at what age did your child stop breastfeeding?

barkley

DIS Veteran<br><font color=orange>If I ever have a
Joined
Apr 6, 2004
Messages
21,117
i had to wait at dd's doctor's office yesterday and picked up a parenting magazine to read. there was an article about a woman who has been continuously breast feeding for 17 years. her youngest is now 6 1/2 and she has had the practice with all 3 of her children to not stop breastfeeding until the child no longer wanted to (said the other 2 stopped around 6). she felt that it was a comforting mechanism for her child and did it on demand-any time, any place (she was vocal that she refused to stop doing so in public venus such as the mall and that she was very angry when at age 4 her dd's school demanded she stop doing so in view of other students/parents-felt it was natural and did not need to "hidden away").

she said she gave the kids all the appropriate foods at the appropriate ages, but allowed them free access to her breast milk so long as they wanted.

the m.d.'s who were consulted said that as long as the child was getting appropriate nutrition there was no medical problem-but they hesitated to comment on it furrther.

so at what age was your child when they stopped breastfeeding? did you initiate it? did the child? do you think this woman's behaviour is appropriate?

my opinion is that a 6 1/2 year old should have developed self comforting mechanisms that do not include breastfeeding. i would have serious concerns about this child's emotional development when she is encouraged to utlize what is generaly an infanitle manner to de-stress/cope (the mom's words not mine). i would also wonder what effect the mom's public doing of this/making others aware of it (apparantly she is very vocal about the practice and it is common knowledge among the child's teachers/classmates) would have socialy on the child (i tend to think the child has to "cope" allot with the teasing she has to be experiencing).

interested in hearing everyone's opinions.
 
I will keep my mouth shut. I will keep my mouth shut. I will keep my mouth shut. :rotfl:
 
the first at a year the second at 8 months, both time initiated by the child. With the upcoming third I'll be lucky to make it to 6 months since I will be working.
 
popcornsmilie.gif
 

Sorry if Im going to offend anybody. But, breastfeeding a 6 yr old is GROSS!!! I dont care what the world breastfeeding association said, or what LLL said. Thats just gross.
I do believe breastmilk is best, no doubt about it. But, I think enough is enough. I breastfed my 2nd for 14 months, and my youngest is almost 17 months and still breastfeeds 2 times a day. Im really getting to a point now that "enough is enough".
I think when a child is 6 yrs old and is still breastfeeding that more for the mother then child.
Ok, people bash away :rotfl:
 
Both DDs nursed for about 4 months - I had a six month maternity leave, but they both got a bottle occasionally, and they both gave it up around the same time. I'm totally for breastfeeding as an option for a mom, but I'm not militant about it, and realize that some moms prefer a bottle for a variety of reasons. No judgements here!!!!

Having said that, 6 years old crosses my personal comfort level by a country mile. I'd have to say anything over the age of 18 months to 2 years old always makes me wonder if the mom has another agenda going on, other than just feeding a baby.

Just my opinion...
 
I stopped BFing both of mine at age one.

And I would love to have some of that popcorn...this will be a doozy!!!
 
Oh, gosh this could get interesting but I guess I will post anyway.

I nursed ds until 15 months. I will likely nurse this next one until closer to 2 years, as ds had some minor ear issues that the ped. said likely would not have been an issue had I not stopped bfing when I did. From what I have heard, world health organization recommends until age 2; american academy of pediatrics recommends at least a year.

As far as the 6.5 year old, I have a very hard time telling anyone what is or is not appropriate with their own child. There really isnt a 'right' answer as far as the perfect age to quit. Is 9 months okay but 10 months weird? What about 15 months okay but 16 months weird? Or 24 months okay but 26 weird? 30 months okay but 36 weird? It is hard to determine that 'exact' moment when another parent should stop; I do believe it is a personal decision.

That being said, of course that mother has passed what I as a parent would be comfortable doing (and she passed that point quite a while ago). I hear all of your concerns Barkley, and I identify with them. I would worry about many of the same things.

I saw a story like this on Dr. Phil once. I think it is almost unfortunate when there is a story such as this, as it does seem very 'taboo', especially for people who are already a little squeamish about bfing. I would hate for this type of story to influnce anyone's feelings about one's decision to bf their children. Unfortunately, this is the type of story that gets in your head and never leaves.
 
Off topic....
I'm placing my bet now for 3 pages max... anyone else?

On topic...
6 years old and still breastfeeding....child abuse.
 
9 mos and I'm a WOHM. DD didn't care how she got fed as long as she got fed. :rotfl2:

I think when a child is 6 yrs old and is still breastfeeding that more for the mother then child.
Ok, people bash away

I wasn't going to be the first to say it, but I'm happy to be the second :rotfl:
 
DS.... a couple of months due to health problems early on that requirred him taking a bottle for the first 2 weeks. He never learned to latch on so I pumped and giave it to him in a bottle

DD... just shy of her 2nd bday. Completely child led weaning. would have nursed as long as she wanted to. I know many that nurse until age 4 or so. They have no "infintile manner" what ever the op meant by that, and are all physically and mentally healthy childrem.

However I do understand and somewhat agree with the OP's opinion about the mother being very vocal about it. For example, as much as I believe in child led weaning, I did not stand behind the woman who lost custody of her child after being court ordered to stop breastfeeding him. I believe the case started when he was about 7 and continued until he was 9 or so.
 
Madison was 21 months-it was just a few weeks ago, 12/11/05 was her last 'drink'. Timing worked out well for me as baby #2 was conceived about a week before that and I didn't ever plan to nurse while pregnant. I had planned on trying for a year when she was born, but then we planned a 3 week vacation for when she was 13-14 months so I didn't want to wean her till after we got home (she is very thin, 20th percentile for weight but 85th for height, and does not eat very well when we're away from home cause she gets very distracted) so then I was going for 15 months. Around 15 months we had cut back to just once a day, 1st thing in the morning, and that lasted everyday till around 20 months, partially due to my own laziness. Madison would climb into my bed around 5am, nurse, then sleep till around 6/6:30 when we get up for her preschool. So rather than stay up starting at 5am I let the nursing continue. Then around 20 months she didn't ask everyday so it went to maybe 3-4 times a week and then after about a month of that it was done. I just started getting up before her in the morning and then she didn't even think about it when she woke up. So I guess sorta led by me, but I think she was ready too. When I first started around 14 months she wasn't too thrilled, but she seemed to accept it more as time went on (plus I really wonder how much milk I had at the very end, past mid-November). With this next baby I'm hoping to wrap things up between about 15 and 18 months because after about 18 months with Madison I had reached the point where I was ready to be done.
 
4cruisin said:
Off topic....
I'm placing my bet now for 3 pages max... anyone else?

On topic...
6 years old and still breastfeeding....child abuse.
You betcha ;)
 
Somewhere between 21-22 months with DD. She was down to only a couple times a day at that point. By the time I weaned her I was very ready to be done and she was ready too. She didn't put up much of a fight. I plan on trying to go that long with DS. If it is sooner it will be because one of us can't take it any more! :D

DVCLiz-No agenda. I see nothing wrong with BFing a 2 year old.

Personally I wonder about the 3 year olds who are still in cribs. DD was in her own twin bed at at 1.5. To each their own!
 
I'm sorry, I have a 5yo and I can't imagine him breastfeeding. I don't care what anyone says I think it's gross.
 
Duckfan-in-Chicago said:
My mother still pumps, I'm in my 30's and I support Lyndon LaRouche

Serious (no sarcasm) what does the pumping, if you no longer have a child whom breast feeds, do? Whats the purpose?

I stopped at about 6 months, with both. Simply cuz they were feeding more then I could handle. And when I was lactating, my "bottles" were enourmous. Just gigantic and I had to use both hands to do so, otherwise I'd smother my child.

Doctor "*HOW* did the baby suffocate?"

So it became hours of feeding, and not being able to do anything else.

That being said - Not my business how old a child is, if theyre still being breastfed. Not my kids (or "bottles)
 
14 months with one
12 months with the other...

Never used bottles or formula..neither would take them!!


I can see or even try until age 2, but 6 years is hard for me to stomach...
but, people being different is what makes the world go 'round!
 
Duckfan-in-Chicago said:
My mother still pumps, I'm in my 30's and I support Lyndon LaRouche

ROTFL! :rotfl2:

I agree with the poster who says at 6 years old it is for the Mother not the child.

Edited to Add: I bf 1 child for 6 weeks and the other for 2 weeks... it wasn't my "cup of tea"
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom