American Idol Top 20 Season 9

[WDWRocksMySocks]

this is MY favorite Rolling Stones song and...i'm not digging this. idk, i don't think it works for her voice or something.

Not a fan, either. Her screeching at the end freaked my cat out. She was walking by the TV and literally just froze and looked up at the TV like, ***?!?!?!

 

[Nancy]

I liked that except for the scream at the end.

 

[chisnpeke]

I thought that was the best of tonight.

 

[WDWRocksMySocks]

Okay, I wasn't an Adam fan but seriously?! How is she comparing THAT to Adam? Psh, whatever Kara.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

I like the arrangement, but her voice sounds too "sorrowful' for the arrangement, if that makes any sense. Her tone is too low.

and that was a SCREAM....not a high note....she even cracked on it.

how about the music? i could barely hear it.

ugh i HATE it when people scream!!! she was alright in that one song a few weeks ago but PLEASE don't do it anymore!!

 

[StephyDee]

It's the best of the night so far....it's the most interesting of the performances so far.

...but that scream....oh goodness, that SCREAM!

 

[kimmar067]

this is MY favorite Rolling Stones song and...i'm not digging this. idk, i don't think it works for her voice or something.

...okay, so what version was the dawg listening to??!??! ....I gotta get me an Ipod....STAT!

 

[Nancy]

She is quickly becoming my favorite. and I need to leave now to pick up the kid....I'm sad I'll be missing Lee...hope to get back before the pimp spot.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

...okay, so what version was the dawg listening to??!??! ....I gotta get me an Ipod....STAT!

lol ipod....i feel so old, i don't even have one. i have a cheap MP3 player that olds 92 songs, that's about it. i still have cds of everything else lol

 

[mandy200587]

Umm no it was fine till that awful note. Then

 

[chisnpeke]

Okay, I wasn't an Adam fan but seriously?! How is she comparing THAT to Adam? Psh, whatever Kara.

I think because of the stairs. Adam had stairs in a performance.

 

[Pig Pen]

Well, Simon was right...it was "memorable." Actually, except for the scream it was good. She is an odd one, isn't she?

 

[StephyDee]

how about the music? i could barely hear it.

ugh i HATE it when people scream!!! she was alright in that one song a few weeks ago but PLEASE don't do it anymore!!

Well, the intro for the song was creative. Never thought of that style for the song really.

and I know what you mean. If people thought Adam screamed last season, they can't say that now. THIS was truly a scream. Like, ew.

 

[Nancy]

Okay, I wasn't an Adam fan but seriously?! How is she comparing THAT to Adam? Psh, whatever Kara.

I hated Adam and she is no where like Adam.


And I agree...please don't scream, not needed and really makes me cringe.

 

[Robinrs]

I really like Siobhan, she is strange, she's really out there, but I like her!

Her little stick legs look a little strange, though...

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

i'm going to say it again.........i miss David Cook........

 

[GoofyforDisney3]

I agree with Simon that it was a risk, Tim is on too rocky ground to be taking risks.

Sorry, I have to keep picturing him in his swim trunks to like him...

Yes, I'm shallow and a Cougar, is anyone SURPRISED????

I keep thinking the same thing.

 

[WDWRocksMySocks]

lol ipod....i feel so old, i don't even have one. i have a cheap MP3 player that olds 92 songs, that's about it. i still have cds of everything else lol

I was like that, too, until DH got me a new car stereo that had a USB port. I got an iPod and it's the most AMAZING thing to have in the car. I love not having to juggle w/ CD changing. I felt so modern!

 

[kimmar067]

I think because of the stairs. Adam had stairs in a performance.

...and a 'good' scream.....

 

[charming23]

Okay, I wasn't an Adam fan but seriously?! How is she comparing THAT to Adam? Psh, whatever Kara.

I am an Adam fan and was insulted. I am sorry that was not hitting a note at the end it was screaming, kind of reminded me of Danny's scream at the end of "Dream on" during the top 4.