Another stupid Disney lawsuit..

johare

DIS Veteran
Joined
Aug 30, 1999
Messages
895
Suit: Disney stole pass idea

What's wrong with these people? If I give my feedback somewhere with my idea to make something I enjoy even more enjoyable, I'd be happy to see my idea used....I wouldn't sue for it.

Besides...how can this fool claim that this whole concept was uniquely his? When going to restaurants, you can have a reservation and be seated sooner, or you can wait (aka standby) for a table to come up. Same thing if you go for a haircut or to have your car serviced. You can make an appointment for the next open timeslot or you can sit there and wait standby.
 
Not me. I would have definitely stuck that in a box somewhere. Not so much in case I needed it for a lawsuit. Its just not everyday that you get a written rebuke from a company like Disney.

I don't pretend to know what really happened here, but I know I've seen statements from Disney about how they simply do not accept unsolicited ideas and will not evaluate them.

I guess that policy started after 1991?
 
Can someone post the article ? I don't feel like signing up for an O.S. account. Thanx.
 

After Robert Keyes watched a man pass out in a ride queue at Disney-MGM Studios, he had an epiphany, he said: Theme park visitors do not have to stand in line.

So, according to a patent lawsuit Keyes filed this month in federal court in Orlando, he sent a letter to Disney executives in 1991 describing a system that would allow some theme-park visitors to wait in a "standby" line but give others a ticket to return later and avoid the wait.

A top Disney executive sent him a letter back a month later, telling him the idea wouldn't work and would result in "more guest inconvenience," according to Keyes' lawsuit.

Nearly a decade later, in 1999, Disney introduced FastPass, an automated system that gives visitors a ticket so they can skip the long lines at its parks' most popular rides. The invention has been copied across the industry.

Now Keyes alleges that Disney stole his idea, and he is seeking credit and unspecified damages.

"After Disney told me this thing didn't work, that it wouldn't work, and that it was an inconvenience for the customer, they went out and patented it," said Keyes, who owned a small textile company in Sarasota before moving to Tennessee a few years ago.

A Disney spokeswoman said Thursday the company was still evaluating the lawsuit and would not comment further.

In an interview Thursday, Keyes said he has been to Walt Disney World maybe 50 times, but his last visit was in 1997. Last October, while baby-sitting his grandson in Sarasota, he said, he came across a Travel Channel special on Disney's FastPass program.

"I said, 'Doggone it! That's the same doggone system,' " he said. He found Disney's FastPass patent -- granted in 2001 -- on the Internet, dug out the old letters, and contacted a lawyer. Keyes and his lawyers would not provide copies of those letters Thursday.

It is not the first time Disney has been sued for allegedly stealing an idea.

In 2000, jurors concluded that Disney had stolen the idea for its Wide World of Sports complex and ordered the company to pay $240 million to two businessmen who had pitched a similar idea to the company years before.

Disney is a frequent target of lawsuits alleging intellectual-property theft. In the past, it has been accused of stealing the idea for Epcot as well as for magazines and movie scripts.
 
About three years ago I e-mailed Disney that I thought it would be great if they had a branded Visa or M/C that offered rebated Disney Dollars. I explained how the GM card program allowed 5% in cash rebates and the result has been increased auto sales for GM. I even stated that I wasn't looking for anything in return for my suggestion, that I was certain they were entertaining similar thoughts and that I'm sure this was not an original.

Well, several days- maybe a month- I get a very kert,snippy and legalise e-mail that basically said "we didn't ask for your input, we don't want your input, leave us the hell alone !!! "

It didn't offend me because I know the type of world we live in today.
 
Did the guy try to patent the [Fastpass] idea himself way back then? It is not necessary to have a fully operating system complete with kiosks, and it is not necessary to have customers purchase the system in advance; a manually operated model with the written statement that ticket printing machines could be used is sufficient.

Idea for Carousel of Progress:
http://members.aol.com/ajaynejr/disney.htm
 












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom