At what age would you let your children play outside alone?

I was looking at my dd's class pic and there was this one girl who looked older... I asked her how old she was... she is 11 in 3rd grade... :confused3 now my dd was right at cut off for her bday so the school told us it would be best to wait a year (I'm talking a week before the cut off) and she is 9 in 3rd grade but wont be 10 for another 5 months.

wow-11 and in 3rd grade? My daughter was 11 when she started 7th grade! That is a 4 grade difference! I know cut offs are different in places but dang- she would have had to have just missed the cut off and gotten held back 2-3 times to make up that much of a difference! In 3rd grade here the late birthday kids are 7 for the first 3-4 months of school.
Right now going into 12 grade are kids that are 16 in with men that are 19 due to cut offs and parents holding kids back from starting school on time and others for getting held back.
 
wow-11 and in 3rd grade? My daughter was 11 when she started 7th grade! That is a 4 grade difference! I know cut offs are different in places but dang- she would have had to have just missed the cut off and gotten held back 2-3 times to make up that much of a difference! In 3rd grade here the late birthday kids are 7 for the first 3-4 months of school.
Right now going into 12 grade are kids that are 16 in with men that are 19 due to cut offs and parents holding kids back from starting school on time and others for getting held back.

Where do you live?

Kids here (Massachusetts) have to be at least 5 by September 1st and no older than 6 to enter Kindergarten. Therefore it's not possible for a child to be 7 in 3rd grade here.....most would be turning 9 at some point during the year; some 10 if their parents (or the system) held them back a year. It was no different than when I went to school here (100 yrs ago). Most everyone I knew was 18+ at graduation. Your system sounds like the extreme to me :)
 
wow-11 and in 3rd grade? My daughter was 11 when she started 7th grade! That is a 4 grade difference! I know cut offs are different in places but dang- she would have had to have just missed the cut off and gotten held back 2-3 times to make up that much of a difference! In 3rd grade here the late birthday kids are 7 for the first 3-4 months of school.
Right now going into 12 grade are kids that are 16 in with men that are 19 due to cut offs and parents holding kids back from starting school on time and others for getting held back.

There must be a difference in starting age and/or birthday cut off where you live. My DH has taught middle school (7th/8th grade) for 12 years and 11 years old in 7th grade is very very uncommon based on age cutoffs and the district does not allow children to enter early..no testing, no exceptions. He can't recall ever having an 11 year old in 7th grade.

11-12 is generally 6th grade..10-11 is 5th grade (approximately). So based on the average ages/cut offs here it would put her 2 grades behind at most.

No 16 year old would be a senior (12th grade) here unless they were advanced early/skipped grades. 16 is generally sophmore year (most kids go 15-16 sophmore year, 16-17 junior year (11th grade) and 17-18 senior year (12th grade) but with later birthdays some are at 19.

ETA-My oldest is actually one of the YOUNGEST in his class (summer birthday) and he is 7 and in 2nd grade. Most kids in his grade are turning or have turned 8 already. What you are describing age wise is not remotely the norm.
 
There must be a difference in starting age and/or birthday cut off where you live. My DH has taught middle school (7th/8th grade) for 12 years and 11 years old in 7th grade is very very uncommon based on age cutoffs and the district does not allow children to enter early..no testing, no exceptions. He can't recall ever having an 11 year old in 7th grade.

11-12 is generally 6th grade..10-11 is 5th grade (approximately). So based on the average ages/cut offs here it would put her 2 grades behind at most.

No 16 year old would be a senior (12th grade) here unless they were advanced early/skipped grades. 16 is generally sophmore year (most kids go 15-16 sophmore year, 16-17 junior year (11th grade) and 17-18 senior year (12th grade) but with later birthdays some are at 19.

ETA-My oldest is actually one of the YOUNGEST in his class (summer birthday) and he is 7 and in 2nd grade. Most kids in his grade are turning or have turned 8 already. What you are describing age wise is not remotely the norm.

That's how it is in my district. DS is 9 in the 4th grade and will turn 10 in July. The cutoff here is Sept 1st, so he is one of the youngest. My niece is one of the oldest in her class as her birthday is Sept 4th. She is in 1st grade this year and is 7 years old. She will turn 8 shortly after school begins next year.

So, even though DS and DN are only 2 years and a month apart, they are 3 grades apart.

To keep this on-topic, my youngest DS9 is allowed free reign of the neighborhood - and has been for quite some time. We have a lot of boys around his age, so they are constantly going to each others houses to play basketball, baseball, ride bikes, scooters, etc. I love our neighborhood for that reason! :love:
 
There must be a difference in starting age and/or birthday cut off where you live. My DH has taught middle school (7th/8th grade) for 12 years and 11 years old in 7th grade is very very uncommon based on age cutoffs and the district does not allow children to enter early..no testing, no exceptions. He can't recall ever having an 11 year old in 7th grade.

