'm just slow, lol.

This is explained more in the book. Robbie had pretty much been around their family for years. His mother is one of the housekeepers (I'm sure everyone got that part) and in the scene where they're walking to the fountain the discussion is something along the lines of...

C-...he says you plan on becoming a doctor
R- I'm thinking about it, yes
C- with 6 years of student life?
R- How else do you become a doctor?
C-You could get a fellowship now, couldnt you?
R- I don't want to teach
C- Youre first!
R- I said I'd pay your father back
C- That's not what I meant at all

A better example is probably...

B- Cee?
C- Yes?
B- Why don't you talk to Robbie anymore?
C- I do..we just move in different circles, that's all.

(I told you I knew the script by heart :rolleyes: )
So they apparently used to talk, or hang out, a lot..but maybe as their feelings grew it got too awkward, so they backed away from each other?
It sounds a lot like Robbie and Cecilia have gotten to know each other really well. I think that when they both "openly admit" to liking each other, it doesn't seem to fit with the movie because as viewers, we don't see the years behind them..we just see them fight at a fountain, and then proceed to have sex in a library :rolleyes:

The way I see the thing with the man in the hospital, is that he honestly doesn't know what he's saying, and Briony tells him he loves him, because she know's he's going to die, and feels bad. (If I remember correctly, she says that after she loosens his bandage and gasps at his wound)

The conversation starts off with-

Cornet- Here you are, at last.
B-The Sister sent me. For a little chat.
C-Oh, yes, I remember your sister. She was always so nice. What’s she doing now?

:headache: He's delusional.

Or maybe I'm delusional :rotfl:
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top Bottom