My take, based on 2 dinners and one lunch:
Good burgers and meatloaf.
Good microbrews (welcome after a steady dose of the usual suspects at most other WDW spots). Wowzer's Wheat is my own favorite.
Service pretty ordinary, maybe even "poor"-a young waitstaff and management, who don't appear to care a whole lot if you enjoy yourself, or ever come back.
Drab inside. Next time we go, I'll opt for and outside spot on the Boardwalk.
Overall, a C-