11-12 is generally 6th grade..10-11 is 5th grade (approximately). So based on the average ages/cut offs here it would put her 2 grades behind at most.

No 16 year old would be a senior (12th grade) here unless they were advanced early/skipped grades. 16 is generally sophmore year (most kids go 15-16 sophmore year, 16-17 junior year (11th grade) and 17-18 senior year (12th grade) but with later birthdays some are at 19.

ETA-My oldest is actually one of the YOUNGEST in his class (summer birthday) and he is 7 and in 2nd grade. Most kids in his grade are turning or have turned 8 already. What you are describing age wise is not remotely the norm.

All the kids that are born in Sept, Oct, Nov and Dec 1st will be 16 for the first 3 months of their senior year. They also start kindergarten at 4 since the cut off is not until Dec-so for the first 1/3 of the school year they are 4 years old. My daughter started right when she was supposed to-no early testing to get in or anything just a regular kid starting on time and she will be 16 as a senior for the first 1/3 of the school year.
 
Where do you live?

Kids here (Massachusetts) have to be at least 5 by September 1st and no older than 6 to enter Kindergarten. Therefore it's not possible for a child to be 7 in 3rd grade here.....most would be turning 9 at some point during the year; some 10 if their parents (or the system) held them back a year. It was no different than when I went to school here (100 yrs ago). Most everyone I knew was 18+ at graduation. Your system sounds like the extreme to me :)

Here in Michigan the cutoff is December 1, so there are a lot of kids starting school at 4. My older two are on the extremes of the age range for their grades - DS turned 10 in 3rd grade due to a combination of a just-missed-the-cutoff birthday and being held back before we had a dx that explained his reading difficulties. DD, on the other hand, was 8 all the way through 3rd grade and will graduate high school before turning 18, but she has classmates who are younger than her by 2-3 months.
 
All the kids that are born in Sept, Oct, Nov and Dec 1st will be 16 for the first 3 months of their senior year. They also start kindergarten at 4 since the cut off is not until Dec-so for the first 1/3 of the school year they are 4 years old. My daughter started right when she was supposed to-no early testing to get in or anything just a regular kid starting on time and she will be 16 as a senior for the first 1/3 of the school year.

This is how it is done here too, so this is the norm here. Parents do have the option of delayed start, so they don't have to enroll their 4 year old, they can wait until the following year when they are 5.
My dses were 4 when they started Kindergarten and will be 16 when they begin their Senior year of HS, although they will be 17 when they graduate. My dd's birthday was after the Dec.1 cut off so she'll be 17/18 her Sr. year.
 
Our schools have a 5 by Dec. 1st cut off for starting K. So there are 11 year olds at the beginning of 7th grade. We also have a program called young 5's, which really doesn't make sense to me. The title is wrong. The kids still have to be 5 by Dec. 1st just like the regular K students. It is for kids who aren't ready for K. So there are kids who are starting K when they are 4, and some who are starting K when they are 6 (due to spending a year in young 5's.)


My oldest DS started 6th grade when he was 10, and turned 11 in December.
 
Here they just have to be 5 (for K) the day school starts. It started Aug 29th my dd's bday was Aug 22. We also have full day prek so you have to be 4 the day school starts for that.. its not low income full day pre-k, its all incomes just to clarify :)
 
On our street, kids pretty much play out front (and even up and down the block) once they are in Kindergarten.

My DD is 9 and she rides her bike to and from school, plays on our street and the connecting street and can ride to the library or ice cream shop (all with a friend or friends, but not alone).

We have a lot of kids on our block and there is only 1 child that isn't allowed to do these things, he is 9 also. I feel sorry for him because he basically watches out his window as all the other kids play.
 
All the kids that are born in Sept, Oct, Nov and Dec 1st will be 16 for the first 3 months of their senior year. They also start kindergarten at 4 since the cut off is not until Dec-so for the first 1/3 of the school year they are 4 years old. My daughter started right when she was supposed to-no early testing to get in or anything just a regular kid starting on time and she will be 16 as a senior for the first 1/3 of the school year.

Wow..yeah no they don't do that here (even when I was a kid over 30 years ago the cut off was the same but less stringently enforced). You must be 5 by Sept 1 to start Kinder. School generally starts in Mid August so only if the birthday falls in the couple weeks between start of school and Sept 1 would a child be under 5 in Kinder (my DH was like this..early August birthday..graduated at 17 and then turned 18 later that summer). In general most kids that close to the deadline wait until the next year and are older not younger.
 
There must be a difference in starting age and/or birthday cut off where you live. My DH has taught middle school (7th/8th grade) for 12 years and 11 years old in 7th grade is very very uncommon based on age cutoffs and the district does not allow children to enter early..no testing, no exceptions. He can't recall ever having an 11 year old in 7th grade.

