Another news item for the "Fragile Kids" debate.

Maybe- but that would be the correct path for her to take if she thought the teacher did something wrong- calling 911, not so much.

Besides, you have to give the office something to get a chuckle over.

:laughing:


But I still disagree. The correct path would be for the girl to get over herself.
 
Because in my book, rattling a desk is physical intimidation. Why else do it if not to intimidate another person into doing what you want them to do? Your definition above is also intimidation - as adults, you allowed an entire class to intimidate or ignore another student who felt threatened by this teacher's behaviour. Again, I just don't get parents...If that same teacher was found to have been sexually or physically abusing students, and that girl who had the nerve to stand up to the others in order to make a safe environment, would then be looked at as a hero, but because the kids like him, and apparently the parents are ok with his behaviour, it's ok to ignore another student? He is a bully, plain and simple, and in my district, he would be suspended and possibly fired for touching students. I am just dumbfounded that a parent is actually condoning this type of behaviour from a teacher...

A steel desk can be very loud if rattled, so sure that will get someone's attention, but why choose that method? There are better methods to utilize in a classroom, especially with impressionable grade 8 children.

YMMV, Tiger

Wow, if this is the way it is there than I am so thankful my kids attend school here. Why the need to baby these kids?? These kids are getting ready to experience the working world and they need to learn that the world does NOT revolve around them.

Umm, you can tip a child out of their chair while never touching the student.

Since you do NOT know the dynamics of the class than how can you say there are better methods?? Also just curious but what grade do you teach??

I know my 7th grader has complained about kids being rowdy in her classes and she is not the only one I know that has done this. Most parents I know do not have a problem with a rattled desk or a book slammed and shoot using balls is general fun for the kids. I see many of these teachers as keeping it interesting and if my child was so intimidated by a teacher I would address the issue with the principal/assistant principal.

Why do we expect teachers to coddle the kids?? They are paid to TEACH them and as long as they are not physically or sexually or even verbally ( my son had one teacher who was calling the kids names and I did address that because it is inappropriate) abusing the kids than I have no issues with how they get the child's attention.
 
:laughing:


But I still disagree. The correct path would be for the girl to get over herself.

I don't disagree with you- but going to see the Principal if a student thinks there is a problem is acceptable, misusing 911 is not.
 
Palo Alto is a very rich suburb so I am thinking this kid was raised to be a very special snowflake. I think she should have been suspended for abusing 911.
 
Wow, if this is the way it is there than I am so thankful my kids attend school here. Why the need to baby these kids?? These kids are getting ready to experience the working world and they need to learn that the world does NOT revolve around them.

Umm, you can tip a child out of their chair while never touching the student.

Since you do NOT know the dynamics of the class than how can you say there are better methods?? Also just curious but what grade do you teach??

I know my 7th grader has complained about kids being rowdy in her classes and she is not the only one I know that has done this. Most parents I know do not have a problem with a rattled desk or a book slammed and shoot using balls is general fun for the kids. I see many of these teachers as keeping it interesting and if my child was so intimidated by a teacher I would address the issue with the principal/assistant principal.

Why do we expect teachers to coddle the kids?? They are paid to TEACH them and as long as they are not physically or sexually or even verbally ( my son had one teacher who was calling the kids names and I did address that because it is inappropriate) abusing the kids than I have no issues with how they get the child's attention.

ITA. Both of my sons had a teacher that was verbally abusive. An entire group of parents went to the principal at once and the teacher did not return the next year (and she toned down quite a bit for the remaining of that year).

I just don't see rattling a desk as anywhere near abusive. Calling 911 was too far and away from an appropriate response and THAT should be dealt with.
 
I doubt in the slightest that the student was afraid. I think she was probably embarrassed that she was startled and decided to retaliate against the teacher.

Why do you think that?

I would like to know this as well?

Tiger

Wow, you deduced that from a short news article? The teacher couldn't possibly have done anything wrong?

Tiger

That short news article included the very important information that "The sergeant says the teacher's table-rattling startled a student and she used her cell phone to call 911. He says other students in the class weren't bothered by the teacher's actions. ". It also stated that the teacher rattled the table to get students' (plural) attention.

I think AustinTink's assessment is close, if not spot-on.
 
Would have sworn that she called 911 b/c of theft. That they'd taken her money and wouldn't give her the food she ordered nor would give her a refund. That's theft. I'm fairly certain the police like to know when someone is being robbed.



That's so awful. My 5th grade teacher had a nervous breakdown in class in front of us. Sure, the 3 stoner boys had been being a pain for months, yes they pushed and pushed at her, but still, she's a grownup and they were 11 or so... What was extra "fun" was that the 6th grade teacher retired over the summer, and the 5th grade teacher was asked to teach a combo 5th/6th grade class...same obnoxious stoner boys were in that class. We all walked on eggshells around her b/c she had scared us so badly! We talked about it at our 20 year HS reunion...that's how much it bothered us.




Could have been...

"the teacher just flipped out and slammed his fist on the table and I think there's something wrong and he's frightening me, please help."

It all depends on what her background is and what causes fear. I once went into hysterics b/c my mom's 3rd husband decided that I wasn't speaking kindly enough to my mom (he only came into our lives when I was 18, I never felt that he had ANY right to get in between the relationship between him and my mom, and I believe she felt the same b/c he NEVER did it again) and spoke sternly to me. I was 25 at the time. Hysterics for an hour. Because of my past, not only am I not *used to* having a father around, but I SERIOUSLY do not do well with men yelling at me or being stern with me AT ALL.

What you would see as normal could send me reeling, all because of our pasts and how we filter the present.



Agreed.






I am so sorry you two were abused like that. I know you guys seem to not take it seriously, but if some random person had come up and done that to you, wouldn't it have been a bad thing? Just b/c someone is a teacher doesn't give them the right to hurt you. :hug::hug:

Thanks for the compassion but I never considered it abuse. Heck, my Irish grandmother was meaner than the nuns. Here I am functioning fine years later with no trauma attached to the memory.

While I understand you had personal issues that make you respond in a certain way, just because it affects you does not make the other person wrong.

I do not see anything wrong with shaking a table to get attention. If the student was worried about a teacher the appropriate thing to do was go to the office.
 
I'd hate to be a teacher these days. You can't discipline kids at all. I'm glad most schools don't paddle anymore, but the problem is, all other discipline is unacceptable as well. You can't yell at kids. You can't even raise your voice to them. These days even detentions get parents angry because it causes inconveniences to their schedules. You can't give kids lines to write because they could get carpal tunnel syndrome. You can't take away their cell phones without mom and dad pitching a fit. You can't take away any object that the kid is misusing. Parents don't tolerate that! We can't even allow teachers to force kids to pay attention by rattling a freaking table.

I've always considered myself "in the middle" as to the issues of school discipline. I grew up in the 70s and 80s when some teachers were quite abusive. I had a teacher once ask a question in class. I didn't realize she was being sarcastic (I was only 9 and didn't realize she didn't want us to answer) and answered the question. She came over and started pounding on my head over and over again until I literally saw stars. Another girl (same class) was wearing a body brace for, I think scoliosis, and that same teacher ripped her out of her chair, dragged her to the front of the classroom, and paddled her relentlessly....all for talking during quiet time. The same teacher would also grab students by the cheeks and squeeze until she bruised them if they misbehaved.

I am very glad that we don't allow that extreme "discipline" in the classrooms these days. I can't help but to think that the reason so-called "snowflakes" have emerged in great numbers is that many of us grew up with very abusive teachers and do NOT want our kids to go through that! But there has to be a comfortable middle place where abuse doesn't happen, but that kids can be disciplined in school. When we take away all the rights of the teachers to discipline a classroom, then we also hinder the ability to teach and learn. You can't teach a class full of disruptive students and kids can't learn if they aren't paying attention. Now, thanks to this case, teachers are going to be afraid to do anything to get the attention of their students. When does it end????

I was a very anxious child and I would not have even thought of calling 911 on that teacher. On the other hand, I know of at least 10 bratty princesses in my school who would have called 911 in a nanosecond just to be a ***** and to get attention from their classmates. While I believe anything is possible (meaning that MAYBE that kid was really THAT scared), my money is on the likelihood that this girl wanted to show her butt to the teacher and get laughs from her classmates.
 
Wow, rattling a desk? What happens when she lives in a college dorms and starts hearing all sorts of strange college noises late at night? :rotfl:
 
It appears that even the girl's mother finds her to be a "snowflake."

http://sfist.com/2011/03/03/redwood_city_student_calls_911_on_t.php

Atherton Student Calls 911 On Teacher, Gets Him Suspended



An allegedly frightened student at Selby Lane School in Atherton called 911 from the girls' bathroom after a teacher freaked out on his students and dropped/threw a desk. The 13-year-old girl, Maria Prado, claims her teacher, John Haynes, got mad and started swearing at students and "throwing furniture around." Police responded to the classroom, and after "investigating" they found that Haynes had only "dropped" a desk from a few inches above the ground, in order to get students' attention (we're picturing them tittering and texting), and the desk fell on its side.

A school district trustee said that the 911 call gave him pause, and that "You don't want any student to feel in fear." The district has responded by putting Mr. Haynes on administrative leave, pending a further investigation. The student's mother, Ruby Prado, sounds like she blames her daughter for being a busybody and a wimp, and rushes to Haynes' defense, saying he's an excellent teacher, it's all been "blown out of proportion," and her daughter wouldn't be on the Honor Roll without him.

Bonus: Here's the audio of the girl's 911 call.
 
My opinion? I am so utterly sick at the way kids are coddled and babied these days. We shouldn't rattle tables because it might scare a 14 year old?

If a teenager is so fragile - and yes I will use that word - that a rattling desk prompts them to call 911, then she should not be in the general population. I do not care what the disorder of the day is, I do not care if they suffer anxiety. If it is that bad, then they need to be removed from the classroom. Because guess what? The world isn't going to cater to their issues. Desks will be rattled. Noises will be startling. A gym teacher is going to blow a whistle. People might even yell at them.

Frankly, I think this is a case of a coddled kid who has not been given tools to cope. If she was so startled, she could have gone to the principal. 911? Heck no. She wasted the 911 operator's time and police time, as well as resources. As a parent, I would be pissed off to no end if my kid pulled a stunt like this, and would be pissed at myself for letting it get that far, because it would mean I failed my kid somewhere along the way.

Thank goodness someone said it! People are offended by the term "snowflake," but it came from somewhere. I certainly don't condone the behavior of some of the teachers I had, but I think, on a whole, we have leaned too far in the other direction.

Everyone has their own "issues,' but their issues are theirs alone. It is unfair to make your problems (or your child's) everyone else's problem. It is high time we taught our children to accept responsibility for themselves and deal with their own "issues" instead of expecting the world to cater to, and make excuses for them. You may feel or believe that your child is unique or special, but I guarantee that the rest of the world does not. The sooner these children learn that the world does not revolve around them, the better. How will these children ever learn to function in the corporate world? Believe me, my boss, and no one else's either, wants to hear that I can't do my job because I have "issues." Life is not the Oprah Winfrey show, your problems are your problems, not fodder for public drama, or a "get out of jail free" card.

Now back to the original subject..... a teacher rattling a desk to get the attention of a classroom full of 14 year olds is fairly innocuous. I think this child was either overly dramatic, or had an axe to grind. If she did have "issues" that caused he to be unnaturally bothered by the rattling of the desk, then, by the age of 14, she should know enough to know how to appropriately deal with these issues. Calling 911 was totally inappropriate. There was no crime committed, and no one's life was in danger, and at 14 she knows that that is the purpose of 911. If she were that disturbed then she should have gone to guidance, or the principal, or called her parents. I have a 13 year old, and believe me had she pulled that crap as long as she lived in my home she would have never had another cell phone to use to call 911. (BTW... my 13 year old's reaction to this story was "OMG! what a drama queen")

Now if someone could book my 10 year old son's Oprah appearance I would be grateful, because I "flick" his ear when he is not paying attention. :lmao:
 
It appears that even the girl's mother finds her to be a "snowflake."

http://sfist.com/2011/03/03/redwood_city_student_calls_911_on_t.php

Atherton Student Calls 911 On Teacher, Gets Him Suspended



An allegedly frightened student at Selby Lane School in Atherton called 911 from the girls' bathroom after a teacher freaked out on his students and dropped/threw a desk. The 13-year-old girl, Maria Prado, claims her teacher, John Haynes, got mad and started swearing at students and "throwing furniture around." Police responded to the classroom, and after "investigating" they found that Haynes had only "dropped" a desk from a few inches above the ground, in order to get students' attention (we're picturing them tittering and texting), and the desk fell on its side.

