Anne Frank.

tinkerbell12

If you can be my bodyguard, I can be your long los
Joined
Aug 13, 2005
Messages
8,146
For our English class, we have to have 15 quotes on opinions and write an essay on what Anne Frank said about everyone being truly good at heart.
Her exact quote was, "[SIZE=-1]Despite everything, I believe that people are really good at heart."

If you could tell me your opinion, if you agree or disagree, and "back up" your answer, I'd love you.

Thank you so much! :goodvibes
[/SIZE]
 
I don't think it's true. Because some people just can't get rid of the evil in their heart like it says in movie. Anne Frank was an amazing girl, she was so optimistic up until around her sister's death. Basically, when she entered the camp, and watching her mother get thrown into the gas chamber..and never seeing her dad again must've been pure torture. How could any person that's "good at heart" do this to human beings, their own flesh and blood basically? Some people think she's lucky that she escaped the gas chamber and became a labor worker...but that's just dying a slow painful death! I don't even know if the guards fed them. They treated the Jewish people like the black plague just because some guy with a ******** mustache wanted to eliminate them. The Holocaust was horrible and made no sense at all to me.
 
Anne Frank was an amazing little girl, she really was. But I have to disagree with the quote. Some people are just evil and nothing else.
 
I actually agree with it.
Although some people do really bad things, if they personally think it's right, then in a way fkgjdlkj I don't know.
I'm trying to phrase this in a way so that it doesn't sound like I'm a mean-people supporter, haha.
I guess that if a person truly believes that they are doing the right thing, then to them personally, it's good. Like, obv. Hitler did very very very bad things. Theres absolutely no defending what he did, it was badbadbad. But he thought he was helping his people. So, in a way, he was good a heart, for himself personally.
I don't know.
This isn't coming out right/making sense.
 

I actually agree with it.
Although some people do really bad things, if they personally think it's right, then in a way fkgjdlkj I don't know.
I'm trying to phrase this in a way so that it doesn't sound like I'm a mean-people supporter, haha.
I guess that if a person truly believes that they are doing the right thing, then to them personally, it's good. Like, obv. Hitler did very very very bad things. Theres absolutely no defending what he did, it was badbadbad. But he thought he was helping his people. So, in a way, he was good a heart, for himself personally.
I don't know.
This isn't coming out right/making sense.
No I completely understand! Today I was watching a movie about terrorists (yeah, I know it's just a movie) and they were killing americans, because they thought it would help their own country....kwim?

In other words, yes I understand. :)
 
No I completely understand! Today I was watching a movie about terrorists (yeah, I know it's just a movie) and they were killing americans, because they thought it would help their own country....kwim?

In other words, yes I understand. :)

haha, nice, jenny gets me. (:
I was worried people would be like *** paula. The entire post I wrote sounds like vomit.

What movie was it, btw?


EDIT: it was in acronym form and dis still starred it out. :|
 
haha, nice, jenny gets me. (:
I was worried people would be like *** paula. The entire post I wrote sounds like vomit.

What movie was it, btw?


EDIT: it was in acronym form and dis still starred it out. :|
It was actually a TV show. :goodvibes: 24 on Fox.

Weird, since when is that starred out? Hmmm.
 
i think people start out as neutral.. neither good nor evil... and depending on how they grow up, the neutralness fades and leans to the side in which their development leads them to
 
Hey, we're learning about Anne Frank too :)

I have to disagree with that. Good people don't do bad things.
 
As much as I would love for that to be true. I disagree with it, some people are just evil and nothing will ever change them.
 
I wish I could believe that quote..
But some people have done things too wicked.
There's some good in them, it's just the bad outweighs the good in a lot of cases.
 
Paula, I get what you mean.

I agree with Anne Frank.
I actually had to write an essay on that quote two years ago.
And I still believe people are inherently good.

I'm in a Holocaust class at school.
And I'm bombarded daily with images, stories, things that make me have nightmares. And you think "How could good people have done that?"

But then you learn about WHY the National Socialist Party (Nazis) came to be.
And why most of these high ranking Nazi officials needed to feel like they were part of something bigger, the kinds of things that happened to them their entire lives, where they were made to feel like less than nothing, had their parents tortured in front of them, how sometimes they were abandoned by their own families...
And you sympathize with them. With what happened to them, not justifying what they did. But you can understand why they would want to lash out at others.

And then you learn about how they did what they did.
And psychologists have studied it, and the majority of people involved in the Holocaust were in this state of mind (I can't remember then name, it started with a D though...) where they had to disconnect their actions at "work"- concentration camps, labor camps, ghettos- from their home lives.

And all people have to do that to be able to perform those atrocities.
And I think they HAVE to, because people are inherently good.
If people were bad, why would they have to disconnect themselves from their murders and terrible actions, make themselves believe they were doing it for the greater good, that it was justified?
If people were bad, they could kill without any justification or reasoning.
But people can't do that.

Again, I'm not justifying ANYTHING that happened in the Holocaust, because what those people did (and didn't do- the Holocaust couldn't have occured without bystanders) was absolutely despicable, and so incredibly wrong.
But, like Anne Frank, I believe people are good.
I wouldn't be able to go on thinking that they weren't.

Sorry, that's long and jumbled... and confusing..
 
Thanks so much guys.
This is really interesting to read all your opinions.
Thanks, again.
 
She was very innocent and naive at the time.
I thought the same thing to but now I dont.
Some people are just plain mean and evil.
Example: HITLER
 
i agree, becuase it hurts me too bad to think it isn't true.

i'm sorry if that doesn't help, but i can't bring myself to say that it isn't. i've not lost all faith in humanity yet-so i can't disagree.

people have the good in them buried, but i believe that (even though it may never ever resurface again) it is really there.
 
I have to agree with those that have said that to the individual, whatever they've done that seemed to others so atrocious, was an act of goodness to them. Hitler thought he was doing good for the entire world; he truly believed that. Others believed he was doing good, as well.

The answer to the question, "Are all people good," is difficult to answer, I believe, because everyone has different definitions of good. Good is an opinion, rather than a fact, which makes it an unbalanced question.
 
i just finished reading the freedom writers diary, based on the movie. it talks about anne frank a little
 
OT but if you liked Anne Frank, you should read Rena's Promise. Truly amazing book.
 

New Posts


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom