We have been seriously considering it. However, we have some time because ours do not lapse until July 2006. I absolultely DESPISE the new BRP. We like taking last minute trips, and given our careers it's not always possible to plan in advance. Sometimes we can, but I need to have the security of knowing I have a 5 or 7 day cancellation policy. Now, second thing...the passholder site sucks. I don't have time to screw around with it...I'd rather call the old fashioned way. But I digress...
We talked about it and did the math. We go 2-3 times a year and although the AP's have gone up in price considerably, we still save about $68 each versus buying MYW tickets with the park hopper option. I must park hop! So, unless the AP's go up again to the point where it doesn't make sense, we will probably renew. We'll just see what happens between now and July. I'm beginning to feel like changes are on the way - I think Disney is starting to see that BRP is not the answer to all answers.
One tip for you. Stay at the Swan or Dolphin. They don't play the Best Rate game. We called 5 weeks ago and booked a trip for Thanksgiving and got an AP rate. No non-refundable deposit, no stress, no strain. That's the way it should be!!!!!
THANK YOU SWAN/DOLPHIN.
PamNC