Are any of these terrible?

[ready4mouse]

OK- I've fiddled and changed and stayed up way to many late nights trying to get this right! Please take a look at my ADR's and let me know if any of these are terrible restaurants that we should run from! Or, am I missing anything fabulous?
FYI- The cast is me, DH, DS9, DS5; we will be on the DxDDP; I know there's a lot of TS- it what the DH has requested...

Here's the lineup in no particular order

Breakfasts:
-Crystal Palace
-O'hana w/Lilo and Stitch
-Tusker House with Donald
-Cape May Cafe
-Boatwrights

Lunches:
-LeCellier
-Garden Grill
-Earl of Sandwich
-Wolfgang Pucks
-Tony's (only b/c we're meeting w/ another group and this is the only place in the MK that can hold us...)
-Prime Time Cafe
-Yak and Yeti

Dinners:
-Chef Mickeys
-Cinderellas Royal Table
-Hoop De Doo
-Chefs De France
-Boma
-Mama Melrose F!package
-Liberty Tree Tavern


I'd love to know what you think while I still hopefully have time to add/drop!
Thanks!

 

[Doc Goofy]

For every place you've chosen, you'll have those who LOVED it and those who HATED it! I've been to three of the ones you've chosen - Cape May, Chef Mickey, and Le Cellier - and liked them very much.

 

[InLoveWithTheBeast]

I've been to a few that you listed, pretty much everything at Disney is good. I would recommend that CRT is more for the atmosphere than the food. I wasn't in love with Donald's breakfast if that is the same one I've been to. We went to the Breakfastosaurus over the summer, and it was okay, but Crystal Palace was so much better.

 

[princessesrule4]

Our only other must do that I don't see on your list is California Grill.
It looks like you have a good variety! Have a great trip!

 

[hmillerbarilla]

Another vote for California Grill. We never miss it. Also, another favorite of ours is Kona at the Poly. REALLY fantastic.

I think your list looks good--CP made me crazy but I have a one year old and it was soooo busy when we went for dinner. If I go again, I'd try breakfast. Le Cellier is great, Chefs is one of my favorite places--Love it!

We also usually go to PTC, the pot roast is the best.

Looking forward to your reports on Cape May & Garden Grill. We want to try those next year. (we'll be on the deluxe plan too) Have fun!

 

[itchin2go]

I want to go with you! Sounds fantastic!

 

[Tricia1972]

For every place you've chosen, you'll have those who LOVED it and those who HATED it!

I couldn't agree more with the above statement! I'll give you my reviews mostly because almost all of them are positive. I promise you though, the one that I wasn't crazy about, you'll find at least 15 people who LOVE to eat there.


I have been to:
Crystal Palace - Great
LeCellier - Amazing
Earl of Sandwich - Fantastic Sandwiches
Wolfgang Pucks - Incredible Flatbread
Prime Time Cafe - FUN atmosphere, steak was more like leather and didn't like root hash - would still go back.
Chef Mickeys - Great character interaction. Food is always reliable. Nothing special, but nothing horrible either
Chefs De France - Only bad service I have ever received in Disney. Food was ok, but service was so bad that we won't be rushing back here.
Boma - Good Food - lots of interesting choices and a 'safe' way to try them
Mama Melrose F!package - LOVE the steak gorgonzola. Amazing food!
Liberty Tree Tavern - Good food. Loved the rolls, the rest was like a typical thanksgiving dinner.

 

[mama4]

I've only been to Crystal Palace and Earl of Sandwich of the places from your list. Crystal Palace was yummy for brkfast and for dinner and Earl is really good and a great bargain for Disney food. My sandwich was huge!

On our next trip we're trying CM, PrimeTime and 'Ohana (for dinner though-my kids aren't huge on character meals right now and 1 per trip is enough) We're really looking forward to it!!!

Your list looks fine to me! Enjoy!

 

[Doc Goofy]

Combining two of the posts above: I, too, am a big California Grill fan and was not impressed with Chefs de France (did not notice that on your list at first). So, if I were to change anything... it would be to switch those two out. BUT there are many Chefs de France fans out there who would disagree. And there are other considerations like where you'll be touring that day...

 

[disprincessatheart]

WOW - how many days is your trip? I can't imagine having the time or the stomach capacity to eat that many TS meals!

But to answer your actual question, here are my reviews on the ones below that I've eaten at - have a great trip!

Breakfasts:
-Crystal Palace - DF LOVES it, but we've only ever done lunch. Food is always good, not great

Lunches:
-LeCellier - KEEP THIS!! It's the hardest ADR to get and the most raved about. We're going on our disneymoon!
-Earl of Sandwich - Great sandwiches and great prices!
-Wolfgang Pucks - we've done it twice. First time we loved it, in Sept it was not as great, but good food
-Tony's (only b/c we're meeting w/ another group and this is the only place in the MK that can hold us...) - I liked it, but I ordered pasta. DF didnt' like it, but he ordered steak. I say stick with simple dishes

Dinners:
-Chef Mickeys - always fun and the food is simple but you can fill up
-Cinderellas Royal Table - Done it 5 times and would go every time if DF would let me. We liked the food, but it takes a while and they rush you out of there, so we dont' try to do it all the time
-Hoop De Doo - havent' been since i was a kid, but it was fun and I remember good country food
-Chefs De France - did this in Sept and it was just ok.

 

[OKWMom]

Breakfasts:
-Crystal Palace we do this every trip had one bad food experience and one bad service experience out of five visits


Lunches:
-LeCellier we've only had dinner here but it is on our "must do" for every trip
-Wolfgang Pucks we've been twice in the past year. Once was very good and once was not good (food and service)
-Tony's (only b/c we're meeting w/ another group and this is the only place in the MK that can hold us...) This is the only place on your list we really, really, hated. (Sorry) We went as a group of 8 and the service was HORRIBLE, it took forever to get our food and the ice cream had almost completely melted by the time it arrived at our table. DH refuses to try it again, but I've read reviews here were others love it, so.....
-Prime Time Cafe Again, we did dinner, not lunch, but we enjoyed the food and the antics. Our kids were wide eyed when our server told them to sit up straight and not to put their elbows on the table.


Dinners:
-Chef Mickeys I did dinner here once and it was ok. We make the breakfast a must-do each trip
-Chefs De France We've been there once and liked it

The others I haven't tried.

 

[Ashley80]

I have to agree with a couple of the others to skip Chefs de France. Food wasn't "bad" just not that great and I certainly wish we would have used our credits at a different restaurant. Was probably the lowest ranking restaurant in our opinion (besides Cantina de San Angel (Mexico counter service)-yuck!!).

The rest of your selection sounds great! We have been to most of those and will be hitting the others you have on our next trip in January. We can't wait!

 

[MickeyNicki]

The only two that I would drop would be Chef Mickey's and Mama Melrose. The food at CM was horrible and MM was just plain BLAH

 

[ntsammy5]

Good choices. Enjoy