There has been some clarification since the initial announcement, but it still isn't good.
While non-refundable "deposits" make sense for the resorts, as a consumer, it makes no sense. I refuse to pay for something that I may not be able to use due to unforeseen circumstances. I've had to cancel too many personal and business trips due to family crises--things
travel insurance would exclude--or unforeseen circumstances at work.
And they are still offering a "pig in a poke," with 4-month lead time and no specific AP rates. Great for Disney--they would have the money. Very poor option for the consumer.
I definitely support requiring one adult AP per room (possibly 2 rooms, as some families require two rooms). That would minimize one significant loophole.
Disney appears to be returning to their former arrogant ways--no room discounts (or very few and minimal amounts) and very high prices for everything. After my WDW trip in 1981, I didn't return for 22 years. As much as I enjoy the Disney experience, it was not a good value for the money. The Fairytale Package and AP discounts changed that. At this point, my November trip is on hold until this is clarified and if the clarification goes the way I expect, it will be cancelled. In that case, I seriously doubt I will visit WDW again unless they offer significant discounts when they discover business has declined significantly due to their own greed!
There are far too many vacation options available that offer better value!