American Idol Top 9 Idol Chatter and Idle Chatter

[Cindy B]

I think so. Isn't it Simon's favorite song?

From what I have heard it is.. that is why he hates to hear it...

He also likes Wuthering Heights (Kate Bush song), there's not much danger in too many Americans singing it though....

Here's a nice MTV article about Adam and the Broadway production of Spiderman.

http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1609202/20090414/story.jhtml

Info from mjs

 

[TruBlu]

Isn't Unchained Melody on the "forbidden" list--which aslo includes Sugar Pie Honey Bunch, most Whitney Houston songs, most Celine Dion songs and close to the entire catalog of Stevie Wonder songs.

Yep, but singing the phonebook is OK.

 

[mandy200587]

Upcoming Idols on the show:

Top 7- Jennifer Hudson
Top 6- David A
Top 5- Syesha Mercado
Top 4- Unknown
Top 3- Jordin Sparks

 

[mandy200587]

For the Jason Fans

Atlantic Records has announced the signing of singer/songwriter Jason Castro. The Texas-based tunesmith – best known as the third runner-up on the 2008 season of Fox’sAmerican Idol – is currently hard at work on his debut album, set for release later this year. Among his creative collaborators are Grammy Award-winning producer John Fields (Lifehouse, Switchfoot, Soul Asylum) and a number of acclaimed songwriters, including Kara DioGuardi (Kelly Clarkson, Jewel, Santana), Martin Terefe (Jason Mraz, KT Tunstall), Sacha Skarbek (James Blunt, Jason Mraz), Guy Chambers (Robbie Williams), and Jason Reeves (Colbie Caillat).
​

 

[damo]

I'm hearing rumours of Kris singing Falling Slowly from Once.

 

[mandy200587]

damo it needs to go in white, it's a potential spoiler.

 

[Cindy B]

I'm hearing rumours of Kris singing Falling Slowly from Once.

Is Once the movie? Falling Slowly produced a very measly result from IMDB. Once is a movie set in Ireland.

 

[Cindy B]

damo it needs to go in white, it's a potential spoiler.

But then wouldn't all the Rebel Yell stuff go as well? It's a rumor, just like the Billy Idol stuff.

 

[mandy200587]

But then wouldn't all the Rebel Yell stuff go as well? It's a rumor, just like the Billy Idol stuff.

There's a high chance that song is the song he's doing tonight. We've always posted stuff like that in white. It's just out of respect cause there have been people who don't want to know rumors or spoilers. A rumor and spoiler are almost the same thing when it comes down to it. I'm not trying to be mean I'm just trying to be considerate of everyone.

 

[Cindy B]

There's a high chance that song is the song he's doing tonight. We've always posted stuff like that in white. It's just out of respect cause there have been people who don't want to know rumors or spoilers. A rumor and spoiler are almost the same thing when it comes down to it. I'm not trying to be mean I'm just trying to be considerate of everyone.

I honestly don't see the difference. Its just a discussion. Why is there two pages on Rebel Yell --without any "issues" and suddenly another song comes up and someone has a "concern".

Personally I like conjecturing and guessing. Other people liked the list which listed the movies which had Rebel Yell. Other people liked to guess as well.

Is it you personally that doesn't like the rumors or spoilers? Is is a very small minority that likes to be suprised-- I never saw the need to hide any facts from a discussion. Just curious, because it has not been an issue before.

 

[chisnpeke]

I honestly don't see the difference. Its just a discussion. Why is there two pages on Rebel Yell --without any "issues" and suddenly another song comes up and someone has a "concern".

Personally I like conjecturing and guessing. Other people liked the list which listed the movies which had Rebel Yell. Other people liked to guess as well.

Is it you personally that doesn't like the rumors or spoilers? Is is a very small minority that likes to be suprised-- I never saw the need to hide any facts from a discussion. Just curious, because it has not been an issue before.

It should be in white because not everyone wants to know. Those who like to participate in this thread who don't want to know deserve to not know. Just because most people want to know doesn't mean everyone does.

 

[Nancy]

Vote for the Worst has now endorsed Lil Rounds...

