Spiceycat
I completely agree with your post. We made cash reservations for a 2 BR LV at the BLT in June. We were originally given room 7605. My heart sank when I looked out the big window and saw......the building in front of ours and a sliver of lake out to the left.
I called the front desk and informed them I was supposed to have a lake view. The lady on the phone informed me "Room 7605 is considered a Lake View and we have no other rooms available at this time." I told her the only way I'd feel okay about the view is if they removed the extra charge for a "lake view". The front desk put a manager on the phone and I explained the situation. She repeated the "If you can see the lake, it's a lake view" mantra. She was nice but really emphasized and wanted me to understand room 7605 is a "lake view". I was very nice and diplomatic on the phone but I don't care what they say, if 75% of my view is the building on the other side of the concourse, it's not a lake view and not worthy of the extra $$.
They did graciously move us to 7602 which was MUCH better. We had to wait until the room was ready but it was so worth the wait.
BTW, I loved BLT so much I now call it "home". It really was wonderful and for anyone trying to decide, there are SO MANY great fireworks viewing options, other than your balcony that I would never spend my points on an MK view. There's the TOTW and an outdoor terrace outside the CR, just before you cross the walkway to BLT (no special passes /
DVC cards needed for this) and of course, there's the walkway. Personally, I'd rather hop the 'rail to the Poly and view from the beach, then hop back to the CR.
My initial bad experience with this sketchy "lake view" room makes me nervous about even spending points on another lake view. I agree they really need to change the classification of those inner circle rooms and not consider them lake views.