American Idol: Season 11 OFFICIAL thread!

[Robinrs]

I'm so over her (and Beyonce too for that matter).

What Jimmy said is MORE proof they planted her. She had a big following on YouTube before she showed up at the "audition"... like she had to "audition".

I realize NOW why they didn't have a female soul singer in the bunch, they didn't want any competition for Baby Beyonce. It bugs the HELL out of me.

 

[TLSnell1981]

Well, so far..I'm liking tonight. Skylar, Colton, Elise/Phillip..

 

[Nancy]

What Jimmy said is MORE proof they planted her. She had a big following on YouTube before she showed up at the "audition"... like she had to "audition".

I realize NOW why they didn't have a female soul singer in the bunch, they didn't want any competition for Baby Beyonce. It bugs the HELL out of me.

I totally missed what he said!


She is just too studied and perfect acting for me. I still just think that she spends hours standing in front of the mirror practicing her facial expressions and hand movements to make sure they work with the song. Choreography is one thing...studied movements is a whole other thing.

 

[Mean Queen]

I'm so over her (and Beyonce too for that matter).

Not really a fan of Jessica or BB Cheese.

I did like Joshua tonight.

 

[ugadog99]

LOVE Bruno Mars and LOVE Joshua! My favorite of the night...by far!

 

[Nancy]

Way to go Josh!

 

[Robinrs]

Go birthday guy!!

 

[FINFAN]

AAAAWWWWWYYEEEAAAHHHHHH Joshua! LOVED him singing this! If he coulda pulled oof the James Brown slide it would have been Da Bomb!

 

[DarthKTrava]

This was one of Josh's best performances. He just sang it rather than trying to throw screams and gospel in to it.

 

[Robinrs]

AAAAWWWWWYYEEEAAAHHHHHH Joshua! LOVED him singing this! If he coulda pulled oof the James Brown slide it would have been Da Bomb!

It was totally JB~~ loooooved it.

 

[Robinrs]

I totally missed what he said!


She is just too studied and perfect acting for me. I still just think that she spends hours standing in front of the mirror practicing her facial expressions and hand movements to make sure they work with the song. Choreography is one thing...studied movements is a whole other thing.

Jimmy was talking about how much Akon wanted to "steal her". ugh.

 

[Carriemel]

Are they SURE Colton and Skylar aren't dating??????? Wow...


And is Randy Jackson watching the same show we are??????

 

[Nancy]

Are they SURE Colton and Skylar aren't dating??????? Wow...


And is Randy Jackson watching the same show we are??????

Me thinks they doth protest too much.


I wasn't a huge fan of them doing that song. Skylar sounded OK but I think she was over singing the chorus so she got too loud and the notes were a little . Colton started out good...but he got drowned out by Skylar too much.

 

[Robinrs]

Are they SURE Colton and Skylar aren't dating??????? Wow...

The thought makes me ill...

 

[Mean Queen]

Enough of trying to pair up the singers. I do not think in any way that either Phil and Elise or Colton and Skylar are a pair. Stop trying to create another Casey/Haley pairing.

 

[FINFAN]

Skylar sounded a bit harsh to me on it...not bad or anything, but just not soft or vulnerable enough. That said, when the judges were beaming over Elise in their duet, I preffered PP~ go figure.
Now Hollie doing Pink..really not sure how this is gonna go......maybe she has a Joshua moment here?

 

[Mean Queen]

Not normally a Hollie fan but I do love Pink and think she's doing a great job with this song.

 

[Mean Queen]

Skylar sounded a bit harsh to me on it...not bad or anything, but just not soft or vulnerable enough. That said, when the judges were beaming over Elise in their duet, I preffered PP~ go figure.
Now Hollie doing Pink..really not sure how this is gonna go......maybe she has a Joshua moment here?

Me too. I thought it was too high for Elise. She's better when she's singing low.

 

[Nancy]

Not normally a Hollie fan but I do love Pink and think she's doing a great job with this song.

I think she is doing good..not as spunky as Pink..but I don't think Hollie would be able to pull off that attitude.

 

[Robinrs]

Not normally a Hollie fan but I do love Pink and think she's doing a great job with this song.

Wow, it was the first time I really liked her and it is SOOOO obvious they had their "get Hollie the heck out of here" notes memorized.

God forBID someone interfere with their CHOSEN ONE.

hate HATE HAAATE the duets!!! I understand more than most that they need to streeeeeetch the show to make advertiser dollars but this is ridiculous. And the interviews beforehand...Elise sounded like she'd rather have a root canal than sing with Philip and WHO THE HECK thought that Colton and Skyler were a couple????

Excuse me, I threw up in my mouth...

Did like the skit with Joshua and Hollie... and whatshername.. It explained why he hugged her and DISSED Heejun when they were in the bottom three a few weeks back. No joke, he dissed him like a TRUE QUEEN! Bumped shoulder and all!

I thought the show was pretty okay last night, and that's about the best I can ever give it.

Top for me:

Joshua
Hollie
Elise

Middle:
Colton
Jessica
Skyler

Bottom:
Philip

I love Philip but last night was the last time I want to hear that same ol' song. Time to do something different, guy!!