And I'm the opposite of the last two posters. I've stayed on-site and just don't see the point. Too spendy for too little value, IMO.
Another issue I had was specifically with the hotel vs motel point. In a hotel you're inside, so anything going on anywhere just sticks around. In our case, I feel strongly that there had been cigarette-smoking going on, and from the way the room was when we checked in late, I think they were caught and kicked out for it. The smell hung around, and you could also smell weird smells in the hallways.
Whereas when you're in a motel, when you step outside you're outside, and nothing will linger with you!
We used the fancy pool once, and walked past the pools at the offsite hotels b/c we didn't feel that swimming was something we felt like doing. Service at the restaurant at the Anabella was FAR better than at PP, b/c you could just order "to go" rather than going through Room Service, which was required by PP (and the hefty room services charges that go along with it).
But ultimately, you have to figure out what you want, and then find things to match what you want. Same goes for the rest of your trip. Figure out places you want to go (cities or sites) then go back to your TA and see what she has within that category, rather than just going with what SHE says is worth seeing.
And with that I step aside, since I probably just made it harder.
