American Idol Top 4 Idol Chatter and Idle Chatter

[WDWRocksMySocks]

Ha, both sets of parents are too cute.

 

[dahirsh]

I like his voice when he just sings...but I really don't remember this from before. 19 year old DD said "that was really boring"

Probably because half the country missed it when the show ran long during one of the "pimp" spots people have complained endlessly about

 

[Nancy]

Not sure if I would have had Kris sing this song, but since it is one he changed up I guess I could see why he chose it. I just don't like this song all that much

 

[onelilspark]

They repeat a song they've done at the finale every year, I think.

The contestant had to pick one they did previously, the producer picks one, and the third is the "winner" song.

Thanks to both. It's been a long day. I need to pay a little more attention

In that case, I think they both picked good songs to repeat!

 

[GoofyforDisney3]

Is Simon using his reverse psychology again?

No, I think he was jealous. Paula said that Adam looked really handsome tonight and he called her beautiful. He was green with envy.

 

[ShuisFan584]

I don't remember most of the songs that Kris did this season, so I don't remember this one. He did good. But round 1 goes to Adam for sure!

 

[java]

Round 1 Adam I think.

 

[Robinrs]

No, I think he was jealous. Paula said that Adam looked really handsome tonight and he called her beautiful. He was green with envy.

I thought the same thing!!! Did you see the way he looked at her when she said he looked handsome!!

 

[Cogswel_Cogs]

ADAM DID IT EVEN BETTER THAN TEARS FOR FEARS!!!!!
ADAM IS GONNA WIN!!!!! (WELL, I WANT HIM TO!)

QUOTE:
SIMON : WHAT WERE YOU THINKING???
JASON CASTRO: I WAS THINKING MARLY MAN!
I LOVE THAT QUOTE!
I WONDER IF THEY WILL BRING ONE OF THE PEOPLE WHO AUDITIONED. REMEMBER THAT GUY WITH THE 'I AM UR BROTHER' SONG? HE WAS ONLY IN THE AUDIOTINS. I WONDER IF THERE WILL BE ANYONE ELSE THEY WILL BRING BACK... WONDERING...

 

[chisnpeke]

They repeat a song they've done at the finale every year, I think.

David Cook didn't last year. He picked The World I Know by Collective Soul and Simon said he should have picked Billie Jean or Hello.

Archie did Imagine, which he picked from before.

 

[onelilspark]

I've liked Adam all season, but for me...

Round 1: Kris.

 

[Nancy]

Probably because half the country missed it when the show ran long during one of the "pimp" spots people have complained endlessly about

No, I just really don't remember too many of his performances. I watch all the way to the end because I don't have DVR so I never miss anything

 

[Robinrs]

OmG.... for once I'm facing the tv and HOW MANY PRINTS IS RANDY WEARING????

 

[Bluestars]

Kris did very well. That is definitely one of his better performances.

 

[dahirsh]

I was joking...just forgot to put the winking and laughing smile in there...geez

me too, sorry if it didn't come off that way

 

[WDWRocksMySocks]

Hard to say who was better...they both did really well and they are both so different. Although, my bias response would be Kris -- round one!

 

[DarthKTrava]

No, I think he was jealous. Paula said that Adam looked really handsome tonight and he called her beautiful. He was green with envy.

 

[Lynn5700]

I love that Kris sang that. That was my favorite performance from Kris.I loved when he sang it earlier in the season.

 

[java]

Is Paula medicated tonite?

And simon says Kris wins round one? huh? I'm no Adam fan but even I think he sounded even better than the first time he sang it and that time was fantastic.

 

[Mean Queen]

I actually thought he did better when he sang it the first time, but I still liked his version tonight. Though I love that song anyway, it's from one of my favorite movies "Notting Hill."

Simon is doing what he did last year. He hyped David A. and David C. fan went nuts. Tonight he's hyping Kris, so Adam fans will go nuts.