American Idol Season 7 ~ The Top 12 and better!~

Status
Not open for further replies.
I can't even remember which one David Cook is.

david_c.jpg

Helloooooo, is it ME you're looking for???​
 
Okay.....now I feel ANCIENT!

Who would NOT know the Beatles???:confused: They managed the 60s, 70s and 80s so the Beatles should be a breeze!


That's the problem with doing themes based on decades and artists that were popular 20 years before most of these "kids" were born. I think this is why we see them do so many songs that are just plain 'ol duds and those of us of "advanced age" are sitting at home screaming at the tv. We know that there are much better 60's, 70's and 80's songs out there and we sit there scratching our heads when they get on stage and sing "Moon River" or yet another Celine, Whitney, Mariah, etc. song. It's frustrating.

I'm sure the contestants get the list of songs and the first thing they do is look for one they recognize... whether it fits their singing capabilities or not. This is why we constantly hear "Dog... that was not a good song choice.... That didn't suit your voice at all" Ugh.

If they had to do themes, I'd rather they did musical genres (though, no BIG BAND :lmao: that was brutal). Honestly though, I would prefer that they be allowed to just sing the style of music that they want their career to be based on so we can see who they are as an artist.

Just my two cents.
Mary
 
I'm not a fan at all. I might have to hit the mute button when she's performing. :rolleyes:

This is why I LOVE my DVR. I will be fast forwarding through all the mentors that I can't stand to watch, especially the aforementioned one. I can't watch regular tv anymore, commercial breaks drive me crazy now.
 
That's the problem with doing themes based on decades and artists that were popular 20 years before most of these "kids" were born.


I'm only 21 and I don't know a single person who doesn't know the Beatles music. My parents are huge fans of what's now "classic rock" and I grew up with Pink Floyd, The Who, Led Zeppelin, The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, Fleetwood Mac, Steve Miller Band, etc and those are all HUGE names in music. I honestly don't have a single friend who doesn't know that stuff and I find it hard to believe, and really weird, that these people are getting into the music industry yet they know nothing about one of the biggest names in the history of music! :confused3 It's not an age thing, it's a "half the people on the show are clueless" thing :lmao:

I do LOOVVEEEE this season, though! I haven't been so into it since season 2 when I loved Clay :rotfl: My top 3 this season (David C :lovestruc , Michael and Jason, in that order) are AMAAAZZZINNNGGG and my favorite ever on this show and I think I'm a little obsessed :lmao: I already set up season passes on my Tivo for American Idol Extra on Fox Reality and Idol Chatter on TV Guide Network. I'm loving this season!
 
This is why I LOVE my DVR. I will be fast forwarding through all the mentors that I can't stand to watch, especially the aforementioned one. I can't watch regular tv anymore, commercial breaks drive me crazy now.
My DVR won't fast forward live TV. :headache: I might have to record that show and watch it at a later time.

Robin ~ You crack me up! :lmao:
 
Had to join the thread! :)
So far I am more of a fan of the guys, as usual ;)
David C. is my favorite.
I would LOVE to see Jason get rid of the dreads, but doubt that will happen.
 
David C. is also my favorite. I'm glad to see so many on this thread like him too!

Hope that means he'll be sticking around for awhile.
 
I'm only 21 and I don't know a single person who doesn't know the Beatles music. My parents are huge fans of what's now "classic rock" and I grew up with Pink Floyd, The Who, Led Zeppelin, The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, Fleetwood Mac, Steve Miller Band, etc and those are all HUGE names in music. I honestly don't have a single friend who doesn't know that stuff and I find it hard to believe, and really weird, that these people are getting into the music industry yet they know nothing about one of the biggest names in the history of music! :confused3 It's not an age thing, it's a "half the people on the show are clueless" thing.

I'm glad to hear that, babieemelly... my son is 15 and HE knows these songs! I wonder if the spokesperson just said that just the heck of it...??? :confused:


This is why I LOVE my DVR. I will be fast forwarding through all the mentors that I can't stand to watch, especially the aforementioned one. I can't watch regular tv anymore, commercial breaks drive me crazy now.

I can't stand it either, and commercials are my JOB!! :lmao: I zoom right thru them and David A's "aw shucks" speech every week... :rolleyes:

My DVR won't fast forward live TV. I might have to record that show and watch it at a later time.

None of them do, the TV industry wouldn't make a DIME if they did. What you can do... like I do.. is start taping about 5 minutes before the show comes on and watch the show from the DVR instead of the actual show. Most breaks are about 4 mins long. That way you just about live and you can still FF thru the breaks.

Don't tell anyone I told you that.... :laughing:
 
I'm only 21 and I don't know a single person who doesn't know the Beatles music. My parents are huge fans of what's now "classic rock" and I grew up with Pink Floyd, The Who, Led Zeppelin, The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, Fleetwood Mac, Steve Miller Band, etc and those are all HUGE names in music. I honestly don't have a single friend who doesn't know that stuff and I find it hard to believe, and really weird, that these people are getting into the music industry yet they know nothing about one of the biggest names in the history of music! :confused3 It's not an age thing, it's a "half the people on the show are clueless" thing.

I'm glad to hear that, babieemelly... my son is 15 and HE knows these songs! I wonder if the spokesperson just said that just the heck of it...??? :confused:


This is why I LOVE my DVR. I will be fast forwarding through all the mentors that I can't stand to watch, especially the aforementioned one. I can't watch regular tv anymore, commercial breaks drive me crazy now.

I can't stand it either, and commercials are my JOB!! :lmao: I zoom right thru them and David A's "aw shucks" speech every week... :rolleyes:

My DVR won't fast forward live TV. I might have to record that show and watch it at a later time.

None of them do, the TV industry wouldn't make a DIME if they did. What you can do... like I do.. is start taping about 5 minutes before the show comes on and watch the show from the DVR instead of the actual show. Most breaks are about 4 mins long. That way you just about live and you can still FF thru the breaks.

Don't tell anyone I told you that.... :laughing:
 
I do LOOVVEEEE this season, though! I haven't been so into it since season 2 when I loved Clay :rotfl: My top 3 this season (David C :lovestruc , Michael and Jason, in that order) are AMAAAZZZINNNGGG and my favorite ever on this show and I think I'm a little obsessed :lmao: I already set up season passes on my Tivo for American Idol Extra on Fox Reality and Idol Chatter on TV Guide Network. I'm loving this season!

I totally agree with your top 3.

David C. :lovestruc :faint: (even if he is young enough to be my um...much younger brother!)

Johns kind of bothered me until I heard a song from his previous band. I then realized the guy CAN sing even if I had not been bowled over by him on the show so far.

I like Castro but there is something about the eye brows when he sings that makes me cringe a bit. And the dreads. :scared: But he is easily my next favorite of the guys.


I used to love Clay too. :laughing:
 
I totally agree with your top 3.

David C. :lovestruc :faint: (even if he is young enough to be my um...much younger brother!)

Johns kind of bothered me until I heard a song from his previous band. I then realized the guy CAN sing even if I had not been bowled over by him on the show so far.

I like Castro but there is something about the eye brows when he sings that makes me cringe a bit. And the dreads. :scared: But he is easily my next favorite of the guys.


I used to love Clay too. :laughing:

:lmao: Much younger brother works! He's CUTE :lovestruc He's not even typically cute but I've always had weird taste :rotfl2: I loved him from the beginning but after last weeks performance I was just :worship: Love that guy! :love:

Michael Johns is awesome but I don't think it has that much to do with his singing. I do LOVE his voice, but what puts him over the edge for me is his stage presence... and he's also ridiculously gorgeous :love: They have an insanely good looking group of boys this season ;)

Jason has a very singer/songwriter appeal... he seems very "real" and I love that. But you're right... his eyes are gorgeous but his eyebrows are so perfectly groomed and pointy that when he raises them as he sings it just looks funny :rotfl2:

And Clay was ROBBED that season!
 
My DVR won't fast forward live TV. :headache: I might have to record that show and watch it at a later time.

Robin ~ You crack me up! :lmao:

Mine doesn't either. I tape it while I am doing other stuff (getting the kids to bed, etc.) then I watch it. Sorry, I should have clarified that.
 
david_c.jpg

Helloooooo, is it ME you're looking for???​


I think he is even better looking than that when he sings. (that crooked smile, that angry look when he sang "or is someone lovin you").

Since the try-outs last summer, I think he looks like he lost some "beer weight" :rotfl:, cut the scruff and tried to make his thinning hair seem kind of legit.

Of course, the fact that I know any of this scares me. Although I thought I :love: some of the contestants in the past, I never really stalked any like David C. :scared1: And yeah, I'm old enough to be his mama!
 
I'm only 21 and I don't know a single person who doesn't know the Beatles music. My parents are huge fans of what's now "classic rock" and I grew up with Pink Floyd, The Who, Led Zeppelin, The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, Fleetwood Mac, Steve Miller Band, etc and those are all HUGE names in music. I honestly don't have a single friend who doesn't know that stuff and I find it hard to believe, and really weird, that these people are getting into the music industry yet they know nothing about one of the biggest names in the history of music! :confused3 It's not an age thing, it's a "half the people on the show are clueless" thing :lmao:

I do LOOVVEEEE this season, though! I haven't been so into it since season 2 when I loved Clay :rotfl: My top 3 this season (David C :lovestruc , Michael and Jason, in that order) are AMAAAZZZINNNGGG and my favorite ever on this show and I think I'm a little obsessed :lmao: I already set up season passes on my Tivo for American Idol Extra on Fox Reality and Idol Chatter on TV Guide Network. I'm loving this season!

My kids know all of the classic stuff too and are younger than most of the contestants as well. I think that Kristy and Cheeze will have the hardest time this week.
 
Won't be the same around here until Robinrs, dolphindan, Nancy, Tammie et al check in...

These days I like Jason Castro. That kid REALLY understands lyrics and the stories behind songs - he's smart. Many of this year's crop...ehhhh...they sing pretty (sometimes) but ignore the WORDS, they grin like idiots on deep/sad/melancholy songs.

agnes!

I second that!!!
 
The OLDEST person up there is young enough to be MY CHILD!! :lmao: Heck, I'm expecting Dateline at my door any minute now!! :scared:

1184367762037.jpg

Uh, Robin.... my name is Chris Hansen, can I talk to you for a minute??​
 
I think he is even better looking than that when he sings. (that crooked smile, that angry look when he sang "or is someone lovin you").

Since the try-outs last summer, I think he looks like he lost some "beer weight" :rotfl:, cut the scruff and tried to make his thinning hair seem kind of legit.

Of course, the fact that I know any of this scares me. Although I thought I :love: some of the contestants in the past, I never really stalked any like David C. :scared1: And yeah, I'm old enough to be his mama!

:lmao: :lmao: I love it! People make fun of the judges saying "this is the best season ever" but we're all here stalking the contestants and analyzing everything they do :rotfl2: :rotfl2: I didn't realize that the auditions were so long ago... David does look thinner. But I've never liked guys who were all cut and muscley and in perfect shape so it's cute that he's still a little chunkier :lmao: :lmao: I actually can't wait for the tour this season.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom