American Idol Thread

[happygirl]

I have never heard of Natasha?? and why in God's green earth did she hug and snuggle with David A when David C was right there

 

[happygirl]

That call for Simon was cute lol, he was blushing that was time I had seen him blush

 

[happygirl]

aww poor Brooke,

 

[Caropooh]

The cuts are always so much harder at this stage. Poor Brooke.

 

[happygirl]

Does anyone know what the theme is for next week??

 

[bicker]

Hopefully, they get to sing whatever they want next week.

Then the week after, I think, is the "you pick one, judges pick one, and fans pick one" week.

 

[suzimar57]

brooke really took it hard....

 

[bicker]

That's not surprising, given what we've come to know about Brooke.

 

[damo]

The theme is top 500 from the Rock and Roll Hall of fame or something like that.

 

[bicker]

You've got to be kidding me. ANOTHER OLDIES WEEK???? What is wrong with Nigel????????????

I can see it now, David Archuleta singing the Supremes. Ugh.

 

[golfgal]

You've got to be kidding me. ANOTHER OLDIES WEEK???? What is wrong with Nigel????????????

I can see it now, David Archuleta singing the Supremes. Ugh.

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame?? I think it is more on the lines of The Rolling Stones, etc.

 

[macraven]

hey, this might be a good week when you stop and think about it....

i'm looking forward to it.

 

[Robinrs]

This is my wish for the bottom two

 

[Robinrs]

I have never heard of Natasha?? and why in God's green earth did she hug and snuggle with David A when David C was right there

She reported that she's in a very committed relationship.. I don't think the boyfriend would mind her cuddling with Archie, but might be if she hugged up with Cook..

 

[Chattyaholic]

I knew Brooke's days were numbered but I was really hoping Syesha would go before her, darn it!

Didn't care for Neil Diamond's new song. I wish he would have sang a mix of his popular ones instead. And who in the heck is Natasha whatever-her-last-name-is?? Thank goodness for fast forward!!

I'm hoping it comes down to the two David's, with David A. winning. I don't like David A. but want him to win so he can be A.I.'s puppet and record what they want him to, while David C. can do his own thing and come out with a super-great in a few months!!!

 

[Jennasis]

No bombshell last night. I think most of us thought that Brooke's time was up. When she was sobbing at Ryan and Syesha it made me wonder two things 1)she was SO upset...was it the weight of the competition or was she upset cause she honestly thought she had a shot at the title? I hope the former....and 2) WHY do they make the "bootee" sing at the end of the show??

On to Rock and Roll Hall of Fame week! SO many awesome badns and artists to choose from. Certainly not an oldies week by any stretch..Madonna, REM, Van HAlen, U2, Prince....

I cannot wait!

 

[bicker]

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame?? I think it is more on the lines of The Rolling Stones, etc.

Nope: The Supremes are definitely in the Hall:

The Supremes

Induction Year: 1988

Induction Category: Performer

http://www.rockhall.com/inductee/the-supremes

The Rolling Stones are there, as well, of course: Which one of the two do you think Mr. Archuleta would choose to sing?

 

[princessesrule4]

No bombshell last night. I think most of us thought that Brooke's time was up. When she was sobbing at Ryan and Syesha it made me wonder two things 1)she was SO upset...was it the weight of the competition or was she upset cause she honestly thought she had a shot at the title? I hope the former....and 2) WHY do they make the "bootee" sing at the end of the show??

On to Rock and Roll Hall of Fame week! SO many awesome badns and artists to choose from. Certainly not an oldies week by any stretch..Madonna, REM, Van HAlen, U2, Prince....

I cannot wait!

i knew it was coming for Brooke but boy, she took it hard. I felt bad for her. I was surprised at the very end when she went to the back of the stage by herself . Usually, the one who just got kicked off hugs and gets consoled by the other Idols. Made me wonder....
I can tell you that I would have gone straight to the arms of D.C. for a little consoling!

 

[bicker]

I think you need to look at who's left. Brooke has been the mommy, for most of the finals. Who's going to be her mommy from within that group? Amanda or Carly, perhaps, but they're gone.

 

[Jennasis]

Aside from her messing up the intro of the final song, did anything else interesting happen at the end? My stupid new DVR cut off right after she got to her first "I am I said" chorus.