Arizona couple loses bid to re-join Club 33

The best part about that article is the constant responses to comments being made by "soldout21" who is either one of the two Andersons or a very close friend (the poster keeps switching from the third person to the first person in their responses). It's quite entertaining.
 
When you can spend 30k for basically nothing for club 33 then I don't your going to get to much
The best part about that article is the constant responses to comments being made by "soldout21" who is either one of the two Andersons or a very close friend (the poster keeps switching from the third person to the first person in their responses). It's quite entertaining.
No the funny part is that people pay 30k per year for basically nothing.
 
When you can spend 30k for basically nothing for club 33 then I don't your going to get to much

No the funny part is that people pay 30k per year for basically nothing.
Funnier than spending $400K trying to get the "privilege" of spending that $30K per year back, and still losing? Best part is their ongoing delusion, hands-down. It's a delicious blend of abject stupidity and rampant hubris.
 
As a DLR fan, this line really bothered me:

"As a couple, they went on the Haunted House ride nearly 1,000 times."

C'mon LA Times...did you not do any research?! 🤣

I'll paste the article below for those that can't read it:
--------------------------------
As members of Disney’s exclusive Club 33, Scott and Diana Anderson visited the two Anaheim theme parks 60 to 80 times a year.

The private club, with its wood-paneled trophy room and other amenities, was the center of their social life. They brought friends, acquaintances and business associates. As a couple, they went on the Haunted House ride nearly 1,000 times.

The club’s yearly dues were $31,500, and with travel and hotel expenses, the Arizona couple were spending close to $125,000 annually to get their Disney fix.

All of it came to an end in 2017, when Disney revoked their membership in the club after an allegation that Scott Anderson was drunk in public. Diana Anderson, a hardcore Disney aficionado since childhood, called it “a stab in the heart.”

The Andersons, both 60, have spent the years since then — and hundreds of thousands of dollars — trying to get back into Club 33. On Tuesday, an Orange County jury rejected their claim that Disney ousted them improperly.

It had taken the Andersons more than a decade to gain membership in Club 33, which includes access to exclusive lounges, dining, VIP tours and special events.

They finally made it off the waiting list in 2012.

At about 9:50 p.m. on Sept. 3, 2017, security guards found Scott Anderson near the entrance of California Adventure displaying signs of what they took to be intoxication, including slurred speech and trouble standing, according to trial testimony.

“His breath smelled of alcohol quite a lot,” one of the guards said in court.

The club swiftly ousted them.

Macias said Scott Anderson had 2½ to 3 drinks and that Disney did an incomplete and slipshod investigation, with no Breathalyzer or blood tests and no videos of Anderson’s behavior that night.

“They have not established that Mr. Anderson was intoxicated,” Macias said. Instead, he argued, Anderson’s symptoms were the result of a vestibular migraine, which can be triggered by red wine — among the drinks Anderson consumed that day.

In effect, Macias argued, Disney was punishing Anderson for a medical condition.

A medical expert testified for the Andersons that the symptoms of a vestibular migraine could be confused with intoxication, with a neurologist hired by Disney countering that Anderson’s behavior was more likely the consequence of drinking.

The September 2017 incident was not the first time the Andersons had run afoul of Club 33 management. The year before, Diana had been briefly suspended for “using some salty language … a couple F-words,” as Macias put it.

Macias told jurors that the Andersons filed suit against Disney to vindicate their reputation. “He doesn’t want to be known as a drunk,” Macias said. “They love that place. They took the fight to Disney because it’s his name.”

In their complaint, the Andersons asked to be reinstated to Club 33, with a $10,500 reimbursement for four months of unused membership in 2017. They also wanted $231,000 — the equivalent of seven years in the club.

Jonathan E. Phillips, an attorney representing Disney, said that Club 33 membership guidelines forbid public intoxication.

“They did not want to pay the consequences of failing to follow the rules,” Phillips told jurors, adding that Scott Anderson’s conduct “cost his wife of 40 years her lifetime dream of having access to Club 33.”

The security guards, who no longer work for Disney, were more credible than the Andersons, Phillips said — “What possible reason did the security guards have to lie to you?”

In their original complaint, the Andersons alleged that Club 33 targeted them for retaliation because they had complained about a club member harassing other members and staff. But Superior Court Judge Deborah Servino curtailed that line of evidence, which the Andersons saw as the death knell for their case.

“My wife and I are both dead set that this is an absolute wrong, and we will fight this to the death,” Scott Anderson, who owns a golf course in Gilbert, Ariz., told The Times. “There is no way we’re letting this go.”

He said the lawsuit has cost him about $400,000.

“My retirement is set back five years,” he said. “I’m paying through the nose. Every day, I’m seeing another bill, and I’m about to keel over.” He said he will appeal.

His wife said she wants to keep fighting.

“I’ll sell a kidney,” Diana said. “I don’t care.”
 
The most surprising part to me is that they would want to rejoin something that clearly doesn't want them. I get that Disneyland is an addiction, but they could be enjoying lots of other things there instead, like staying in the Adventureland Suite whenever they visit.

I have the vertigo migraines that they are claiming are the cause of appearing drunk. I've had days where I could drive or walk, but I have never appeared drunk. Also, when I am even just the slightest bit symptomatic, I know not to drink alcohol, especially red wine. It would ruin the entire trip!
 
Honestly. Some people really do have more money than sense.

They should have given me $400,000. I wouldn't have been able to get them back into Club 33, but it would have gone to better use than what it has so far.
Amen - many of us on here could do better with the $400k! The thought that crosses my mind is that just because they're spending all this money doesn't mean they actually have all this money. Maybe some debt behind the scenes!
 
As a DLR fan, this line really bothered me:

"As a couple, they went on the Haunted House ride nearly 1,000 times."

C'mon LA Times...did you not do any research?! 🤣
That is an odd mistake, considering how famous the Haunted Mansion is.

Yet just in the first paragraph, the reporter refers to "the two Anaheim theme parks," which demonstrates a good knowledge of the Disneyland Resort.
 
I wasn't able to read it via LA Times but just searched the internet to find the article. They've spent $400K to get back in and they wanted Disney to pay them for the years that they weren't members?!
Yeah, that last part makes no sense. Why would Disney "reimburse" them for seven years of dues they didn't pay because they weren't members during that time???
 
That is an odd mistake, considering how famous the Haunted Mansion is.

Yet just in the first paragraph, the reporter refers to "the two Anaheim theme parks," which demonstrates a good knowledge of the Disneyland Resort.
Maybe...the article was somewhat made by AI?

Because it is strange to know there are two parks but not call the Haunted Mansion by name...because only none locals call it a haunted house or an AI that is using online info
 
What a complete waste of money and time for Disney legal department to deal with truly insane guests like this. Glad they were kicked out of the Club and hope never set foot in theme park again.

Imagine dealing with someone like that in daily life- fight to death and sell kidney? Seriously.

(yes most likely AI written with quick unpaid intern review)
 
None of this makes much sense to me. What did his alleged drunkenness near DCA have to do with getting kicked out of Club 33? Is there a list of members with the security people so the Club can be alerted when someone gets plastered? I can understand it if it happened within the club, but it doesn't sound like it was even in the park, though it was on Disney property (the espanade?).

Methinks there is more to this than meets the eye.

And c'mon, LA Times, the Club 33 trophy room hasn't been around in years :rolleyes2
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top