Yes, We cruised in October once. Our experience wasn't great though. BUT I've read here on the DIS that what we experienced wasn't normal. The temps were GREAT, but we sailed during a hurricane. Our itinerary was totally different from the normal eastern, and we went to CC twice. That was nice. But the seas were pretty rough. We were all sick, as I assume most would be if in the midst of 18-20 foot swells. Our most recent Western cruise was this past May. It was PERFECT in every way. Temps, and sea's were smooth as glass. Most likely, your cruise (IF you go in October) will be great. Like I said, ours wasn't normal. You will save boo coo's of $$ if you go in October, but I LOVED our May cruise. It is before the major part of the hurricane season starts!!