At least they are backing the right person at this time

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxPZh4AnWyk&feature=haxa_popt00us0b

The link above is showing Simon being shocked then very nice to a lady auditioning for britans got talent.
She was AMAZING!

That was amazing. It brought tears to my eyes. Who knew that voice would come out of that woman. To be compared to Elaine Paige is a high honor.

From what I have heard it is.. that is why he hates to hear it...

He also likes Wuthering Heights (Kate Bush song), there's not much danger in too many Americans singing it though....

Here's a nice MTV article about Adam and the Broadway production of Spiderman.

http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1609202/20090414/story.jhtml

Info from mjs

My husband loves Kate Bush...my kids cringe when he plays her stuff.


So is it just songs from movies or is it theme songs from movies? Songs from movies leaves it wide open since so many songs get used in movies.

 

[mandy200587]

All I'm asking is to be respectful for those who don't want to know because this has been an issue in the past on the threads. That's it.

 

[Cindy B]

At least they are backing the right person at this time



That was amazing. It brought tears to my eyes. Who knew that voice would come out of that woman. To be compared to Elaine Paige is a high honor.



My husband loves Kate Bush...my kids cringe when he plays her stuff.


So is it just songs from movies or is it theme songs from movies? Songs from movies leaves it wide open since so many songs get used in movies.

Another Kate fan... That makes me so happy. I love KATE! There is a fantastic cumulative DVD out there with all of Kate's stuff from early years to the Aerial album. I LOVED it. I rented it from Blockbuster.

I know sometimes my kids go crazy when I play Violin too much... Babushka is one of my favorites as well. Wuthering is a fave but dare I say a bit overplayed.

And from what I have read that it is songs from contestant's favorite movie. Of course the contestant can just say that a film is a favorite just to sing it... I don't put too much stock in that.

I liked that lady from Britains got talent as well. I hope she can sing other songs just as well.

 

[Nancy]

I honestly don't see the difference. Its just a discussion. Why is there two pages on Rebel Yell --without any "issues" and suddenly another song comes up and someone has a "concern".

Personally I like conjecturing and guessing. Other people liked the list which listed the movies which had Rebel Yell. Other people liked to guess as well.

Is it you personally that doesn't like the rumors or spoilers? Is is a very small minority that likes to be suprised-- I never saw the need to hide any facts from a discussion. Just curious, because it has not been an issue before.

I prefer not to know and even when the spoilers are in white I end up peeking and then ge mad at myself for doing that.

The difference between the whole Rebel Yell discussion is that it was just a talk about the song it self and not on the fact that someone might be singing it.

I don' mind discussing the show live and having the spoilers from that..but I do like the song surprises and we've been whiting out the song spoilers since last season (or maybe even the year before, I can't remember) to be nice to those that might not want to know the songs beforehand.

 

[Cindy B]

All I'm asking is to be respectful for those who don't want to know because this has been an issue in the past on the threads. That's it.

Understand-- but you didn't answer my question-- is it you personally that wants to be suprised?

 

[mandy200587]

Understand-- but you didn't answer my question-- is it you personally that wants to be suprised?

I don't mind them but there are others that do.

 

[Nancy]

Another Kate fan... That makes me so happy. I love KATE! There is a fantastic cumulative DVD out there with all of Kate's stuff from early years to the Aerial album. I LOVED it. I rented it from Blockbuster.

I know sometimes my kids go crazy when I play Violin too much... Babushka is one of my favorites as well. Wuthering is a fave but dare I say a bit overplayed.

And from what I have read that it is songs from contestant's favorite movie. Of course the contestant can just say that a film is a favorite just to sing it... I don't put too much stock in that.

I liked that lady from Britains got talent as well. I hope she can sing other songs just as well.

I don't think she'll be rocking out but she sure can do theatrical music with the best of them. She might be able to go the way of Josh Groban too.

 

[chisnpeke]

Understand-- but you didn't answer my question-- is it you personally that wants to be suprised?

Mandy posts them so I think it's obvious she doesn't want to be surprised. She just wants to be considerate of those who do not want to know.

 

[Nancy]

I don't mind them but there are others that do.

but then I can't help but look so I try to stay away until show time once spoilers are put on here.