11-12 is generally 6th grade..10-11 is 5th grade (approximately). So based on the average ages/cut offs here it would put her 2 grades behind at most.

No 16 year old would be a senior (12th grade) here unless they were advanced early/skipped grades. 16 is generally sophmore year (most kids go 15-16 sophmore year, 16-17 junior year (11th grade) and 17-18 senior year (12th grade) but with later birthdays some are at 19.

ETA-My oldest is actually one of the YOUNGEST in his class (summer birthday) and he is 7 and in 2nd grade. Most kids in his grade are turning or have turned 8 already. What you are describing age wise is not remotely the norm.

My son was 11 for three months of six grade. He has a Dec birthday and the cut off was Dec. 31. He started high school at 13 and graduated at 17. He never skipped a grade.
 
When my children were little the cut off for starting kindergarten was December 31. My youngest is a December baby and he started K at a very young 4. He was such a baby too, it really was much too soon for him but that was the way it was done then. Now the cut-off is Sept. 1, a child actually has to be 5 by the start of Kindergarten, which makes sense.

I let the kids play outside without me when the oldest was about 10. Individually they could have run of the neighborhood at 10/11. We live in a safe neighborhood but on a busy street so I was never really comfortable with them playing in our front yard, I would rather they go to their friend's house to play since they were on a less busy street.
 
Last summer was the first time I let my kids play out in the frontyard by themselves - they were 7 & 9, and I count on them to tattle on each other when they are doing something wrong. I know I'm pretty uptight about it though.

As for ages, my DS was born 10/4, and started kindergarten when he was 4. We thought he was ready, he is super tall for his age (and was then, too), and DH was a Halloween baby who started when he was 4 and did fine. If I had it to do over again, I'd have waited a year because he's just turned 10, and almost done with 5th grade, and headed to middle school when he's 10:scared:. I want to wrap him in a coccoon to protect him this fall.;)
 
My son was 11 for three months of six grade. He has a Dec birthday and the cut off was Dec. 31. He started high school at 13 and graduated at 17. He never skipped a grade.

See here that wouldn't happen because he couldn't have started Kinder because he wasn't 5 by Sept 1st. That is our cut off and why the ages seem so "off" to me as kids with Sept/Oct/Nov/Dec birthdays do not enter until they are 5 almost 6 not at 4 almost 5. This has been the cut off since I was starting school over 30 years ago. Now back in my day they let kids test in..now they don't (at least my kids district doesn't allow it..no exceptions to the deadline).
 
One of my ds's has a late Sept. birthday. The district we lived in when he started 5K had a cut off date of 12/31. The district he graduated from has a cut off date of 9/1. That made him one of the youngest in his class every year from 8th grade to 12th. He wasn't thrilled, but I loved it! He couldn't leave school without me getting a call that night, he couldn't drive to school in 10th grade (legal driving age is 15 here), he couldn't sign up for stupid classes unless I knew about it, etc, etc. He was more then ready to start school and wasn't small for his age, so there were never any issues about his maturity or readiness in any grade.

On the original topic, it all depended on where we lived. My oldest boys were in 3 school districts between 5K and 1st/2nd grade, so we had pretty frequent moves back then. If we lived in a country area, off the main road, they had to be where I could hear them or I had to know where they were going before they left. If we lived on a main road, they had to stay in the fenced in back yard because the traffic was really bad, there were no sidewalks, and the house was surrounded by woods so a driver wouldn't see them running out. Where we live now is very rural. It's a 5 mile dead end road with a lot of sharp curves. The younger kids are 13, 13, 9, and 6. The 2 oldest have the run of the road. The younger 2 don't leave the property without an older kid with them. I'm not afraid of them being snatched, I'm afraid of the curves and teen drivers. They're also not allowed to far into the woods or fields on our property without an older kid because of the snakes. The 9 yr old never looks where she's going and the 6 yr old would try to bring home a copper head if he could catch one!
 
So, Indiana has had one of the earliest kindergarten cutoff dates (and the oldest kindergarteners). The cutoff for my daughter was July 1. Her b-day fell less than two weeks after the cutoff. We didn't push her through "early" so she was six when she started K. She will turn 19 two months after graduation.

On the flip side, I did allow my kids to play in front of the house by about 5 without my supervision. They were required to stay on our side of the sidewalk (what I felt was a safe distance from the road) and in our own yard unless they asked permission to go to a neighbor's yard. They were coached endlessly on NOT going into the street after a ball, etc. lol.

By 7 & 9, I let them ride bikes around our small town with a cousin who was 10. They did okay, kept in touch by phone, but did have a couple accidents which may have been prevented with adult supervision :rolleyes1 (a bike wreck resulting in a broken nose and a swimming accident that required a couple stitches). They handled these accidents in a mature manner for a pack of kids, so I never felt the need to take back their freedom, just chalked it up to a learning experience.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom