American Idol, Season 5 Official Discussion Thread Part 2

Mickey's sunshine · Apr 25, 2006

Man I just can not stand her, the ditzy routine has to end....please!!!

Paula is speechless.....wow.

MeanLaureen · Apr 25, 2006

Holy crap, when Paula disses you, you know you're bad..ROTF

Poohbear123 · Apr 25, 2006

WDWLVR said:
Kellie - don't like the hair at all and the make up doesn't suit her either. I didn't like her singing at all. Just kind of blah for me.

Paula should be crying after that performance. :rolleyes:

Yes SIMON!

Mickey's sunshine · Apr 25, 2006

tears for another reason :lmao:

RyMickey · Apr 25, 2006

Did Paula just say someone shouldn't be in the competition?!?!?!? And did I just agree with Paula?!?!?!?!?

Poohbear123 · Apr 25, 2006

Are they saving MY Taylor for last?? :rolleyes2

*NikkiBell* · Apr 25, 2006

Okay, that was just brutal. Kelly needs to get the boot!

MeanLaureen · Apr 25, 2006

Poohbear123 said:
Are they saving MY Taylor for last??

second from last. Chris is last

Mickey's sunshine · Apr 25, 2006

Hi Faith-y-Pooh! :wave:

Poohbear123 · Apr 25, 2006

Mickey's sunshine said:
tears for another reason

Hey Christine, 21 more days till WDW! :thumbsup2

luv2nascar · Apr 25, 2006

My dd just said she made steak and hotdogs out of that song. She butchered it. :rotfl2:

Poohbear123 · Apr 25, 2006

Only YOU can call me that Christine! :lmao:

Mickey's sunshine · Apr 25, 2006

Poohbear123 said:
Hey Christine, 21 more days till WDW!

WOOOOOOOOHOOOOOOOOOO!!!! :Pinkbounc

mickeymousemom · Apr 25, 2006

I liked Katherine...yes the song may have been a bit big for her, but I think she carried it fairly well.

Elliot sang.....I melted

Kellie sang...
....and now I have 17 dogs on my front porch :rolleyes:

Poohbear123 · Apr 25, 2006

Go Paris, they clapped for her! :thumbsup2

Mickey's sunshine · Apr 25, 2006

luv2nascar said:
My dd just said she made steak and hotdogs out of that song. She butchered it.

That is great!! Tell you DD, well done!!

Poohbear123 · Apr 25, 2006

Kinda flat, she is nervous....Come on Paris!

jaimee1024 · Apr 25, 2006

Just goes to show that different people have different taste. I know that Elliott has a great voice and I want him to do well, but I don't care for his style of singing and would probably never buy his music. Katherine on the other hand...I would definitely buy her CD.

Paula is getting more and more bizarre each week. UGH!

Listening to Paris...ugh...again, not a style of singing that I enjoy.

Shugardrawers · Apr 25, 2006

Paris: yaaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwwwwwwwwwwwnnnnnnnnn

Poohbear123 · Apr 25, 2006

Go Paris you can DO IT!!!

American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread** Part 2

<font color=darkgreen>Had a blast at MGM's Super S

<font color=purple>Slam Dancer Extraordinaire<br><

<font color=CCCC00>Will travel without lipstick<br

<font color=darkgreen>Had a blast at MGM's Super S

Disney Freak

<font color=CCCC00>Will travel without lipstick<br

Livin’ that DVC & AP life!

<font color=purple>Slam Dancer Extraordinaire<br><

<font color=darkgreen>Had a blast at MGM's Super S

<font color=CCCC00>Will travel without lipstick<br

<font color=purple>You're a wizard Harry. And a th

<font color=CCCC00>Will travel without lipstick<br

<font color=darkgreen>Had a blast at MGM's Super S

Missing: Three tags last seen in this space. Larg

<font color=CCCC00>Will travel without lipstick<br

<font color=darkgreen>Had a blast at MGM's Super S

<font color=CCCC00>Will travel without lipstick<br

Mouseketeer

<font color=teal><b>Ovarian Cancer Survivor!<br><f

<font color=CCCC00>Will travel without lipstick<br

American Idol, Season 5 Official Discussion Thread Part 2