We had brought a LOT of Disney beanies on our March 2002 trip, as we had read that interesting things could happen with them - of course, with 3 girls, aged 5, 11, and 13 - we bought more throughout the week. The Mousekeeper at the CR was incredible! Every day we came back to a new scenario - they went on a picnic, hiking - watched TV - etc. We also got a couple of small towel animals during the week. My girls thought coming back to the room was the best part of the day. We did use the Mousekeeping envelopes with a tip, and although there are 5 of us, we did keep the room fairly tidy - just a quick makeup of the beds, and a vacuum, as well as the usual bathroom cleaning was needed. Everything was put away - so she didn't have to move things to clean.
When we went back in Dec - 2002 - we stayed at the CR - South Wing this time. No animal arranging, no towel animals, and the cleaning was not nearly as well done as in March. We then moved over to AKL Concierge - no towel animals, but we did receive turndown service every night - my oldest loved the little African proverbs they left with the mints. Not only were our animals not arranged - one day - my daughter's Eeyore from our first trip was missing!!!! I tried to reassure her that it must have gotten mixed up in the bedding. I asked the concierge to check with the laundry - he had me fill out a missing item report. When we returned that evening, there was Jennie's Eeyore, along with an identical (brand new) friend! I think the concierge wanted to replace Jennie's, while the real one had been found in the laundry. WoW!! Great service.
At the All-Stars, we also used our mousekeeping envelopes. The CM happened to be in the room when we returned the first afternoon - and wanted to know if this was truly for her, when we replied yes - her whole face lit up. I don't think that everyone tips! We did receive one towel duck from her during our stay.