loves to dive
DIS Legend
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2011
- Messages
- 13,327
I've had one for going on 3 years now (time to renew Sept. 20) and can't imagine not having one. When I first got mine I knew I was taking two trips that year and I always get Phs. At the time AAA and Disney were still speaking so I got a AAA discount on the AP. It worked out less than my ph's would have been, I think I was making two 5 night trips but I don't remember. The renewal is less than the pass so it just made sense to renew since, again I knew I'd be down twice the next year. I don't consider the discounts when making my decision since they are a moving target, especially the food ones. My upcoming trip is actually the first time I've used it for a room discount other than that first trip. Again, AAA and Disney were still speaking so I already had the trip booked with a AAA discount and when I got the AP turns out they were offering AP discounts which were better so I used it then. Every trip since then, it was better for me to use the general public discount and stack that with an Orbitz either 10% or 15% discount. My upcoming trip, I had booked a split stay with a general discount and Orbitz discount on top for 2 nights at CSR then 3 nights at Swan (I'm a Starwood member) but I used my AAA discount with Swan. That stuck until about 2 weeks ago when I decided to add a day to the beginning of the trip. No way I could keep Swan unless I changed that reservation to 4 nights, one of which was a CSR night already booked, then cancelled the CSR, which would give me a $25 cancellation fee with Orbitz and rebooked CSR. Turns out YC all of the sudden showed up for an AP discount that was less than what I was paying for Swan when I factored in parking since I drive. I could then cancel the Orbitz and book CSR through WDW with the same rate even with the Orbitz discount applied that I got through Orbitz and book YC. So adding a day only cost me what the CSR for that one day and the $25 cancellation fee, which was absorbed in the discount. I'm still playing around with changing it again to one night at CSR, one night at WL and keeping the 4 nights at YC. All with AP discounts.