A school district trustee said that the 911 call gave him pause, and that "You don't want any student to feel in fear." The district has responded by putting Mr. Haynes on administrative leave, pending a further investigation. The student's mother, Ruby Prado, sounds like she blames her daughter for being a busybody and a wimp, and rushes to Haynes' defense, saying he's an excellent teacher, it's all been "blown out of proportion," and her daughter wouldn't be on the Honor Roll without him.

Bonus: Here's the audio of the girl's 911 call.

I kinda wanna hug that mom. :worship:


And the 911 call? I listened to the whole thing and either the kid IS the world's most fragile snowflake, or she has serious anxiety issues that require professional help.
 
I am very grateful to this girls mom for proving all of us right---the girl is a wimp, and was totally in the wrong, not to mention being a little liar!

She sure sound "TERRIFIED" at the begining of the call...... Not til her "friends" are around does she start crying.
 
Wow, I've seen a lot of strawman arguments here on the DIS, but this one may take the cake. Desk rattling and sexual abuse aren't even on the same planet, let alone the same ballpark when looking at this issue. Instead of coming up with such an extreme stretch to try and prove a point, why not discuss the case as it is presented?

Not at all. If this teacher exhibits this behaviour, he could also exhibit other behaviour. Did I say this teacher is sexually abusing kids? Absolutely not, but I have seen cases here in my own board, where fear, intimidation and bullying in the classroom were being used to cover up more than just unruly kids. Now, I would never call this particular teacher a bully, as I don't know him, nor, how he runs his classroom, but as a teacher, I find his method of shoving a desk to be disrespectful to the classroom environment. If he shoves a desk, then his students should be able to as well, yet somehow, I think they would be suspended for doing that. Mutual respect is a very positive and effective way of teaching and parenting children. I know this from years of experience, and a high success rate with at-risk kids. Our school thrives on this, yet we also discipline students. Imagine, you can have both?

Wow, if this is the way it is there than I am so thankful my kids attend school here. Why the need to baby these kids?? These kids are getting ready to experience the working world and they need to learn that the world does NOT revolve around them.

Umm, you can tip a child out of their chair while never touching the student.

Since you do NOT know the dynamics of the class than how can you say there are better methods?? Also just curious but what grade do you teach??

I know my 7th grader has complained about kids being rowdy in her classes and she is not the only one I know that has done this. Most parents I know do not have a problem with a rattled desk or a book slammed and shoot using balls is general fun for the kids. I see many of these teachers as keeping it interesting and if my child was so intimidated by a teacher I would address the issue with the principal/assistant principal.

Why do we expect teachers to coddle the kids?? They are paid to TEACH them and as long as they are not physically or sexually or even verbally ( my son had one teacher who was calling the kids names and I did address that because it is inappropriate) abusing the kids than I have no issues with how they get the child's attention.

I have taught almost all grades. No need to tip a child out a seat, and it's definitely not a requirement of preparation for the working world. If my principal did that to me, he would be suspended, and sued. :thumbsup2

Thank goodness someone said it! People are offended by the term "snowflake," but it came from somewhere. I certainly don't condone the behavior of some of the teachers I had, but I think, on a whole, we have leaned too far in the other direction.

Everyone has their own "issues,' but their issues are theirs alone. It is unfair to make your problems (or your child's) everyone else's problem. It is high time we taught our children to accept responsibility for themselves and deal with their own "issues" instead of expecting the world to cater to, and make excuses for them. You may feel or believe that your child is unique or special, but I guarantee that the rest of the world does not. The sooner these children learn that the world does not revolve around them, the better. How will these children ever learn to function in the corporate world? Believe me, my boss, and no one else's either, wants to hear that I can't do my job because I have "issues." Life is not the Oprah Winfrey show, your problems are your problems, not fodder for public drama, or a "get out of jail free" card.

Now back to the original subject..... a teacher rattling a desk to get the attention of a classroom full of 14 year olds is fairly innocuous. I think this child was either overly dramatic, or had an axe to grind. If she did have "issues" that caused he to be unnaturally bothered by the rattling of the desk, then, by the age of 14, she should know enough to know how to appropriately deal with these issues. Calling 911 was totally inappropriate. There was no crime committed, and no one's life was in danger, and at 14 she knows that that is the purpose of 911. If she were that disturbed then she should have gone to guidance, or the principal, or called her parents. I have a 13 year old, and believe me had she pulled that crap as long as she lived in my home she would have never had another cell phone to use to call 911. (BTW... my 13 year old's reaction to this story was "OMG! what a drama queen")

Now if someone could book my 10 year old son's Oprah appearance I would be grateful, because I "flick" his ear when he is not paying attention. :lmao:

I'm not even sure how to respond to this post? You seem to be advocating no Special Education accommodations or modifications, but perhaps I've misunderstood you? And I'm sorry, but when a child comes to school abused or not having eaten for 4 days, as mom spent their grocery money at the casino, that is my problem. As educators, we have a duty to protect our students, and so serious problems do become our problems.

I'm really hoping I have misunderstood your post, because if I haven't, I surely hope you don't ever hold any position of responsibility with children, as you show a total lack of compassion, empathy and understanding about students in need. Perhaps you don't mean them, and if that's the case, it didn't come out in your post.

I am very grateful to this girls mom for proving all of us right---the girl is a wimp, and was totally in the wrong, not to mention being a little liar!

She sure sound "TERRIFIED" at the begining of the call...... Not til her "friends" are around does she start crying.

Seriously, you are ok with a parent calling her child a wimp? How sad...:sick:

Tiger
 
Thank goodness someone said it! People are offended by the term "snowflake," but it came from somewhere. I certainly don't condone the behavior of some of the teachers I had, but I think, on a whole, we have leaned too far in the other direction.

Everyone has their own "issues,' but their issues are theirs alone. It is unfair to make your problems (or your child's) everyone else's problem. It is high time we taught our children to accept responsibility for themselves and deal with their own "issues" instead of expecting the world to cater to, and make excuses for them. You may feel or believe that your child is unique or special, but I guarantee that the rest of the world does not. The sooner these children learn that the world does not revolve around them, the better. How will these children ever learn to function in the corporate world? Believe me, my boss, and no one else's either, wants to hear that I can't do my job because I have "issues." Life is not the Oprah Winfrey show, your problems are your problems, not fodder for public drama, or a "get out of jail free" card.

Now back to the original subject..... a teacher rattling a desk to get the attention of a classroom full of 14 year olds is fairly innocuous. I think this child was either overly dramatic, or had an axe to grind. If she did have "issues" that caused he to be unnaturally bothered by the rattling of the desk, then, by the age of 14, she should know enough to know how to appropriately deal with these issues. Calling 911 was totally inappropriate. There was no crime committed, and no one's life was in danger, and at 14 she knows that that is the purpose of 911. If she were that disturbed then she should have gone to guidance, or the principal, or called her parents. I have a 13 year old, and believe me had she pulled that crap as long as she lived in my home she would have never had another cell phone to use to call 911. (BTW... my 13 year old's reaction to this story was "OMG! what a drama queen")

Now if someone could book my 10 year old son's Oprah appearance I would be grateful, because I "flick" his ear when he is not paying attention. :lmao:

How is it catering to other kids? By asking teachers not to yell, call names, tip kids out of desk, rattle furniture forcefully, throw things at kids? That's helpful to all.

And, sorry, but yes some kids do have medical issues. Are you suggesting doing away with IEPs? You do not think teachers should make the required modifications for them?
 
I kinda wanna hug that mom. :worship:


And the 911 call? I listened to the whole thing and either the kid IS the world's most fragile snowflake, or she has serious anxiety issues that require professional help.


A lot of kids do.

But, since her mom said that, I guess we now can be pretty sure the daughter was just being a spoiled brat. Mystery solved.
 
Not at all. If this teacher exhibits this behaviour, he could also exhibit other behaviour.


OHHHHHH ok, well fantastic, based on your information here, we are now granted the right so say if any of your "at-risk" students have ever swore at their mom, they are also 100% capable of raping and murdering her....
 
A lot of kids do.

But, since her mom said that (way to go Mom!), I guess we now can be pretty sure the daughter was just being a spoiled brat. Mystery solved.

It's true that a lot of kids have extreme anxiety, sometimes general anxiety and sometimes over specific events. I had a friend who was scared to death of tornadoes and whenever the weather would get bad, she would run out of the classroom and go hide in a bathroom crying her eyes out! I can imagine that if a child came from a very abusive home, any act of anger could be scary. I was in a violent relationship and had PTSD...took years for me to not get scared when I was around angry people. So I can understand that there was the possibility that the kid was honestly that scared. But I also remember the kids at my school and some of them were really mean, even to the teachers. I can totally see some of those kids doing anything in their power to get a teacher in trouble.

It could have gone either way, and as you say...mystery solved. I hope the teacher gets to return to work quickly and I hope that girl learned a lesson. It sounded to me that the tears started whens he realized the magnitude of what she started. I think it scared her when she realize she had pushed over the first domino and no matter what she did, there were going to be a consequence.
 
OHHHHHH ok, well fantastic, based on your information here, we are now granted the right so say if any of your "at-risk" students have ever swore at their mom, they are also 100% capable of raping and murdering her....

Nope, I explained what I meant. In the cases in our board, those teachers who were exhibiting those behaviours were doing so as they were abusers. The tone of this thread and the other one, is implying that kids are spoiled and coddled, and this girl has issues, so she shouldn't be taken seriously. I can assure you that I have taught girls like this, and they were being abused.

Once you decide that it's ridiculous and can't happen, that's when it does. Kids need to know that they will be trusted by adults, but in this instance, if any of you were the principal, you more than likely would have told her to go back upstairs and keep quiet, and my point was that it has happened in my board, and those same students who were not taken seriously, were victims of abuse. It hasn't happened very often, thank goodness, but my point is that you all can't just automatically judge this girl or assume she is just a drama queen. Thank goodness there is an investigation, for both sides involved, but abusers count on the opposite happening. Adults are usually taken more seriously than kids, and that is sad.

We also have a few cases where parents are suing the board, as the principal did not do anything in regard to bullying behaviour exhibited by other students - the principal knows the bully's parents on a personal level, and they are big donators to his school. There were also several cases in our Disciplinary College of Teachers this year, where disciplinary investigations revealed intimdation and bullying by teachers towards certain students. Students weren't taken seriously by the principal, so parents went to board, and they then found enough evidence in which it was sent to disciplinary board. Each of those cases involved a mark on their teaching certificates, and all of the teachers had to take courses in proper disciplinary techniques and classroom management before returning to the classroom. Not sure what happened at the board level between the principal and superintendents, as those are private contracts, and aren't mentioned in our disciplinary case reviews.

Nowhere did I say this teacher was an abuser, but the fact remains that abusers intimidate their victims, so it's disheartening to hear that so many of you said that this girl was a drama queen and shouldn't be taken seriously. I've had students who suffered in the same respect, and they were being abused by an adult in a position of responsibility who was treated as if he could do no wrong, and the student must have a bone to pick with him. The exact same thing I saw people automatically assume on this thread, and that is sad to me.

It does and can happen, and that's all I hope people remember, Tiger
 
Tiger--I'm not saying It CAN'T happen, My father grew up in a church (in the 1950-60s) where the Priest was BELOVED by everyone in the community, but he was molesting the alter boys (my father fortunately wasn't one of them....I think he was too smart an dthe preist knew he wouldn't get away with it with him) The boys eventually told, and the parents believed them, the priest was transfered to another church (yeah...thats a reasonable consequence...)

But when looking at the facts of this story, it is very clear that this is NOT what took place. I feel that your comments are not addressing the case, they are addressing your own personal experiences. I'd hate for you to be on a Jury of my "peers" if I were ever in court for something. You need to look at the EVIDENCE provided.... The teacher had helped this student get on honor role, the other students like him and nobody felt intimidated, she went in the bathroom, LIED to thr POLICE and only started to sound mildy upset when she hear the cops actually came and she thought she was going to get in trouble. If thise teacher is such a bad man, why would the other 20 something kids in the class ALL say that he wasn't throwin desks and chairs and swearing at them?
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom