Any suggestions? What were some of the things you discussed before making the decision?
I understand your frustration and concern! It took us atleast a year before we made the decision to just "go for it" and take them out and try home schooling. For us it was a hard decision because both DD's love school and their teachers and friends - but I had reached the decision that it wasn't the best for them. They weren't being challenged and there were some issues in the classroom -one DD's teacher was absent WAY too much, one teacher left the kids alone in the classroom way too often, etc. I also stuffed report cards into folders once and was startled that virtually every child in the class of fifth graders had all A's and B's! That sounds great, but as a former high school teacher myself, I know that means grade inflation and low expectations.
I did tell their teachers that we were thinking about homeschooling and they were very concerned - wanted us to stay - the principal called me, etc. - but I think i had already made up my mind. You might want to tell your school you are considering home schooling - maybe it will make them more concerned with answering your questions and communicating with you.
When we started k12, I did indeed find out that my daughters, especially the DD8 were behind. We had to work hard, especially in math, to get caught up before the CRCT's! They miss their friends and teachers - but we go back ocassionally and visit (we made sure to leave on a good terms). I would love to put them in a quality private school so they could have the "school" experience and be challenged, but can't afford that right now.
Home schooling has its pros and cons just like anything else. For a concerned parent who will put in the time, it can't be beat - you are giving one on one attention, you know exactly what she needs to work longer and harder on and can adjust accordingly. And as you mentioned, you can teach for 80% or even 100% comprehension - you don't have to move on because the rest of the class is moving on. And even if your child had a caring teacher, nobody cares more than you. The cons for us have been missing the friends and the whole set up of traditional school - although they don't seem to mind getting to sleep in a little later in the mornings or pajama Wednesdays

.
You could always try it for awhile and if it just doesn't work, maybe she could go back to school. Although make sure you give it atleast 2 months. I thought I was going to pull my hair out the first week or two - trying to get used to everything and figuring out the best way to do things - but it got MUCH better!
As far as attendance, do you have to be on a Monday thru Friday schedule or can you attend on Saturday and Sunday as well?
Once you took your children out of school-did you have to report to the school board that your were enrolling them in GVS as you would homeschool?
(does that question make sense?)
You are assigned to a teacher who keeps up with your progress, has web meetings with your kids once a month, sends emails, collects your portfolio assignments throughout the year, etc. I believe most of the teachers are very flexible with the schedule - as long as they see that you are doing what you are supposed to be doing and making progress. You can log in hours on Sat and Sunday. I've actually done that before myself. And, we changed our spring break from the second week in April (when it was scheduled for all k12ers) to May 4-8 with no problem (we're actually leaving this Sunday for WDW

My DH is in school and his break is next week - so it is really nice to have that flexibility)
I did tell the school and the school board that we were going to be doing k12. It was very easy - there was no paperwork or anything because k12 is a public online school - they keep up with our attendance and progress and report it to the board (another good thing about k12 - less work keeping your own records of everything to send to the state). I hope it works for you and you like it. Let me know if you think of any other questions. I'll be more than hapy to share what I know!
