Another tipping question

pwoodham

<a href="http://www.wdwinfo.com/dis-sponsor/"targe
Joined
Mar 1, 2002
Messages
312
Since valet parking is now only free to DVC members, what's the usual tip? Should I tip both when the car is parked and when it is retrieved or just once?
Also, I read on this board somewhere that the recommended tip for bringing luggage to the room is $3 per bag. We'll have 13 people, about 20 suitcases and about 20 carry-ons when we check in. Should I seriously tip $120??? I sure hope you say no!!
 
You will probably get different answers for both of these questions. We usually tip $2 both when we drop off the car and pick it up. We found this to get a bit expensive when we stayed at WL this last trip due to how many times we needed the car during the day. So we ended up parking the car ourselves towards the middle of our stay. We've always tipped $1-2 per bag to the person who brings the bags up to the room. Sometimes we give a bit extra if they give exceptional service. The only problem is that the person who gets your bags out of your car will usually not be the person that brings them to the room. This always gives me a headache deciding how much to tip each person. This last trip we had 7 bags to bring in (most of them were very small) so I tipped the person who unloaded $5 and the person who brought them up $5. I'm sure that there are others who would have tipped more, but we had everything right in the trunk to unload and the person who brought them up just unloaded the bags right at the door.
 
We ususally tip $2/bag to get our luggage to our room. The last BWV trip they put our bags in storage right away. Well, our room was ready and we could have taken the bags right up. We tipped the second bellman only $1/bag. I think we will tip $1/bag to get them out of the car and another when they get to the room. DH is a very generous tipper when he gets extra help, like with my ECV or a bellman noticing we didn't have an umbrella as we started out in the rain and got us one without being asked.
Tipping is our way of giving the magic back(within reason LOL)
 
The valet tipping question does indeed have several "answers". Many guidebooks and Internet travel sites recommend tipping only the valet who brings your car to you--$2.00 is the suggested amount. The rationale seems to be that this is the person who actually performs the "service", and you are certain that he is the person who did perform the service. When you drop off your car for valet parking, you really can't be sure if the fellow who takes your keys and gives you the parking slip will actually be the person parking your car. Often your car will sit for awhile, and it is possible that the guy you just tipped won't do anything to deserve it--someone else will wind up taking your car to the lot.
That said--I tip $2.00 both ways, just like Nanjo1. Mostly because I know that valets don't share tips at WDW, and secondly because I'm a nice guy.
 

I tip $2 both ways, as long as they are prompt. I tip the bellman (valet) who takes the bags out of the car $1 per bag ($5) and the one who brings them to/from the room the same.

With 40 bags, you're going to need more than one bellman and you'll also have to split them out by what room they are going to. If you are arriving at at time when your room will be ready, I would take the carryons yourself, it might be less confusing.
 
Thanks for the info. I was thinking of $2 per "car park/retrieve," so I'm glad that's more or less a consensus.

As for the bags, we'll be arriving about 3 pm and going straight to the HDDR, so unless they have both our rooms ready (unlikely), the bags will have to be stored, including the majority of the carry-ons. I really wasn't thinking about the fact that at least two people (I assume) will be handling our luggage and it seems to me sometimes it just appears in the room and we don't see the bellman who delivered it. Has that happened to you? Should I tip the guy at the bellstand in that case, in addition to the one who takes it from the car?

My husband and I feel like we should be responsible for the tipping, because then we're sure it will happen. Not that the other people in our group wouldn't tip, but they may inadvertantly forget, and some don't travel enough to be aware of the expectations.
 
At BWV or anywhere else we've stayed at WDW, they've never delivered the luggage to the room without us being there. Will you be arriving in separate cars/vans? With 13 people, I assume that you will have more than 1 room (unless it's a grand villa). I'm just wondering how they will separate the luggage to deliver it to the proper rooms, they could be spread apart and even on different floors.
 
/
I don't know if they have started a new policy, but the last two trips that we stayed at WL and BWV they wouldn't deliver our bags until we called from the room when it was ready. I was assuming this was to make sure that the bags were delivered to the correct room and to insure that bell service received a tip. Do they still deliver luggage to an empty room?
 
Tips on Tipping
Source: American Society of Travel Agents, Alexandria, Va.
Who do you tip? When? How much?

These are the questions that have nagged at consumers since the first service transaction. The practice of tipping is meant as a form of thank-you for services rendered, or beforehand as a subtle bribe for special treatment.

Tipping need not be considered mandatory or automatic. Too often, tips are taken for granted or expected regardless of the quality of service. Tipping should be done at your discretion and as a reward for good or superlative service.

Below are some tipping suggestions for travelers. At nearly every step of the traveling process, there are professionals waiting to “lighten your load” or provide assistance. So remember to carry a lot of change and small bills for tips.

Taxi/Limo Drivers: A $2 to $3 tip is usually satisfactory; more if he helps you with your bags and/or takes special steps to get you to your destination on time.

Porters: A standard tip for airport and train porters is $1 per bag; more if your luggage is very heavy.

Hotel Bellman: Again, $1 per bag is standard. Tip when he shows you to your room and again if he assists you upon checkout. Tip more if he provides any additional service. Note: A $5 tip upon arrival can usually guarantee you special attention should you require it.

Doorman: Typically, a $1 tip for hailing a taxi is appropriate. However, you may want to tip more for special service, such as carrying your bags or shielding you with an umbrella.

Concierge: Tip for special services such as making restaurant or theater reservations, arranging sightseeing tours, etc. The amount of the tip is generally dependent on the type and complexity of service(s) provided—$2 to $10 is a standard range. You may elect to tip for each service, or in one sum upon departure. If you want to ensure special treatment from the concierge, you might consider a $10–$20 tip upon arrival.

Hotel Maid: Maids are often forgotten about when it comes to tipping because they typically do their work when you are not around. For stays of more than one night, $1 per night is standard. The tip should be left in the hotel room in a marked envelope.

Parking Attendants: Tip $1 to $2 when your car is delivered.

Waiters: 15–20% of your pre-tax check is considered standard. The same applies for room service waiters. Some restaurants will automatically add a 15% gratuity to your bill, especially for large parties—look for it before tipping. If the 15% is added, you need only tip up to another 5% for superlative service.

Cloakroom Attendants: If there is a charge for the service, a tip is not necessary. However, if there is no charge, or extra care is taken with your coat and/or bags, a $1 to $2 tip is appropriate.

Tour Guides/Charter Bus Drivers: If a tip is not automatically included, tip $1 for a half-day tour, $2 for full-day tour, and anywhere from $5 to $10 for a week-long tour. Tip a private guide more.

These are some of the people you are most likely to encounter while traveling in the U.S. Undoubtedly there will be others. If there is one standard rule in tipping it is this: If someone renders special service to you along the way, show your appreciation with a tip.

NOTE: International travelers should be aware that tipping customs outside the U.S. are often very different. Consult travel guides for the country you are visiting.
 















New Posts





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top