American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread**

[Fan2CSkr]

He ended better than he started but not sure thats saying much.

 

[Nancy]

That's the most animated I've seen him when singing.

Wasn't crazy about it though.

 

[Stephieann]

LOL did you see simon make fun of paula.... i just love simon!!!!

 

[J.Cooper]

Kevin can go home now.............

Absolutely! Bye-Bye Kevin

 

[Poohbear123]

OMG is right! Moved me? WHAT is Paula SMOKING? WHAT? Is SIMON SMOKING??? What are they SMOKING together???

 

[Stephieann]

i had a feeling kelly would sing patsy cline......right up her ally

 

[Nancy]

Kellie is singing Patsy Cline....sorry but NO ONE can sing Patsy...especially NOT Kellie.

 

[Shugardrawers]

I love Chris, I think they should just give him the prize now. But why is it that Chris "knows who he is and refuses to compromise" whereas other contestants need to get out of their comfort zone and try something new??

 

[Poohbear123]

Kellie is singing Patsy Cline....sorry but NO ONE can sing Patsy...especially NOT Kellie.

She most likely NEVER Heard of Patsy Cline, like she never heard of SALMON before!

 

[Fan2CSkr]

OMG is right! Moved me? WHAT is Paula SMOKING? WHAT? Is SIMON SMOKING??? What are they SMOKING together???

I was thinking that same thing. I'm surprised with some of the comments from them tonight. Paula falls all over herself with her comments and its embarassing.

 

[J.Cooper]

OMG is right! Moved me? WHAT is Paula SMOKING? WHAT? Is SIMON SMOKING??? What are they SMOKING together???

I was thinking the same thing . Paula said she got chills? Yeah from the drugs rotfl:! Not Elliott. He wasn't good at all. I've seen better.

 

[Nancy]

I love Chris, I think they should just give him the prize now. But why is it that Chris "knows who he is and refuses to compromise" whereas other contestants need to get out of their comfort zone and try something new??

I honestly hope Chris doesn't win...that way he CAN go out and be himself and not fall into the AI machine.

 

[Philadisney]

I love Chris, I think they should just give him the prize now. But why is it that Chris "knows who he is and refuses to compromise" whereas other contestants need to get out of their comfort zone and try something new??

a lot of people have commented on that and i was thinking about it tonight, i think maybe what's going on is that the judges feel chris has found what he is GREAT at singing, whereas other contestants are COMFORTABLE with singing a certain style but maybe they aren't great at it yet, and need to explore other styles of performing...comfortable doesn't mean good....just my guess

 

[Stephieann]

I was thinking the same thing . Paula said she got chills? Yeah from the drugs rotfl:! Not Elliott. He wasn't good at all. I've seen better.

that is what i was thinking!!!

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Are ya KIDDING me----Barry Manilow never heard of Walkin' After Midnight/Patsy cline---seriously!!!

Very surprised at that.

don't know why--but just surprised.

 

[Poohbear123]

Walking after midnight, I KNOW that song, and Barry hasn't??? WHAT is HE smoking?????

 

[Planogirl]

Yes he was...I cant believe anyone would think Bucky was any better than Kevin!

I do. I think that Bucky sounded off tonight but Kevin was like painful to me. But to each their own.

 

[Stephieann]

they must have had one big smoke fest ...

 

[Poohbear123]

Not bad, not bad at all.....

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

I like leann rimes singing patsy better than this.

Not too bad--but not the right voice to really sing it though.