Same here!! I do tend to read more of the negative reviews than I do positive, and then try to put myself in their shoes and see if what happened to the reviewer was some kind of fluke or a regular practice, and then I think about if the same thing would bother me as much. DH and I are VERY laid back, and usually don't expect a lot out of a hotel other than a bed to sleep in. Sure, we want it to be clean & friendly and extra perks are nice, but with the amount of time we spend in our hotel sometimes can't justify a high price for things we're not going to use.
Same goes for restaurants reviews. I hate to admit this, but DH and I have very cheap taste in food. Before going to WDW for the first time, I had read several negative reviews about some of the places I was really looking forward to, only to find out that a lot of "foodies" travel to WDW and expect a bit more out of those places.
It really doesn't take a lot to please us!